Islamabad Metro Bus, Lahore Metro Bus Criticism

[NaMaloom]

@ Metro haters

If you don't like Metro feel free to travel in these tin cans with your family.

And somehow you think 'families' use buses in Pakistan? lmao!

A family getting on a public transit bus in Pakistan is an anomaly.

No one is 'hating' on the Metro Bus Project, what is being questioned is the lack of transparency and the sky high cost of he project - both of which are inter-linked. Did the government hold public consultation before embarking on such a huge project? What input was taken from the communities and business in the areas that will be served by this project? Why was the cost almost Rs. 50b, who were the contractors, what were the terms, etc?

When a government has no transparency and accountability, shiny new toys don't really amount to much once things start to unravel. We all know what happened to Khaaadim-e-Aaala patwari's 'Laptop scheme'.

 

[Death Adder]

Obviously! When Punjabi politicians take taxes from all over the country but invest the most in their own province of Punjab - even then if Punjab isn't ahead of all other provinces then those Punjabi politicians would really be inept. Everyone knows how much tax contributions come from Karachi, but Karachi barely sees a dime of it.

And by saying Punjab, I mean Lahore and its surrounding areas, what I call the Greater Lahore Area (G.L.A) which patwari league is busy investing in to buy off votes for next election. South Punjab - the Siraikis - is in deep ruin and poverty much like interior Sindh under the jiyala party there.

It's not just money KPK Govt failed to make use of development budget around 50% was left unused and they failed to attract any foreign investment? Whom fault is this Punjabi Politicians?

And somehow you think 'families' use buses in Pakistan? lmao!

A family getting on a public transit bus in Pakistan is an anomaly.

No one is 'hating' on the Metro Bus Project, what is being questioned is the lack of transparency and the sky high cost of he project - both of which are inter-linked. Did the government hold public consultation before embarking on such a huge project? What input was taken from the communities and business in the areas that will be served by this project? Why was the cost almost Rs. 50b, who were the contractors, what were the terms, etc?

When a government has no transparency and accountability, shiny new toys don't really amount to much once things start to unravel. We all know what happened to Khaaadim-e-Aaala patwari's 'Laptop scheme'.

All relevant information is available and conspiracies debunked many time. People who travel in these buses don't give a shiat . What are you going to achieve from all these findings even our defense projects are incomplete without kickbacks. What happened to laptop scheme? I don't know please enlighten me.

 

[CHARGER]

A ride on the PML-N's shiny new toy - Blogs - DAWN.COM

 

[NaMaloom]

It's not just money KPK Govt failed to make use of development budget around 50% was left unused and they failed to attract any foreign investment? Whom fault is this Punjabi Politicians?

Not spending money is better than handing over that money to your party's MPA and MNA to spend - thereby enabling them to do corruption and steal public money from those development funds and spending them on their own constituencies only to buy off votes. But ofcourse, how can a patwari be made to understand that simple mechanism of 'transparency'; patwaris don't know the meaning of the words transparency, accountability & responsibility.

Here's something for lazy patwaris who like to make claims against KPK but are afraid to touch their keyboard to do a simple Google search:

Investment Promotion Cell Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, KPK

All relevant information is available and conspiracies debunked many time. People who travel in these buses don't give a shiat . What are you going to achieve from all these findings even our defense projects are incomplete without kickbacks. What happened to laptop scheme? I don't know please enlighten me.

Yes please tell us where is this 'relevant' information available? Where is the proof of public consultative meetings held by the Federal Govt for ICT or Punjab Govt for Rawalpindi prior to giving the go-ahead for the Metro Bus Project? Simply making stupid statements doesn't absolve you from the responsibility of providing evidence here.

PMLN Youth Laptop Scheme Corruption Scandal

You must be really living in some alternate reality to not be aware of the laptop scheme corruption. So here's for the benefit of your enlightenment Laptop Scheme drama conducted by khaadim-e-aala dramay-baaz/show-baaz:

Excerpt:

Grave financial irregularities, undue favouritism, misuse of official authority and corruption to the tune of billions of rupees have surfaced in the Punjab government’s laptop scheme launched in their previous term, Pakistan Today has learnt.

