What's new

Israel forges deeper bonds with India as it waits for its FM to arrive

DavidSling

SENIOR MEMBER
Joined
Oct 25, 2013
Messages
4,826
Reaction score
0
Country
Israel
Location
Israel
For decades, India’s close relations with Israel were kept in low profile and Israel was compared to a mistress not to be brought in public.

ShowImage.ashx

Israe-India relations expert Anat Bernstein-Reich. (photo credit:Courtesy)

Israel and India are having a honeymoon.
This week, the Indian Minister of Foreign Affairs, Ms.Sushma Swaraj, will be visiting Israel and the West Bank in a 3 days’ long visit.

For decades, India’s close relations with Israel were kept in low profile and Israel was compared to a mistress not to be brought in public. When the current Prime Minister, Mr. Narendra Modi, got into power on May 2014, he was no more hesitant to upgrade the relations, in a way that so many people believed that his first international visit will be to Israel.

If we look back, when Mr. Modi was the Chief Minister of the state of Gujarat, it was Israel that invited him for a visit, at a time when he was a persona non grata in the USA due to bloody riots that took the lives of over thousand Muslims, an incident in which USA blamed Mr. Modi to be responsible.

Many of the Israeli business people that operate in India are proud to present a picture with Mr. Modi during his tenure as the Chief Minister. At that time, he welcomed business with Israeli companies such as Elbit Imaging and Netafim, that set its first base in India in Modi’s state.

Apparently, Modi’s visit is still awaited and in the meanwhile he sends his special envoys to Israel.

In October came the Indian president Mr. Pranab Mukherjee. The visit of President Mukherjee was crowned as a success, he received an honorary doctorate from the Hebrew University, spent a lovely evening with Mr. Reuben Rivlin, and was welcomed warmly by the Knesset.

One unfortunate mis-pronounciation of the word “Hommus” will not be forgotten. While his speech to the Knesset, he wanted to say that “We Indians like to eat Hommus”. Unfortunately he said, “We Indians love Hammas”. The MKs lifted their heads when they heard it, and laughed when they understood that it is was a mistake.

For Ms. Sushma Swaraj, the Minister of Foreign Affairs, this is not the first time in Israel. Few years back she came as an opposition member of Parliament, wearing the hat of the President of the parliamentary Israel-India Friendship Association. Ms. Swaraj is considered as one of the leaders of the ruling party, the BJP, and a candidate to be the Prime Minister of India one day.

The press in India criticizes Mr. Modi for not traveling to Israel yet, after almost covering all the major capitals in the world, and accuses him that he is trying to be nice to the large Muslim population in India that accounts for 14% . The point is that the Muslim population in India is not anti-Israel, but for few small pockets. Few years back, the former Ambassador of Israel to India, Mr. Alon Ushpiz made a nice gesture and invited the leaders of the Indian Muslim community for the Iftar dinner that concludes the Ramadan.

And until his visit, Mr. Modi doesn’t stop tweeting. He sent us a Happy New Year and happy Hannuka twits, and greeted Mr. Netanyahu after the recent election.

Instead of visiting our Silicon Wadi, he visited the Silicon Valley and was hosted by Mark Zuckerberg and his parents. Modi's US visits were triumph trips. At the first one, he participated in an assembly of Indians living in New York, in a the Madison Square Garden, that for a day changed its name to “Modison Squae Garden” and in his second trip, he met with Fortune 500 companies, and with CEOs of Indian origin that manages few of the largest US companies, such as PepsiCo, Microsoft, Google, Adobe and many more.

There is no doubt that India’s appeal in the world grew after Modi’s elections and India gradually takes a center stage in the world’s economy and politics. Last July, a member of the Indian parliament opposition, Mr. Shashi Tharoor, spoke at the prestigious Oxford University Club.

Mr. Tharoor used this stage to call on Britain to recognize the injustices done to India and the economic and cultural damages caused due to the two hundred years of British ruling, named the British Raj. This extraordinary speech was applauded on both sides of the Indian Parliament, and Mr. Modi said that it represents the sentiment of all Indians. Tharoor said that he does not expect high reparation payments, but he asked Britain to recognize its wrong doing and to ask for India’s forgiveness. That was a preface to Modi’s visit to the UK last November, in which there was a public discussion led by an Indian origin member of the British Parliament whether Britain should give back to India the Kohinoor Diamond, that was taken from India over 160 years back and was placed in the late Queen mother’s Crown.

