J-10 vs F22

[lhuang]

The following is a quote from a discussion on BRF, it's about a Russian report on the development of HAL Tejas and the J-10. On page 25 it states that a J-10 has engaged a F22 and come out victorious.

How much substance is there to this?

Not sure if this has been posted but Air Fleet carried a nice review on Tejas and J-10 development program.

Clicky Pdf

Page 25:

«In the summer of 2007 a Chinese J-10 fighter
“Tzianbin-10”, created on Israeli Lavi basis with
Russian engines АL-31FN, managed to shoot
down an American multipurpose fighter of the 5th
generation F-22 Raptor above the Taiwan Strait.
During the incident subflight Su-30 blocked other
American Air Force aircraft off the “Feathered
Raptor”. The shot down Raptor fell down the
continental part of China and after that was taken
to pieces “for spare parts” by the locals. And the
successfully catapulted F-22 pilot was “quietly” –
by mutual consent of the parties – sent by the
Chinese to the American Command…».

: )

 

[M8R]

You're here to troll again by quoting BR?

 

[lhuang]

You're here to troll again by quoating BR?

urbandictionary on trolling

trolling:

Being a prick on the internet because you can. Typically unleashing one or more cynical or sarcastic remarks on an innocent by-stander, because it's the internet and, hey, you can.

Guy: "I just found the coolest ninja pencil in existence."
Other Guy: "I just found the most retarded thread in existence."

Fit the definition?

 

[topjumper]

J-10 shot down a raptor?? Nah, that's hard to believe, unless it had a radar fault or something but unlikely.

 

[farhan_9909]

Men behind the gun theorey still exist

anything is possible.

 

[lhuang]

Men behind the gun theorey still exist

anything is possible.

This,

also how would the Russians hear about it?

 

[ptldM3]

This,

also how would the Russians hear about it?

I seen an artical in Chinese, so i'm guessing they just picked up the story.

As for the incident it is fake, one of the Chinese articals posted a picture of a destroyed F-22 but that picture was from one of two F-22 crashes, one was from pilot error and the other was from a glitch in the FBW system.

 

[SOCOM]

i don't believe the posts. J-10 nor any plane can compare to the F-22.

 

[cloneman]

BS article.J10 won't have a chance to stand before F22.

 

[Materialistic]

Or maybe J-10 Pilot drank RedBull to get extra wings.

 

[Chanakyaa]

J-10 shot down a raptor?? Nah, that's hard to believe, unless it had a radar fault or something but unlikely.

May be the Raptor was Not armed at all.. or may be there is a video game haveing J10 and Raptor..

Two Real Possibilities.

 

[WAQAS119]

Chinese Shoot Down an F-22


We’ve received some very disturbing intelligence reports recently that have painted a less than impressive picture of the F-22 Raptor. Now a quite distressing report. Right out of China. An F-22 has been downed by the forces of China’s People's Liberation Army Air Force. We have obtained an extremely taunting video produced within the realm of the People’s Republic of China that recreates the events which led up to this most disturbing situation.

To ease your viewing, and so that you will better understand what you’re seeing, we’ve asked the experts at the FU audio/visual department to interpret this video. Amazingly, they discovered underlying audio that could only be detected with the most sensitive of auditory equipment. The communiqué was in Chinese so we asked the FU School of Languages to interpret. Below you can read the scripted message that resulted from our interpretation. Before watching the video, you may want to read through this a few times so that you are better able to catch the various innuendos and subtle implications.



Look up in the sky. Right there in the red circle. Do you see it now idiot? Yes, that's an American F-22 Raptor.

Here's our kickass early warning system. (Guess it didn't work too well this time since the Raptor is already over one of our cities.)

Here's some of our kickass surface-to-air missile systems. We might even fire a mobile intercontinental ballistic missile at him.

Here's our kickass airborne early warning and control aircraft, the KJ-2000, an original idea of ours.

Launch the J-10's!!! Kickass fighter isn't it? Here's our artists interpretation of what the engagement looked like. Notice how we kickass with just one J-10 while the other performs a Cobra maneuver just for fun. (Oops, those may be F-15's in the artist's interpretation. Please visualize, in your mind, an F-22 in their place.)

Hahahah!!! ROR (Raugh out Roud). There's the smoking hole. Proof of our superiority.

There's the Yankee cow parachuting to the ground.

There's the smoking ruins of the F-22. If you squint your eyes, real itty-bitty, it looks just like the remains of the crash at Nellis. See, we even have pictures with red arrows to prove it. (Oops, that lower right hand picture may be an F-35. Please visualize, in your mind, an F-22 in its place.)

Oh yeah, we also have really kickass special forces that are way better than yours. Here's some of our guns. We buy them in Shanghai, right on the street.

Don't mess with us.

 

[gambit]

You people CANNOT be this gullible, right? This desperate, right?

 

[Nav]

When nato and Us Bombard chinese embassy in balgarad then PlAAF Intercepted a stealth aircraft and force the pilot to surrender , Plaaf was successful , i read this in some magazine few years bk

 

[xuxu1457]

No plane can stand with F22 now,may be J-10 has some chance with the help from ground on Airspace of China