Ex U.S. ambassador wants inquiry into Pakistan assassination
Editorial
Sunday 4th December, 2005
The former U.S. Ambassador to India, John Dean, has accused Israel of being behind the assassination of Pakistan President General Muhammad Zia-ul-Haq in 1988.
Dean made the allegation in an article in the World Policy Journal. He said he believed the attack was carried out by Mossad, Israel's intelligence service.
It happened on August 17 1988. Pak One, Pakistan's equivalent of Air Force One, took off from a military air base outside of Bahawalpur in the late afternoon. On board was Pakistan's president, joint chief of staffs, and most of the Pakistan army's top generals, the U.S. Ambassador to pakistan Arnie Raphael and General Herbert M. Wassom, the chief U.S. military official in Pakistan, and a four-man crew. Within minutes the plane crashed and all 30 on board were killed.
The U.S. Secretary of State George Schultz pressed the FBI not to participate in the ensuing investigation, notwithstanding two very senior U.S. officials had been killed in the incident, and that a substantial team of investigators had already been assembled. Schultz was supported by the Pentagon.
The State Department actively promoted the notion that the incident was an accident and even leaked stories to that effect to several newspapers including the New York Times. The official investigation subsequently concluded the plane crashed as the result of sabotage, and not any mechanical failure.
Ambassador Dean, who served under Schultz, now says Israel brought the plane down.
Dean said he was often asked to persuade India to have closer ties with Israel.
Dean who was once Richard Nixon's White House Counsel went on to become the Ambassador to Denmark in 1975 and then Ambassador to Lebanon in 1978 before being appointed to similar posts in Thailand in 1981 and India in 1985.
It was in Lebanon between 1978 and 1981 that Dean first incurred the wrath of Israel. Caught up in a vicious civil war, Dean traveled the length and breadth of the country negotiating with more than a dozen different factions to try and restore peace. The U.S. had a strong presence in Lebanon as did Israel. Dean was a joint signatory on Lebanon's bank accounts with Lebanese President Elias Sarkis.
Dean was authorized to negotiate with the Palestine Liberation Organization (PLO) if it was deemed to be in Americaââ¬â¢s ââ¬Ånational security interests.ââ¬Â When an ââ¬Åinterlocutorââ¬Â in Washington wondered if the Palestinians could help release American diplomatic hostages being held in Tehran, Dean soughtââ¬âand receivedââ¬âPalestinian help. PLO leader Yasser Arafat and his aide Abu Jihad themselves went to Tehran in 1979 and secured the release of 13 Americans. Never, Dean noted, did the two receive any thanks from Washington for their efforts.
Anyone who gets between the U.S. president and the prime minister of Israel ââ¬Åfinds himself in trouble,ââ¬Â Dean was quoted as saying in The Washington Report.
Riding in his armored limousine in Beirut with ardently pro-Israel Congressman Steve Solarz, a bullet hit the car. ââ¬ÅWhatââ¬â¢s that?ââ¬Â Solarz asked. ââ¬ÅJust a bullet,ââ¬Â Dean replied, ââ¬Åbut donââ¬â¢t worry. We are armored.ââ¬Â Solarz insisted on returning to the American Embassy, where he cabled home, ââ¬ÅArafat shot at me.ââ¬Â
According to The Washington Report, to stress his support for the sovereignty of Lebanon Dean always cabled protests to Tel Aviv and the State Department in Washington whenever Israeli planes intrudedââ¬âas they frequently didââ¬âinto Lebanese airspace. These reminders irritated U.S. Ambassador to Israel Sam Lewis, with whom Dean preserved cordial relations but who suffered to a notable degree from what the U.S. Foreign Service calls ââ¬Ålocalitisââ¬Â.. Other irritants flowed from Deanââ¬â¢s urging Lebanese Christian leader Bashir Gemayel to stop seeing Israeli Mossad officers.
Deanââ¬â¢s staunch defense of Lebanese (and American) interests came to a head in the early evening of Aug. 27, 1980, when, according to all the evidence, said The Washington Report, Mossad tried but failed to assassinate Dean and his family. The long-rumored attempted murder of Dean by Mossad, was publicly confirmed for the first time in talk by Dean in Washington.
En-route from his residence in Lebanonââ¬â¢s hills to the Beirut residence of the AUB president, Deanââ¬â¢s limousine and convoy took 21 rifle bullets. The automobile bearing the ambassador and Mrs. Dean was also struck by two light anti-tank weapons. The shot-out tires on the Deansââ¬â¢ bulletproof car automatically reinflated. The second car, however, carrying their daughter and her fiancé, did not have bulletproof tires and was momentarily stranded. The security guards in the convoyââ¬â¢s third car pushed the daughter and her fiancé into the Deansââ¬â¢ vehicle, and they sped away. Incredibly, none of the ambassadorââ¬â¢s party or security guards were seriously wounded. Some shots struck where Dean was sitting, but bulletproof plastic windows saved his life, said The Washington Report.
Picked up by Lebanese security, the anti-tank canisters had made-in-America markings. After unanswered telegrams to the State Department and all but silent responses to his telephone inquiries, Dean eventually learned that the anti-tank weapons were sold and shipped to Israel in 1974. Dean apparently mused to himself on the irony of an American ambassador being subjected to an Israeli assassination attempt with American weapons supplied to Israel for defense.