The Punjab government distributed 110,000 laptops to university students across the province allegedly to counter the rising popularity of Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI) Chairman Imran Khan among the youth just one year before the 2013 General Elections.

However, a special audit conducted by the government’s own wing – the Auditor General’s Office – pointed out serious corruption in the scheme.

The laptop distribution scheme was themed as, “Advancement of information technology amongst students through provision of laptop computers,” for the year 2011-12.

Documents available with Pakistan Today reveal that the price of one laptop was shown as Rs 20,000 as approved by the Provincial Development Working Party (PDWP) in October 2011 for a dual-core Dell machine. However, two months later, the PC-I of that scheme was revised and the laptop price was increased from Rs 20,000 to Rs 37,950 per piece without changing the original specifications.

Hence, the prices were jacked up without any justification, causing a direct loss of Rs 2 billion to the public exchequer.

Moreover, the project to enhance IT labs in Punjab schools – a project of the School Education Department – was rolled up and Rs 2 billion finances were diverted to the Higher Education Department (HED) for the laptop scheme without any provision under the rules.

“UNDUE FAVOURS GIVEN BY PUBLIC OFFICIALS TO CONTRACTORS”

A team of auditors further unearthed that public officials handling the scheme gave “special” favours to the contractor, M/S Inbox Business Technologies, in violation of their own contract.

As per clause 16(f) of the contract: “The bank shall make 80 percent amount of invoice value on maturity date of bill of exchange starting from the date of presentation of the letter of credit (L/C) documents.”

Further, Rule 2.10 (b)(5) says that no money can be withdrawn from the [government] treasury unless it is required for “immediate disbursement” and that it is not permissible to draw advances from the treasury for the execution of works, the completion of which is likely to take a “considerable time”.

However, during the audit of the laptop scheme, bank statement account no 7497-000-907 (maintained at the Bank of the Punjab, Civil Secretariat, Lahore) revealed that in five cases Rs 1.6 billion for five L/Cs were debited by the bank prior to maturity dates and receipt of laptops in violation of the contract.

EATING UP SPECIAL EXCISE DUTY – RS 162M DAMAGE CAUSED:

Moreover, according to the Ministry of Finance, Economic Affairs, Statistics and Revenue (Revenue Division) Notification No SRO 655(1)/2007 dated July 29, 2007, Special Excise Duty is exempted on computer hardware including laptops, notebooks, PCs mainframe and other peripheral units and parts thereof. However, examination of record revealed that the contractor was paid Rs 200 per laptop as excise duty whereas it was exempted by the government of Pakistan as per above notification causing a loss to public exchequer valuing Rs 22 million.

Interestingly, the rate of excise duty at the rate of 1 percent (Rs 200) mentioned in the commercial invoice is exactly equal to original cost of laptop as per PC-1 i.e. Rs 20,000. Whereas, excise duty, if any, amounts to Rs 302 as per commercial invoice which needs investigation and explanation from the contractor.

Moreover, it was noticed that 110,000 laptops at Rs 37,700 each [the government reduced the price by Rs 150 per laptop], valuing Rs 4.1 billion were purchased from M/S Inbox Pvt (Ltd).

However, advance income tax was not deducted because HED is exempt from payment of advance tax at import stage under the SRO 947/(I)/2008 dated September 5, 2008. However, income tax at source at the rate of 3.5 percent amounting to Rs 140 million was neither deducted nor recovered from the contractor, yet again causing heavy losses to public exchequer.

LATE DELIVERY DAMAGES FORGONE – RS 31M DAMAGE CAUSED:

According to Clause 4(b) of the revised contract agreement dated January 2012 and purchase order for supply and commissioning of 100,000 laptops issued to M/s Inbox Business Technology, “The complete delivery of all the goods shall be affected within 60 days starting from establishing of first L/C.” Also, Clause 14(2) of the same supply order further states that “in the event of non-fulfilment of the delivery schedule, liquidated damages at the rate of 2 percent on the quoted approved value of the undelivered quantity of the order will be levied per month and damages will be counted on daily basis.”

However, during the audit, it was noticed that 80,000 laptops were “supplied late” by the contractor in violation of above contractual provisions. Against the due damages of more than Rs 45 million, only Rs 14 million was deducted from the bills of the contractor. Thus, Rs 31million were deducted less, benefiting the contractor and causing loss to the public exchequer.

IRREGULAR TAXATION – RS 11M DAMAGE CAUSED:

Moreover, scrutiny of the record showed that tender for purchase of laptops was advertised in newspapers on November24, 2011. As a result, two firms named M/S Inbox Business Technologies (Pvt) Ltd and M/S Mega Plus Pakistan technically qualified.

The rates of M/S Inbox (Pvt) Ltd being lowest were accepted by the Purchase Committee. As per letter No C No 2(67) EX/2011 dated December 27, 2011, goods imported by non-profit making educational and research institutions are exempt from payment of sales tax. Higher Education Department is also exempt from payment of advance tax at import stage under SRO 947(I)/2008 dated September 5, 2008. Excise duty at the rate of 1 percent is also exempted under Sixth Schedule [Section 13(1) table-1(Sr. No. 52)].

Contrary to all these exemption, Rs 102 per laptop in shape of other taxes/duties were included in the final discounted price of Rs 37,700 per laptop. No government orders in justification of claim for other taxes or duties were available on record. This was deemed “irregular” by authorities and hence another loss of Rs 11 million was caused to the public exchequer.

“VARSITIES INCUR EXPENSES FOR LAPTOP DISTRIBUTION AGAINST RULES”

Note 1(a) below Rule 8 of the Punjab Delegation of Financial Powers Rules, 2006 requires that no expenditure shall be incurred on a scheme unless necessary provision for such expenditure exists in the development budget or the non-development budget of that year, as the case may be.

UNLAWFUL EXPENDITURE DAMAGE¬ RS 29M:

However, the records show that an amount of more than Rs 1 million was incurred on distribution ceremony held in Islamabad for distribution of laptops in Islamabad to the students of other provinces without any provision in revised PC-I. These expenses were borne by various educational boards including Bannu, Kohat, Peshawar, Karachi, Mardan, Protocol DG and Rawalpindi DCO without any authorisation.

Moreover, the expenses incurred during the laptop distribution ceremony across Punjab was more than Rs 28million, all borne by various educational institutions such as PU, GCU, FJWU, AIMC, University of Education, University of Sargodha and Kinnaird College.

The expenditure was held “unauthorized” and without specific budgetary provisions in PC-1. Further, in case of Punjab University, it was made from the budget of City District Government Lahore (CDGL) and in other cases, it was charged from the budgets of the respective institutions which were not “valid” expenditure from public exchequer.

Further, no competitive bidding process was adopted by the management of the respective institutions while making expenditure for respective ceremonies in violation of Punjab Procurement Rules, 2009.

“PLANNING FLAWS, POLITICAL MOTIVES IN LAPTOPS DISTRIBUTION”

Other than explicit violations of the contract which caused heavy losses in millions of rupees the team of auditors also found serious planning flaws in the execution of the laptop distribution scheme.

Documents reveal that there was no feasibility study at hand while planning the execution of this program. The project digest should consider Key Performance Indicators (KPI) which should not be “vague”.

However, observations made by a special team of auditors show only one of the nine performance indicators was specific i.e. to reduce the digital divide between the rich and the poor. Authorities termed the planners “non-professional” and “inefficient”.

The team further observed that no experts were consulted for the planning process, which was totally done in “isolation” initially in the School Education Department and then in the HED.

It was noticed that merit was declared as 60 percent and 70 percent throughout the province despite the fact that in certain institute everyone became eligible for this scheme. This way, the promotion of merit through competition could not be initiated among students and hence the government claim to ensure merit was false.

NO ELIGIBILITY CRITERIA – RS 170M DAMAGE CAUSED:

Moreover, during physical verification of laptops, test review of data of 18 educational institutions revealed that around 450 laptops were issued to the students without observing “eligibility” criteria. The fact points to the real motive of the PML-N leadership which wanted to woo the youth before the upcoming elections.