Mr. Modi brought to India hope. The economic growth is not yet as expected, but the new national schemes, are showing a promise. An Indian journalist commented recently about Modi’s regime that you can hear the plates clatter but food was not served yet. And although the economic growth is not yet as anticipated, India is still expected to become the third largest economy in a decade or so, which gives India confidence not just to demand from Britain an apology for the past injustices, but also expects the world to treat it as an economic power.

Mr. Netanyahu have marked India as a strategic partner, and asked his ministers to look east, towards India and China. The problem is that but for the defense companies, and few others, the Israeli business community have not yet realized, that India is not an anecdote, but a market not to be ignored anymore, that in year 2030 will be third largest economy after the US and China.


upload_2016-1-15_18-58-24.jpeg


Israel forges deeper bonds with India as it waits for its FM to arrive - Israel News - Jerusalem Post

@PARIKRAMA @Blue Marlin @sarjenprabhu @mike2000 is back @Adir-M @ni8mare
 
.
For decades, India’s close relations with Israel were kept in low profile and Israel was compared to a mistress not to be brought in public.

ShowImage.ashx

Israe-India relations expert Anat Bernstein-Reich. (photo credit:Courtesy)

Israel and India are having a honeymoon.
This week, the Indian Minister of Foreign Affairs, Ms.Sushma Swaraj, will be visiting Israel and the West Bank in a 3 days’ long visit.

For decades, India’s close relations with Israel were kept in low profile and Israel was compared to a mistress not to be brought in public. When the current Prime Minister, Mr. Narendra Modi, got into power on May 2014, he was no more hesitant to upgrade the relations, in a way that so many people believed that his first international visit will be to Israel.

If we look back, when Mr. Modi was the Chief Minister of the state of Gujarat, it was Israel that invited him for a visit, at a time when he was a persona non grata in the USA due to bloody riots that took the lives of over thousand Muslims, an incident in which USA blamed Mr. Modi to be responsible.

Many of the Israeli business people that operate in India are proud to present a picture with Mr. Modi during his tenure as the Chief Minister. At that time, he welcomed business with Israeli companies such as Elbit Imaging and Netafim, that set its first base in India in Modi’s state.

Apparently, Modi’s visit is still awaited and in the meanwhile he sends his special envoys to Israel.

In October came the Indian president Mr. Pranab Mukherjee. The visit of President Mukherjee was crowned as a success, he received an honorary doctorate from the Hebrew University, spent a lovely evening with Mr. Reuben Rivlin, and was welcomed warmly by the Knesset.

One unfortunate mis-pronounciation of the word “Hommus” will not be forgotten. While his speech to the Knesset, he wanted to say that “We Indians like to eat Hommus”. Unfortunately he said, “We Indians love Hammas”. The MKs lifted their heads when they heard it, and laughed when they understood that it is was a mistake.

For Ms. Sushma Swaraj, the Minister of Foreign Affairs, this is not the first time in Israel. Few years back she came as an opposition member of Parliament, wearing the hat of the President of the parliamentary Israel-India Friendship Association. Ms. Swaraj is considered as one of the leaders of the ruling party, the BJP, and a candidate to be the Prime Minister of India one day.

The press in India criticizes Mr. Modi for not traveling to Israel yet, after almost covering all the major capitals in the world, and accuses him that he is trying to be nice to the large Muslim population in India that accounts for 14% . The point is that the Muslim population in India is not anti-Israel, but for few small pockets. Few years back, the former Ambassador of Israel to India, Mr. Alon Ushpiz made a nice gesture and invited the leaders of the Indian Muslim community for the Iftar dinner that concludes the Ramadan.

And until his visit, Mr. Modi doesn’t stop tweeting. He sent us a Happy New Year and happy Hannuka twits, and greeted Mr. Netanyahu after the recent election.

Instead of visiting our Silicon Wadi, he visited the Silicon Valley and was hosted by Mark Zuckerberg and his parents. Modi's US visits were triumph trips. At the first one, he participated in an assembly of Indians living in New York, in a the Madison Square Garden, that for a day changed its name to “Modison Squae Garden” and in his second trip, he met with Fortune 500 companies, and with CEOs of Indian origin that manages few of the largest US companies, such as PepsiCo, Microsoft, Google, Adobe and many more.

