It is a Revolt - A Great Article by AG Noorani on Kashmir

[Stephen Cohen]

Noorani is TOTALLY Pro Pakistan

 

[scorpionx]

Noorani is TOTALLY Pro Pakistan

Absolutely NOT. Have you any idea about what he said about Pakistan's claim on Kashmir?

 

[Stephen Cohen]

Noorani is unquestionably a scholar but he is a liberal idealist and not pragmatist.

Absolutely NOT. Have you any idea about what he said about Pakistan's claim on Kashmir?

I have been deliberately reading Noorani for the last Two days

I have read all his works

Do you KNOW ; he reserves his GREATEST anger against Jinnah and Abdullah family

Jinnah because he REJECTED Patel's offer for Kashmir's exchange with Hyderabad

And then he abuses Abdullah for Trusting NEHRU

Later on in his OTHER works he goes on and on about India's perfidies and Betrayals

 

[Areesh]

Looks like Noorani sahab's article was an overdose of facts and realities for Indians

 

[scorpionx]

I have been deliberately reading Noorani for the last Two days

I have read all his works

Do you KNOW ; he reserves his GREATEST anger against Jinnah and Abdullah family

Jinnah because he REJECTED Patel's offer for Kashmir's exchange with Hyderabad

And then he abuses Abdullah for Trusting NEHRU

Later on in his OTHER works he goes on and on about India's perfidies and Betrayals

That in no way proves he is a Pro-Pakistani. I ask you again do you know his stance on Pakistan's claim over Kashmir, the central issue we are struggling to find an answer for the last seventy years?

 

[Stephen Cohen]

That in no way proves he is a Pro-Pakistani. I ask you again do you know his stance on Pakistan's claim over Kashmir, the central issue we are struggling to find an answer for the last seventy years?

Dont try to side track the issue of where his loyalties lie

He is PRO Pakistani certainly ; He says MANY things all at the same time

but the thrust of his arguement is that -- after the wars with Pakistan ; there is no question of India accepting secession

SO he wants autonomy ; BUT who is giving him that autonomy

His main grouse his the dilution and WRECKING of Article 370

He wants it back ; Old man is 85 ; he will pass away broken hearted

 

[scorpionx]

Dont try to side track the issue of where his loyalties lie

He is PRO Pakistani certainly ; He says MANY things all at the same time

but the thrust of his arguement is that -- after the wars with Pakistan ; there is no question of India accepting secession

SO he wants autonomy ; BUT who is giving him that autonomy

His main grouse his the dilution and WRECKING of Article 370

He wants it back ; Old man is 85 ; he will pass away broken hearted

Yes and it is his mere opinion which he has every right to express, not essentially making him a Pro-Pakistani as you erroneously suggested. .

 

[Stephen Cohen]

Yes and it is his mere opinion which he has every right to express, not essentially making him a Pro-Pakistani.

I am under NO OBLIGATION to agree with you

I have read his works ; HE IS PRO PAKISTANI

Looks like Noorani sahab's article was an overdose of facts and realities for Indians

No it was the old man's LAMENTATIONS and TEARS of the World

A dying man's LAST HURRAH

 

[scorpionx]

I am under NO OBLIGATION to agree with you

I have read his works ; HE IS PRO PAKISTANI

You can believe anything but what people have right to judge is whether your belief has sound foundations or not and there you fail.

 

[Areesh]

No it was the old man's LAMENTATIONS and TEARS of the World

A dying man's LAST HURRAH

You guys have grown up listening and believing in lies. You can't understand such scholarly articles.

 

[Stephen Cohen]

You can believe anything but what people have right to judge is whether your belief has sound foundations or not and there you fail.

I only believe that Might is always right

You are NOT giving me marks ; and this is not a bloody exam

You guys have grown up listening and believing in lies. You can't understand such scholarly articles.

If you read his articles you will realise HOW BADLY Jinnah goofed up

Just GOOGLE these Words " Kashmir will FALL in our LAP like a Ripe fruit "

This is what Jinnah believed and he wanted BOTH

Kashmir and Hyderabad

but got NOTHING ; Jinnah refused an agreement on Hyderabad and GOT nothing

This is what is NOORANI's GREATEST lamentation