Further, examination of 17 institutions show that around 5,000 laptops were purchased more than required and hence blocking and wasting around Rs 170 million of public money.

“HED TRYING TO HUSH-UP THE MATTER”

According to officials privy to the corruption which has taken place told Pakistan Today that the audit objections have been conveyed to the HED and its officials have already held meetings of the departmental audit committee (SDAC) headed by Additional Secretary Shahid Zaman Khan.

As per routine practice, these objections are taken up in the SDAC with officials from finance, audit and the higher education and only remaining objections are then forwarded to the public accounts committee (PAC) of the Punjab Assembly.

Officials however maintained that the officials have been tasked to “hush up the matter”.

“They are very powerful people. It actually needs a lot of courage to highlight their corruption. Even government servants cannot risk their careers by writing against them. The task has been given to the officials to take care of the matter and it will be done efficiently,” the official on the condition of anonymity told Pakistan Today.

According to the officials in the Finance Department’s monitoring wing, the HED officials have kept the documents to themselves. “They only show us the files at the time of the meeting and then keep it. So we don’t really remember any details,” an official said.

NO COMMENTS:

HED Secretary Abdullah Sumbal was repeatedly contacted for his comments and he texted that he was out of country and should be contacted after August.

HED Additional Secretary Shahid Zaman Khan, who is heading the departmental audit of the scheme, initially asked for a few days’ time to respond to the audit observations. However, later he refused to comment on the issue.

Punjab Education Minister Rana Mashood was also contacted but his private secretary said he was “not feeling well” and will respond “soon”, but he never did.

Former higher education secretary Dr Ijaz Munir, who is currently holding the portfolio of health, was also not available for comments.

M/S Inbox Business Technologies, a Karachi based company, was also contacted at its Karachi, Lahore and Islamabad offices for comments, however no one came forward to give any version on the issue. According to the Securities and Exchange Commission of Pakistan record, M/S Inbox CEO Ghiasuddin Khan is from Karachi.

Audit exposes mega scam in PML-N laptop scheme | Pakistan Today

Drivers Installation CD of PMLN issued Laptops to Youth, comes loaded with Punjabi Mujra and Stage Drama:
PMLN Laptop Scandal - Khadim e Aala ka Laptop Karnama - Mujra in Laptop CD’s of PMLN - YouTube | Tune.pk


You think a patwari government who does corruption in even the smallest of things such as laptops is going to leave the mega project of Metro Bus untouched by its filthy corruption addiction... You must be dreaming!

 

[Dubious]

I am sorry I usually dont get involved in afwah bazi

Questioning the govt is our right! If they dont want people to question then be transparent and quit being democratic or hiding behind democracy when it suits them while not living up to its meanings!

 

[NaMaloom]

Already there are signs of corruption in Islamabad Metro Bus project

Excerpt,

Some 759 fully grown and decades-old trees, 3,773 small trees and several shrubs were cut down as they were falling in the alignment of the bus route. Additionally, 5,526 ground covers and small bushes were also removed.

According to the Capital Development Authority, the project posed a ‘short-term negative environmental impact’ in terms of loss of green cover, air, dust and noise pollution, and improper dumping of excavated material.

To cover this damage, a contract of Rs324 million was given to a firm owned by the brother of a federal minister for horticulture work.

However, on site, only ornamental plants have been planted and the work, according to the CDA, is faulty and not in accordance with the environment of Islamabad.

Dr Qamar Zaman Chaudhry, the former head of the Pakistan Environmental Protection Agency, said in the past he and other environmentalists was briefed about a phase-wise plan to recover the environmental damages caused by the project.

“Development has a cost. But it should not be to an extent that it becomes unbearable,” Chaudhary said. He added that the government’s plan of environmental rehabilitation was “satisfactory” but there was a dire need to give it as much attention as was given to the construction of the project.

Lined with gold? After paving paradise, metro bus takes off - The Express Tribune

 

[Echo_419]

Already there are signs of corruption in Islamabad Metro Bus project

Excerpt,

Some 759 fully grown and decades-old trees, 3,773 small trees and several shrubs were cut down as they were falling in the alignment of the bus route. Additionally, 5,526 ground covers and small bushes were also removed.

According to the Capital Development Authority, the project posed a ‘short-term negative environmental impact’ in terms of loss of green cover, air, dust and noise pollution, and improper dumping of excavated material.

To cover this damage, a contract of Rs324 million was given to a firm owned by the brother of a federal minister for horticulture work.

However, on site, only ornamental plants have been planted and the work, according to the CDA, is faulty and not in accordance with the environment of Islamabad.

Dr Qamar Zaman Chaudhry, the former head of the Pakistan Environmental Protection Agency, said in the past he and other environmentalists was briefed about a phase-wise plan to recover the environmental damages caused by the project.

“Development has a cost. But it should not be to an extent that it becomes unbearable,” Chaudhary said. He added that the government’s plan of environmental rehabilitation was “satisfactory” but there was a dire need to give it as much attention as was given to the construction of the project.

View attachment 227613
View attachment 227614

Lined with gold? After paving paradise, metro bus takes off - The Express Tribune

Why is the Govt providing subsidy

 

[I M Sikander]

How many medical & engineering colleges in punjab?

8 times what there are in kpk.
25 times what there are in Baluchistan.
Go and check the hec website yourself.

 

[Shan-e-ibrahim]

Mass transit bus stop in Islamabad

Mass transit bus stop in Copenhagen

Mass transit buss stop in Paris

Mass transit bus stop in Frankfurt

What was the need to construct such a large monstrosity?

yahi toh dhoka kha gaye.. are bhai..

we are 20 crore, these european countries have total population of just 5-8 crores.. jitni Punjab ki hai. Peak times main bus stand me jagah honi chahiye hai.

India ne bhi BRT banaya tha, belgium se copy kar ke.. failed as bus stand was so small for crowd and road transit too.

 

[Echo_419]

yahi toh dhoka kha gaye.. are bhai..

we are 20 crore, these european countries have total population of just 5-8 crores.. jitni Punjab ki hai. Peak times main bus stand me jagah honi chahiye hai.

India ne bhi BRT banaya tha, belgium se copy kar ke.. failed as bus stand was so small for crowd and road transit too.

BRT in Delhi is a failure but the one in Gujarat is a success

 

[Shan-e-ibrahim]

BRT in Delhi is a failure but the one in Gujarat is a success

yes because BRT in delhi was designed according to belgium population lol

 

[Echo_419]

yes because BRT in delhi was designed according to belgium population lol

Don't know about that but it was a huge fuckup BTW zyada mehngi baniye hai yeh metro aapne

 

[I M Sikander]

Obviously! When Punjabi politicians take taxes from all over the country but invest the most in their own province of Punjab - even then if Punjab isn't ahead of all other provinces then those Punjabi politicians would really be inept. Everyone knows how much tax contributions come from Karachi, but Karachi barely sees a dime of it. .

You are a tyoical racist , anti punjabi kid.

By the way , I m not from Punjab. I am from sind.
All provinces are getting their equal share through finance commission , Punjab is not getting any extra money.

Metres are completed by Punjab gov. Secondly Karachi is the biggest center of revenue collection, not revenue generation due to sea port and presence of head quarter of most companies in Karachi.
But difficult to understand for immature kids like you.

And by saying Punjab, I mean Lahore and its surrounding areas, what I call the Greater Lahore Area (G.L.A) which patwari league is busy investing in to buy off votes for next election. South Punjab - the Siraikis - is in deep ruin and poverty much like interior Sindh under the jiyala party there.

Bait a jani, fart else where.
The siraki cities of Punjab are much much better than interior sindh,Baluchistan and kpk.
Go and visit the Multan, bahawalpur, rahim yaar khan, etc.
Poverty is one thing , but better infrastructure in Punjab cities is evident even to blind.

 

[Shan-e-ibrahim]

Don't know about that but it was a huge fuckup BTW zyada mehngi baniye hai yeh metro aapne

paisa kha gaye hai isliye.

 

[I M Sikander]

paisa kha gaye hai isliye.

Go and prove it. Its useless to do bak bak in forums.
Take them to court and get them punished.