There is no doubt that India’s appeal in the world grew after Modi’s elections and India gradually takes a center stage in the world’s economy and politics. Last July, a member of the Indian parliament opposition, Mr. Shashi Tharoor, spoke at the prestigious Oxford University Club.

Mr. Tharoor used this stage to call on Britain to recognize the injustices done to India and the economic and cultural damages caused due to the two hundred years of British ruling, named the British Raj. This extraordinary speech was applauded on both sides of the Indian Parliament, and Mr. Modi said that it represents the sentiment of all Indians. Tharoor said that he does not expect high reparation payments, but he asked Britain to recognize its wrong doing and to ask for India’s forgiveness. That was a preface to Modi’s visit to the UK last November, in which there was a public discussion led by an Indian origin member of the British Parliament whether Britain should give back to India the Kohinoor Diamond, that was taken from India over 160 years back and was placed in the late Queen mother’s Crown.

Mr. Modi brought to India hope. The economic growth is not yet as expected, but the new national schemes, are showing a promise. An Indian journalist commented recently about Modi’s regime that you can hear the plates clatter but food was not served yet. And although the economic growth is not yet as anticipated, India is still expected to become the third largest economy in a decade or so, which gives India confidence not just to demand from Britain an apology for the past injustices, but also expects the world to treat it as an economic power.

Mr. Netanyahu have marked India as a strategic partner, and asked his ministers to look east, towards India and China. The problem is that but for the defense companies, and few others, the Israeli business community have not yet realized, that India is not an anecdote, but a market not to be ignored anymore, that in year 2030 will be third largest economy after the US and China.


View attachment 287264

Israel forges deeper bonds with India as it waits for its FM to arrive - Israel News - Jerusalem Post

@PARIKRAMA @Blue Marlin @sarjenprabhu @mike2000 is back @Adir-M @ni8mare
the thing that annoys india is that they sell weapons openly or quietly (usual case) to china. this is because china provides huge incentive to israel which cant be ignored as it makes economic sense to trade. there is a market for israel to tap cheap labour in india and india does have a good services sector coupled with a decent but moderately growing IT sector. that coupled with matured israeli tech would make a good combination. but Israeli companies would have to invest in india to bring them up to speed whilst china is already there. i think it would be a very rocky start in the short/mid term but in the end it should work out. but india is in the position where i needs a balanced approach, it needs to keep ME countries happy too. just like how they are trying to do that with russia and the usa in defence procurements.
 
.
lol Indian media is not criticizing PM Modi for not visiting israel, as a matter of fact, they will be the first one to criticise him for visiting Israel.
the thing that annoys india is that they sell weapons openly or quietly (usual case) to china. this is because china provides huge incentive to israel which cant be ignored as it makes economic sense to trade. there is a market for israel to tap cheap labour in india and india does have a good services sector coupled with a decent but moderately growing IT sector. that coupled with matured israeli tech would make a good combination. but Israeli companies would have to invest in india to bring them up to speed whilst china is already there. i think it would be a very rocky start in the short/mid term but in the end it should work out. but india is in the position where i needs a balanced approach, it needs to keep ME countries happy too. just like how they are trying to do that with russia and the usa in defence procurements.
when did we oppose any arm sales by israelis to any other party? lol we dont even have economic or diplomatic clout for that.
 
.
In defense ties India and Israel are doing great, lot more needs to be done to forge closer economic ties in other spheres specially in agriculture field on vast scale
 
.
For decades, India’s close relations with Israel were kept in low profile and Israel was compared to a mistress not to be brought in public.

ShowImage.ashx

Israe-India relations expert Anat Bernstein-Reich. (photo credit:Courtesy)

Israel and India are having a honeymoon.
This week, the Indian Minister of Foreign Affairs, Ms.Sushma Swaraj, will be visiting Israel and the West Bank in a 3 days’ long visit.

For decades, India’s close relations with Israel were kept in low profile and Israel was compared to a mistress not to be brought in public. When the current Prime Minister, Mr. Narendra Modi, got into power on May 2014, he was no more hesitant to upgrade the relations, in a way that so many people believed that his first international visit will be to Israel.

If we look back, when Mr. Modi was the Chief Minister of the state of Gujarat, it was Israel that invited him for a visit, at a time when he was a persona non grata in the USA due to bloody riots that took the lives of over thousand Muslims, an incident in which USA blamed Mr. Modi to be responsible.

