What's new

It Was Beef, Says A New Lab Report In Major Twist To Dadri Lynching

Manas

BANNED
Joined
Jan 18, 2011
Messages
2,059
Reaction score
-5
http://www.ndtv.com/india-news/meat...998?utm_medium=twitter&utm_source=twitterfeed

NEW DELHI:
In September last year, Mohammad Akhlaq was dragged out of his home and killed by a mob of at least 100 in Uttar Pradesh's Dadri over rumours that he had stored beef.

The police then quoted a local doctor as saying that the meat found in Akhlaq's freezer was mutton.

In a major twist to the case eight months on, a forensic report has confirmed that the meat was beef - that of "a cow or its progeny".

"Initially we did say mutton but subsequently we were told by the lab that it was beef," Uttar Pradesh police chief Javed Ahmed told NDTV on Tuesday.

Beef eating is not a crime in Uttar Pradesh, only cow slaughter is. The police say they tested the meat only to establish the motive for Akhlaq's killing.

A local BJP leader's son was among 18 arrested for murder.

The forensic report is tailor-made for more political sparring at a time parties are prepping for high voltage elections in Uttar Pradesh next year.

Madhukar Jaitely, a lawmaker of the state's ruling Samajwadi Party said: "Our stand remains the same. The government's job is to crack down on law and order violations and that is what we are doing. Someone was lynched and we will ensure that justice is one to the person."

Last year, the Dadri incident and other attacks linked to cow-killing and beef-eating were held up by opposition parties and activists as examples of rising intolerance and bullying by groups linked to the BJP.

The meat in Akhlaq's home was initially examined by a veterinary doctor in Dadri, whose analysis that it was mutton reinforced conspiracy theories. The Samajwadi Party accused the BJP and its affiliates of trying to polarize the region by spreading false rumours.

The meat samples were sent for a final assessment to a government lab in Mathura, which has now concluded that it was beef.

The report has been rejected by Akhlaq's family, which has always denied eating beef on the day of the attack.

"Dadri police said mutton, now you are saying it is beef. This is all politics," said Akhlaq's brother Jaan Mohammad.
 
. .
Even if it's beef lynching a person is wrong and inhumane , if it's against law then the court decide but again killing some one is wrong and un acceptable.

Villagers accused him of killing a missing calf and eating beef . In villages its like killing someone's child and eating it . Now when its proven that it was beef , i feel anger of the villagers who lynched that Muslim man is understandable though still its a murder .
 
Last edited:
.
Whatever.......you can't kill for that.....not even beating. Culprits have to be punished.
 
. . .
I can't disagree with you I have spend some initial years of my life in a remote village in Haryana but still killing some one for it is wrong .there are panchayats which can easily resolve this issue without killing the person

Villagers accused him of killing a missing calf and eat beef . In village its like killing someone's child and eating it . Now when its proven that it was beef , i feel anger of the villagers who lynched that Muslim man is understandable though still its a murder .
 
.
Hindu extremists sound exactly like the Muslim extremists. Oh its the victims fault! their life style was offending my great religion/culture etc. Get over yourself, not everyone should be forced to live the way you want to live your life. Beef or Mutton? irrelevant. What is relevant is the lynching of a man. Nothing can justify it.
 
. .
UP govt is worse they don't care of Muslims polarization suits them and BJP that's why this beef ghost come up again whether it's beef or not but this issue was enough to create polarization and sensationalization

How come they send this to a lab one year after the event?

Do the police have no SOPs at all? This stupid incompetence by authorities and the manipulation of that by politicians is most of the problem in the country.
 
.
Hindu extremists sound exactly like the Muslim extremists. Oh its the victims fault! their life style was offending my great religion/culture etc. Get over yourself, not everyone should be forced to live the way you want to live your life. Beef or Mutton? irrelevant. What is relevant is the lynching of a man. Nothing can justify it.
All 18 people directly or indirectly involved in the lynching are now in prison. No justification is going to get them out of there before their parole hearing dates by which time they will be old men.
 
.
They have resurfaced the old fiasco. Beef or not but U r once again inciting violence in this regard. And let the conspiracy theory jump in by establishing that those who are powerful enough to daringly kill someone, can also easily get the meat replaced with beef.
 
.
UP govt is worse they don't care of Muslims polarization suits them and BJP that's why this beef ghost come up again whether it's beef or not but this issue was enough to create polarization and sensationalization
I have to agree.

This whole thing looks politically motivated to keep it simmering till election time.

What these idiot self serving politicians don't realize is that it is very unnerving for the Muslim community to keep doing this.

Better would be get all the facts out systematically in one go. Including lab reports. I can't believe the original report was based on a vet just eyeballing the meat.

Do justice. There is no law in India that allows for lynching people even if they eat human flesh let alone cow meat.

Put the criminals in prison. Be kind to the victims and move on!

Don't use human misery and fear for politicking!
 
.
Very much possible but it's UP elections and you know there are two ways to win elections one by good work which is very difficult and requires a lot of hard work and other is play with emotions which is easy and give good results
They have resurfaced the old fiasco. Beef or not but U r once again inciting violence in this regard. And let the conspiracy theory jump in by establishing that those who are powerful enough to daringly kill someone, can also easily get the meat replaced with beef.
 
.
Very much possible but it's UP elections and you know there are two ways to win elections one by good work which is very difficult and requires a lot of hard work and other is play with emotions which is easy and give good results

Alas Politics is same all over the world :(
 
.
Back
Top Bottom