Lets suppose if a Referendum is held in Kashmir, what would be the likely outcome???

[M.SAAD]

Okay calm your tits down, its just a hypothetical question, no need to change it into a indo pak debate.


'Lets assume' is the key word here..


Lets assume for a second, if indeed somehow a referendum is held in Kashmir, and Kashmiris will be asked to decide their fate and given 3 option what would they choose???

Would they?


1) Decide to Join Pakistan

2) Decide to remain with India, or Officially Join India..

3) Decide to form a separate autonomous state.



I'm not too sure about it.. What do you think?? both Pakistan and India are in Huge risk of losing their sides of the Kashmir to be honest if a UN based referendum is held there..


And what would the Azad Kashmiri people choose???

 

[M.SAAD]

Anyone from Kashmir who would like to answer this question?? Also why'd Pakistan want to risk losing its side of the Kashmir too in case of a referendum ? how'd it benefit Pakistan?? Pakistan would shrink even more.

 

[Khalid Newazi]

Kashmir becomes part of Bangladesh.

 

[WAR-rior]

Question is which part of Kashmir? Only the valley or Jammu included or Leh Ladhak too included?

Different scenarios have different results.

Make ur question more organised and logical. Thanks.

 

[volcano]

If you do it now, only kashmir will join. But if referendum is after 2 years punjab and sindh will also join(if we are ready to take it).

 

[DV RULES]

There should be no referendum until removal of Hindu settlements from 1948

 

[HariPrasad]

Okay calm your tits down, its just a hypothetical question, no need to change it into a indo pak debate.


'Lets assume' is the key word here..


Lets assume for a second, if indeed somehow a referendum is held in Kashmir, and Kashmiris will be asked to decide their fate and given 3 option what would they choose???

Would they?


1) Decide to Join Pakistan

2) Decide to remain with India, or Officially Join India..

3) Decide to form a separate autonomous state.



I'm not too sure about it.. What do you think?? both Pakistan and India are in Huge risk of losing their sides of the Kashmir to be honest if a UN based referendum is held there..


And what would the Azad Kashmiri people choose???

One pakistan anchor quoting an islamic country survey claimed that pakistan has only 1.5% support in Indian occupied kashmir. Video is there on Youtube

 

[M.SAAD]

Question is which part of Kashmir? Only the valley or Jammu included or Leh Ladhak too included?

Different scenarios have different results.

Make ur question more organised and logical. Thanks.

And what would be the results of those different scenarios??

 

[Kompromat]

They will opt for an independent state which is fine by me.

 

[Bornubus]

Let me Break it Down



Valley - Pakistan/Independent Kashmir

(though large % would vote for India too)

Kargil/Ladakh - India

Jammu - India

But there is no point of referendum unless the Artificial Demography of Kashmir is rectify by rehabilitating Kashmiri Pandits which is Going on.

 

[WAR-rior]

And what would be the results of those different scenarios??

If its only Srinagar then they mite want to join Pakistan but again it wud be 50-50 as Hurriat support is not thruout Srinagar.

If its outside Srinagar but only the Kashmir Valley, there it wud be a fight between getting independent vs staying part of India.

If its including Jammu and Ladakh then its high majority being INTERGRAL Part of India with taking away the SPECIAL STATUS of J&K.

Let me Break it Down



Valley - Pakistan/Independent Kashmir (though large % would vote for India too)

Kargil/Ladakh - India

Jammu - India

But there is no point of referendum unless the Artificial Demography of Kashmir is rectify by rehabilitating Kashmiri Pandits which is Going on.

Valley Guy are in favor of independence. ONly some mohallas in Srinagar are chamchas of Gillani who want to be part of Pakistan.
@SarthakGanguly

 

[M.SAAD]

If its only Srinagar then they mite want to join Pakistan but again it wud be 50-50 as Hurriat support is not thruout Srinagar.

If its outside Srinagar but only the Kashmir Valley, there it wud be a fight between getting independent vs staying part of India.

If its including Jammu and Ladakh then its high majority being INTERGRAL Part of India with taking away the SPECIAL STATUS of J&K.


Valley Guy are in favor of independence. ONly some mohallas in Srinagar are chamchas of Gillani who want to be part of Pakistan.
@SarthakGanguly

What is Pakistan hoping to achieve then???

 

[Bornubus]

If its only Srinagar then they mite want to join Pakistan but again it wud be 50-50 as Hurriat support is not thruout Srinagar.

If its outside Srinagar but only the Kashmir Valley, there it wud be a fight between getting independent vs staying part of India.

If its including Jammu and Ladakh then its high majority being INTERGRAL Part of India with taking away the SPECIAL STATUS of J&K.


Valley Guy are in favor of independence. ONly some mohallas in Srinagar are chamchas of Gillani who want to be part of Pakistan.
@SarthakGanguly

Those who are in Administration,Army and police would opt for India for sure the rest i don't care.

 

[SarthakGanguly]

50 pc for India
5 pc for Pakistan
5 pc undecided
30 pc autonomous state
10 pc independent Islamic riyasat

What is Pakistan hoping to achieve then???

Ummid pe duniya tiki h.

 

[Bornubus]

50 pc for India
5 pc for Pakistan
5 pc undecided
30 pc autonomous state
10 pc independent Islamic riyasat


Ummid pe duniya tiki h.

Nijam e Mustafa led by Andrabi (10% you mentioned)