Many of the Israeli business people that operate in India are proud to present a picture with Mr. Modi during his tenure as the Chief Minister. At that time, he welcomed business with Israeli companies such as Elbit Imaging and Netafim, that set its first base in India in Modi’s state.

Apparently, Modi’s visit is still awaited and in the meanwhile he sends his special envoys to Israel.

In October came the Indian president Mr. Pranab Mukherjee. The visit of President Mukherjee was crowned as a success, he received an honorary doctorate from the Hebrew University, spent a lovely evening with Mr. Reuben Rivlin, and was welcomed warmly by the Knesset.

One unfortunate mis-pronounciation of the word “Hommus” will not be forgotten. While his speech to the Knesset, he wanted to say that “We Indians like to eat Hommus”. Unfortunately he said, “We Indians love Hammas”. The MKs lifted their heads when they heard it, and laughed when they understood that it is was a mistake.

For Ms. Sushma Swaraj, the Minister of Foreign Affairs, this is not the first time in Israel. Few years back she came as an opposition member of Parliament, wearing the hat of the President of the parliamentary Israel-India Friendship Association. Ms. Swaraj is considered as one of the leaders of the ruling party, the BJP, and a candidate to be the Prime Minister of India one day.

The press in India criticizes Mr. Modi for not traveling to Israel yet, after almost covering all the major capitals in the world, and accuses him that he is trying to be nice to the large Muslim population in India that accounts for 14% . The point is that the Muslim population in India is not anti-Israel, but for few small pockets. Few years back, the former Ambassador of Israel to India, Mr. Alon Ushpiz made a nice gesture and invited the leaders of the Indian Muslim community for the Iftar dinner that concludes the Ramadan.

And until his visit, Mr. Modi doesn’t stop tweeting. He sent us a Happy New Year and happy Hannuka twits, and greeted Mr. Netanyahu after the recent election.

Instead of visiting our Silicon Wadi, he visited the Silicon Valley and was hosted by Mark Zuckerberg and his parents. Modi's US visits were triumph trips. At the first one, he participated in an assembly of Indians living in New York, in a the Madison Square Garden, that for a day changed its name to “Modison Squae Garden” and in his second trip, he met with Fortune 500 companies, and with CEOs of Indian origin that manages few of the largest US companies, such as PepsiCo, Microsoft, Google, Adobe and many more.

There is no doubt that India’s appeal in the world grew after Modi’s elections and India gradually takes a center stage in the world’s economy and politics. Last July, a member of the Indian parliament opposition, Mr. Shashi Tharoor, spoke at the prestigious Oxford University Club.

Mr. Tharoor used this stage to call on Britain to recognize the injustices done to India and the economic and cultural damages caused due to the two hundred years of British ruling, named the British Raj. This extraordinary speech was applauded on both sides of the Indian Parliament, and Mr. Modi said that it represents the sentiment of all Indians. Tharoor said that he does not expect high reparation payments, but he asked Britain to recognize its wrong doing and to ask for India’s forgiveness. That was a preface to Modi’s visit to the UK last November, in which there was a public discussion led by an Indian origin member of the British Parliament whether Britain should give back to India the Kohinoor Diamond, that was taken from India over 160 years back and was placed in the late Queen mother’s Crown.

Mr. Modi brought to India hope. The economic growth is not yet as expected, but the new national schemes, are showing a promise. An Indian journalist commented recently about Modi’s regime that you can hear the plates clatter but food was not served yet. And although the economic growth is not yet as anticipated, India is still expected to become the third largest economy in a decade or so, which gives India confidence not just to demand from Britain an apology for the past injustices, but also expects the world to treat it as an economic power.

Mr. Netanyahu have marked India as a strategic partner, and asked his ministers to look east, towards India and China. The problem is that but for the defense companies, and few others, the Israeli business community have not yet realized, that India is not an anecdote, but a market not to be ignored anymore, that in year 2030 will be third largest economy after the US and China.


View attachment 287264

Israel forges deeper bonds with India as it waits for its FM to arrive - Israel News - Jerusalem Post

@PARIKRAMA @Blue Marlin @sarjenprabhu @mike2000 is back @Adir-M @ni8mare


EAM Sushma Swaraj is the right person to visit after Prez Pranab Mukherjee.. She was from opposition time close to Israel and article mentions her visit.
PM NaMo will visit Israel soon... But first i think DM MP will visit as many deals are to be signed including Barak 8 + Aesa Elta 2052 radars for Tejas + many other deals.

About Muslim appeasement or media saying about not visiting Israel, both are exaggerated. True NaMo has not gone but Prez visiting followed by now EAM means a continuous engagement... i am sure he and DM will be there very soon..

Strong ties with Israel is always desired and now with proper agenda being chalked via Sushma Swaraj, PM NaMo visit will be signify a much deeper strategic relationship.
 
.
the thing that annoys india is that they sell weapons openly or quietly (usual case) to china. this is because china provides huge incentive to israel which cant be ignored as it makes economic sense to trade. there is a market for israel to tap cheap labour in india and india does have a good services sector coupled with a decent but moderately growing IT sector. that coupled with matured israeli tech would make a good combination. but Israeli companies would have to invest in india to bring them up to speed whilst china is already there. i think it would be a very rocky start in the short/mid term but in the end it should work out. but india is in the position where i needs a balanced approach, it needs to keep ME countries happy too. just like how they are trying to do that with russia and the usa in defence procurements.
Interestingly I haven't seen any Indian 'annoying' on that part. We can't dictate Israel on Israel's relationship with China just like they don't dictate us on our relationship with Iran.
 
.
lol Indian media is not criticizing PM Modi for not visiting israel, as a matter of fact, they will be the first one to criticise him for visiting Israel.

when did we oppose any arm sales by israelis to any other party? lol we dont even have economic or diplomatic clout for that.
when did i mention the indian media?
israel does not care about you opinion when it comes to selling weapons abroad.
as long as if its in their own interests why should they care?

Interestingly I haven't seen any Indian 'annoying' on that part. We can't dictate Israel on Israel's relationship with China just like they don't dictate us on our relationship with Iran.
wow! you speak the truth because its common sense. congrats.
have a gold star
well_done_sticker-r43968e64d366491a9c6136e15d61bb9f_v9w09_8byvr_324.jpg
 
.
when did i mention the indian media?
israel does not care about you opinion when it comes to selling weapons abroad.
as long as if its in their own interests why should they care?


wow! you speak the truth because its common sense. congrats.
have a gold star
well_done_sticker-r43968e64d366491a9c6136e15d61bb9f_v9w09_8byvr_324.jpg

What gave you the idea that Indians are annoyed about Israel selling to China?.
 
. .
well isnt it obivous?
whos the largest buyer of chinese tech?
and is china on good terms with india?

So you are running on assumption.

Who is the largest buyer of Chinese tech btw?

What has Israel sold to china recently as compared to India?

Btw - the Russians sell much more weapons to the chinese.
 
.
What gave you the idea that Indians are annoyed about Israel selling to China?.
well isnt it obivous?
whos the largest buyer of chinese tech?
and is china on good terms with india?
Actually, Im with blue marlin on this one, it's common sense.
India is annoyed with Israel selling arms to china, same as US is annoyed by this.
Israel is annoyed that US sell arms to gulf countries.

So you are running on assumption.

Who is the largest buyer of Chinese tech btw?

What has Israel sold to china recently as compared to India?

Btw - the Russians sell much more weapons to the chinese.
Israel sold alot of stuff to china, most of them didn't get publish including drones (to russia too)
Israel relations with Russia, China is stable (and maybe even friendly on some areas)
 
.
Actually, Im with blue marlin on this one, it's common sense.
India is annoyed with Israel selling arms to china, same as US is annoyed by this.
Israel is annoyed that US sell arms to gulf countries.

Any proof that India is annoyed over this?..apart from the assumption.
 
.
In defense ties India and Israel are doing great, lot more needs to be done to forge closer economic ties in other spheres specially in agriculture field on vast scale

Israelis are pioneers of drip irrigation technique i believe they cooperated with india in this. It increases agricultural production
 
.
Any proof that India is annoyed over this?..apart from the assumption.
No, this is just common sense.
u can consider this as an opinion if u'd like
Israelis are pioneers of drip irrigation technique i believe they cooperated with india in this. It increases agricultural production
I watched a video that said that Israel supplied even pakistan with assistance in the agriculture area.
I'll try to find it :-)
 
.
Israel sold alot of stuff to china, most of them didn't get publish including drones (to russia too)
Israel relations with Russia, China is stable (and maybe even friendly on some areas)

India, China and Russia have many mutual friends. .And a few irritants.

I would say..India and China aren't really adversaries in the true sense. .Both do not bother what the other purchases.
 
.

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom