What's new

ISRO mum on how 684 of its staff died

sudhir007

SENIOR MEMBER
Joined
Jul 6, 2009
Messages
4,728
Reaction score
1
ISRO mum on how 684 of its staff died - Rediff.com India News

Space and Research Organisation, the principle space research agency of India, does not want to reveal the details about its employees' deaths.

When Mumbai-based Right To Information activist Chetan Kothari tried to find out how many of ISRO's employees had died in the last 15 years at the agency and its associate units, he was provided with a bureaucratic jargon.

Although the agency replied that 684 persons had died in the last 15 years at ISRO and its associate units, it had withheld the cause of their deaths.

"All we know is that at ISRO people have been dying at the rate of 45.6 per year and it does not want to tell the public how have they perished," questioned Kothari.


The figure of deaths at ISRO, excluding its headquarters, in the last 15 years is 387, while at its associate units of ISRO Telemetry, Tracking And Command Centre, Space Applications Centre and Vikram Sarabhai Space Centre and ISRO HQ the figure of dead employees was 297.

"In my appeal, I had emphasised that the identity of the deceased may be withheld to protect the privacy of the families. Giving statistical information on the cause of deaths should not be a problem," said Kothari.

Last year, Kothari had obtained similar information from nuclear establishments and related organizations in which all of the government bodies had provided the cause of death. The revelation then had been startling, as it showed that 197 employees had committed suicide across all the nuclear establishments and related institutes in the last 15 years, while 1733 had died of various illness.

"I was informed by the ISRO that the information related to cause of death is not mentioned in the death certificate that is produced by the family members of the deceased to the ISRO. Majority of the government agencies know the cause of their employee's death, but the ISRO claims that it has no idea how its employees died. This is either sheer callousness on the part of the ISRO or attempt to hide facts from the public," said Kothari.

To his query seeking information about satellite launches, the ISRO provided the list of 29 successful launches done at the cost of Rs 14,160 crore.

"The information provided only pertains to the successful launch of satellites. There is no mention of failed attempts," said Kothari.

His efforts to attend the hearing of the first appeal made before the joint secretary at Anatarishk Bhavan at New Delhi [ Images ] was stone-walled despite several reminders. Kothari has now submitted an appeal before the Central Information Commission.
 
. . . . .
This is nothing. Everyone that born has to go away (at least in my generation).

This are most likely natural deaths.
 
.
May be work pressure... which is driving them to a state where at some point of time heart will choose death a better way than life..
 
.
"All we know is that at ISRO people have been dying at the rate of 45.6 per year and it does not want to tell the public how have they perished," questioned Kothari.

app 47 people per year, that rate is quite high in itself and why ISRO does not want to tell the people is totally another thing.


as it showed that 197 employees had committed suicide across all the nuclear establishments and related institutes in the last 15 years, while 1733 had died of various illness

Various illness, maybe that will include cancer which maybe related to exposure to radiation, still its a very large number.

197 suicides, that do effects the moral of people working around.
 
.
this is very serious.
what the hell is this going on in ISRO.
either it is being done in a planned way to cripple ISRO
or ISRO could be actually working on some sort of secret mission that is eating all these lives.
 
.
Something real fishy going on ISRO.... The government should take note of it(as in react to it)
 
.
They are probably abducted by ISI sponsored Aliens :rofl:
 
.
Whats wrong with the death figures?
What is this ISRO? Just a Space research Organisation. But many of you don't know that this is the premier organisation for research in many fields and space research is just one of it. Research starting from Rockets, propulsion system, material, chemicals, biotechnology, nuclear, nanotechnology.........in other words every field you can think of and also other fields which you are not aware.

Some researches are never publicised, because thay are highly advanced and important to national security. In R & D accidents do happen. What you expect them to do when such accidents happen?
You people want them to simply tell that us that they died due to this research (which is undisclosed) and their cause of death is radiation, or poisoning or some other.

You can not have transparency in every field, and especially those fields which are of national security.
These things happen in all major countries including USA, Russia and many more.
 
Last edited:
.
Whats wrong with the death figures?
What is this ISRO? Just a Space research Organisation. But many of you don't know that this is the premier organisation for research in many fields and space research is just one of it. Research starting from Rockets, propulsion system, material, chemicals, biotechnology, nuclear, nanotechnology.........in other words every field you can think of and also other fields which you are not aware.
Some researches are never publicised, because thay are highly advanced and important to national security. In R & D accidents do happen. What you expect them to do when such accidents happen?
You people want them to simply tell that us that they died due to this research (which is undisclosed) and their cause of death is radiation, or poisoning or some other.
You can not have transparency in every field, and especially those fields which are of national security.
These things happen in all major countries including USA, Russia and many more.

still the rate of deaths and suicide is very high, ISRO is successful in launching satellites and stuff i suppose, other wise it would be alright to term the so many deaths as accidents.
 
.
still the rate of deaths and suicide is very high, ISRO is successful in launching satellites and stuff i suppose, other wise it would be alright to term the so many deaths as accidents.

You are right, all deaths are not accidents, few are natural deaths, and few due to some diseases. But one need to understand that if they publicize cause of few deaths only and ignore cause for other deaths then what will happen. Some people and most inportantly media will make a big fuss about it. So its better that they remain mute.
 
.
I want India to model itself after the US on this. i.e. they also have a freedom of information act and their institutions also try to delay such information as much as possible. However, they have a secrets and national security act where some information is classified . This particular information sort after is not classified and is not state secrets as some have eluded here. far from it. Cause of death does not included where and what the person is working on, simply if it was work related , the location can be classified.

In this particular case, just some good old fashioned journalism can get down to who died and the causes for it. If it due to stress of this naturally high pressure environment or simply the employee to death ratio is pretty much average or that the average age of the people is much older than in any other environment! NASA's average age is much higher than atypical US company...plus its a high pressure environment.

US national media like NY times will still go after the information hard in spite of delays on non classified information ( sometimes even on classified if it looks like it's a cover up). Remember it abhu garib was announced to the world by the US media and not some foreign entity. The US administration pleaded with the media not to release the photos as it would cost more lives, it would embolden the terrorist because of a few bad apples. But they went ahead and published it. That is a thing to be proud of and only makes a country act responsibly.

Don't look at this as embarrassing, and ignore the concern trolling. This is a defining moment showing how far India has come in its democracy.
 
Last edited:
.

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom