What's new

Jinnah Was Right

. . .
LOL Are you affirming that Muslims cannot co-exist with any other group? @hussain0216 coz citizen amendment bill fast track citizenship process to minorities from Afg, Pak and BD.
 
.
. . . .
Jinnah was right but failed to secure lands for Muslims of India. Jinnah a Hindustani Indian Muslim. Muslims of India and BD has to deal with this nutcase India for the foreseeable future. Pakistan was always a separate land with separate rules and people. Nothing changed for Muslims of India. Just some Indian Muslims migrated to Pakistan and BD.
 
.
Jinnah was right but failed to secure lands for Muslims of India. Jinnah a Hindustani Indian Muslim. Muslims of India and BD has to deal with this nutcase India for the foreseeable future. Pakistan was always a separate land with separate rules and people. Nothing changed for Muslims of India. Just some Indian Muslims migrated to Pakistan and BD.

You can't blame Jinnah

He tried everything he could to try and convince Indian Muslims

Many (who formed Pakistan) understood

But MILLIONS refused, thinking India would be secular, Bangladeshis jumped on the bandwagon

Complain about your own actions and lack foresight not about Jinnah
 
. .
For those who argue that had Pakistan not been created the Muslim vote would have been stronger in India, please note how many Muslims got elected to the Indian parliament. Parliamentary democracy doesn’t work that way. The Muslim population would have been even more spread out in Bangladesh & Pakistan so there would have been even fewer constituencies with a Muslim majority to elect Muslim legislators. So even from areas that are now Pakistan & Bangladesh, you would have had fewer Muslim seats.

Add in the fact that ethnic-nationalist parties would have split the Muslim vote even further.

A united India would have also gone in the direction of Hindutva.
 
.
Jinnah was right but failed to secure lands for Muslims of India. Jinnah a Hindustani Indian Muslim. Muslims of India and BD has to deal with this nutcase India for the foreseeable future. Pakistan was always a separate land with separate rules and people. Nothing changed for Muslims of India. Just some Indian Muslims migrated to Pakistan and BD.
Muslims was divided in 1947, Abul Kalam and few other Muslims was the supporter of congress due to which Jinnah bargaining position become weak, otherwise Jinnah could have easily secure more land for indian Muslims
 
. . .
Back
Top Bottom