On the assassination of Arafatââ¬â¢s personal assistant, Abu Hassan, in early 1979, Ambassador Dean was told by the Lebanese intelligence service that three Mossad officers, bearing Belgian and Australian passports, had come to Beirut masquerading as tourists for the purpose of killing Abu Hassan, whose greatest ââ¬Ådrawback,ââ¬Â in Deanââ¬Ës opinion, was that he was close to the Americans.
While Ambassador Dean did not commend himself to Israel, he very much gained the respect and affection of Lebanon which, on his departure form Beirut, awarded him its highest decoration. And out of the turmoil of Lebanon he also kept the confidence of the United States, which subsequently honored him with the additional ambassadorships, in Thailand and India.
It was in India in 1988, three years after his appointment, that the Pakistan president was assassinated, and when Dean conveyed his views to the State Department, that Israel was responsible, he was accused of being mentally unbalanced, and was relieved of his duties.
Now Dean is challenging the State Department's charge and is calling for a fresh inquiry into the plane crash that killed the Pakistan President U.S. Ambassador along with twenty-nine others.
His theory though will compete with a number of other such allegations made since the high-profile crash.
Soviet Russia at the time was in the final throes of its war with Pakistan's neighbour Afghanistan and was irritated by Zia's close affiliation with the United States. The U.S. ruled out any Soviet involvement as it concluded it would not have engaged in an attack against a U.S. ambassador and senior military chief, notwithstanding Raphael and Wassom were not scheduled to travel on Pak One on the day of the crash.
Zis's daughter Rubina Salim claimed the United States engineered the attack even going so far as to say Raphael was aware of the plot and was prepared to die for his country. 'Yes, he was going to commit suicide,' she said. 'Where these people's interest in involved, they feel no compunction about getting their own killed. It makes no difference. If you have to do something for your country and nation, and you have been trained for that purpose, you will, of course, do what you are asked to do. We tried very hard to meet the American ambassador's wife (Mrs Raphel) but America did not allow anyone to meet her. And to date no one has been allowed to meet her. America employed her in its State Department,' she said.
Asked why the U.S. would want to kill Zia, Salim said it was because he was working for an 'Islamic bloc' which would have made the Islamic world strong, something Washington did not want.
Other conspiracy theorists point to elements within the Pakistan military. Vanity Fair speculated that the pilots were incapacitated by a nerve agent similar to VX, which pointed to the participation of 'an intelligence agency.'
The family of Zulfikar Ali Bhutto could also be considered a suspect. Bhutto was the Prime Minister of Pakistan in 1977 when Zia staged a bloodless coup and took power. He subsequently engineered what are generally considered trumped up charges of corruption against Bhutto and he was subsequently hanged. Benazir Bhutto, his daughter, became Prime Minister following elections after Zia's death. Her brother Mir Murtaza Bhutto, for the 9 years previous had run an anti-Zia guerrilla group, which shared offices with the PLO in Kabul, and later Damascus called Al Zulfikar or 'the sword'. Its proclaimed mission, according to Edward Jay Epstein, was to destroy the Zia regime, and the means it used included sabotage, highjackings and assassinations in Pakistan. It demonstrated it had the capacity to carry out complex international terrorist operations when it hijacked a Pakistan International Airlines Boeing 727 with 100 passenger aboard in 1981, flew it first to Kabul, where it executed one passenger and refueled, and then to Damascus, where, with the assistance of the Syrian government, it forced Zia to exchange 55 political prisoners for the passengers. It originally had taken credit for the destruction of Pak One in a phone call to the BBC although subsequently, after it was announced that the American Ambassador was aboard it, Mir Murtaza Bhutto retracted this claim. But Mir Murtaza admitted that he had attempted to assassinate Zia on five previous occasions. And one of these earlier Al-Zulfikar assassination attempts involved attempting to blow Pak One out of the sky with Zia aboard it by firing a Soviet-built SAM 7 missile at it. On that occasion, the missile missed, and when the terrorists who fired it were captured they admitted that they had been trained for the mission in Kabul by Mir Murtaza Bhutto and his advisers.
Benazir Bhutto didn't believe her brother was involved, nor the Soviets, the U.S. or Israel. She said it was divine intervention. 'Zia's death must have been an act of god,' she said.
India has also been mentioned. Prime Minister Rajiv Gandhi, according to Epstein, said publicly two days before the fatal plane crash that Pakistan would have cause 'to regret its behavior' in covertly supplying weapons to Sikhs terrorists in India. The Sikhs, who were attempting to secede from India and create an independent nation called Khalistan, were a crucial problem for Gandhi. They had assassinated his mother when she was prime minister and, with some 2000 armed guerrillas located mainly around the Pakistan border, the death toll from this civil war was approaching 200 a month. Zia had been meeting with top Sikh leaders, according to Gandhi, and providing guerrillas with AK-47 assault rifles, rocket launchers and sanctuary across the Pakistan border. In response, India had organized a special unit in its intelligence service, known by the initials R.A.S., to deal with Pakistan.
It seems just about everyone in the region and elsehwhere had a reason to bring down Zia's plane on August 17 1988. Hence there was little appetite for a full-blown and independent investigation. Dean is now pushing for this to occur. There is a case for him to be supported. It seems there are many unexplained events that preceded and followed what can only be described as a cowardly terrorist act that liquidated thirty people for the benefit of some one, group, or government, or combination thereof.
Source:
http://story.northkoreatimes.com/p.x/ct/9/...2833276bccc267/