Is Pakistan-India enmity real or is it a deception to fight bigger countries like US, China & Russia

[Yaseen1]

People mindset is controlled by media and govt,from past 72 years they are promoting hate and enmity so nothing had changed and will never change if past stance is followed in future,western countries like europe had come out of historical conflicts and looked for better future but your govt are still trying to take revenge of 1000yrs back defeat of hindu rulers from Muslims in the region

Pls don't blame to BJP........ more than 50 years, congress was in central (India), latest 2004-2014... Even if they will come in central for next 50 years than still nothing gonna to change....it is a state policy and does not matter who comes and go..

Read the history, People like Modi only can take such a bold decision. if any agreement will happen than only MODi is capable to fulfill. Congress will always drag as can as possible... and finally will ditch..

Forget about Political parties, a common people of both countries will not accept any agreement if they need to compromise from their part of J & K.



OK...

 

[Kamikaze Pilot]

Is Pakistan-India enmity real or is it a deception in order to fight powerful countries like US, China & Russia?

If it's real why has the Kashmir dispute been unresolved for 73 years? If the belligerence was real, there would have been a fight to the finish long ago and one side would have been vanquished and shattered completely.

Thousands of people have died in wars on either side. So many deaths can't be faked. But the deaths would have happened anyways because the energy to kill in wars would have found other forms like Naxalism in India and TTP in Pakistan. The internal unrest was briefly channeled towards external parties during wars.

Both India and Pakistan face serious threats from big and powerful countries like US, China and Russia. There are strong reasons for the two countries to join forces and cooperate to protect themselves from the three superpowers.

So the mystery remains. Is Indo-Pak enmity real or is it a facade classified by the intelligence agencies of the two countries?

- PRTP GWD

@Aasimkhan @Asimzranger @Indus Pakistan @PakSword

- PRTP GWD

 

[Raj-Hindustani]

People mindset is controlled by media and govt,from past 72 years they are promoting hate and enmity so nothing had changed and will never change if past stance is followed in future,western countries like europe had come out of historical conflicts and looked for better future but your govt are still trying to take revenge of 1000yrs back defeat of hindu rulers from Muslims in the region

your govt are still trying to take revenge of 1000yrs back defeat of hindu rulers from Muslims in the region

Absolutely Wrong!

People mindset is controlled by media and govt,from past 72 years they are promoting hate and enmity so nothing had changed and will never change if past stance is followed in future.

Agreed, happening in both sides of borders.

 

[Asimzranger]

@Aasimkhan @Asimzranger @Indus Pakistan @PakSword

- PRTP GWD

This rap could best describe British Pakistani and desi, and could also relationship.... by Riz Ahmed. Inspired on work of Allama Iqbal shiqwa and jawaba e shiqwa

 

[Aswaklanta D]

It is real. But not very strong.
Politicians knows it, military knows it. Other countries knows it. And take benefits.
Only India Pakistani public don't understand this.
Every political setup is used by powerful persons and oraganisations to profit themselves. Same happens in India and Pakistan. Why powerful change something when it benefitting them.

 

[ARMalik]

@ARMalik

- PRTP GWD

Interesting question. I have my own views on this which I don't want to share here. But one thing is for sure, there are powerful people in both countries who scratch each others back in a big way. There is absolutely no doubt about it.

 

[Aasimkhan]

Interesting question. I have my own views on this which I don't want to share here. But one thing is for sure, there are powerful people in both countries who scratch each others back in a big way. There is absolutely no doubt about it.

No more in Pakistan. Bhuttos and Shareefs were indian puppets. Imran Khan is a different man.

 

[Kamikaze Pilot]

No more in Pakistan. Bhuttos and Shareefs were indian puppets. Imran Khan is a different man.

Clue that Imran Khan also may be corrupt, no different from other politicians

I know nothing about Pakistani politics, society or people. But I know Pakistan cricket team very well. How the various generations of Pakistani cricketers between 1947 to 2015-16 behaved...

Traditionally Pakistani cricket team had been very strong. Just the efforts of two cricketers would be enough to beat India. Be it ODI or be it tests, if the Pakistan cricket team played genuinely to it's true potential the win-loss ratio against India would have been 99:1 without any draw.

But the official results produced were not so. Pakistan lost many matches and many were drawn. Only the first few defeats Pakistan suffered in 1950s were real and there are doubts about even that.

Clearly 1960 onwards it was a case of match-fixing.

Pakistan team's loss and draws against India happened even when Imran Khan was included in the team. Why did Imran Khan allow the defeats and draws?

This gives rise to suspicions. PMIK may be corrupt and he is no different from other politicians. And just as he allowed Pakistan's defeats in Indo-Pak cricket matches, he may be allowing Pakistan's defeats in Indo-Pak political disputes.

- PRTP GWD

 

[fitpOsitive]

Is Pakistan-India enmity real or is it a deception in order to fight powerful countries like US, China & Russia?

If it's real why has the Kashmir dispute been unresolved for 73 years? If the belligerence was real, there would have been a fight to the finish long ago and one side would have been vanquished and shattered completely.

Thousands of people have died in wars on either side. So many deaths can't be faked. But the deaths would have happened anyways because the energy to kill in wars would have found other forms like Naxalism in India and TTP in Pakistan. The internal unrest was briefly channeled towards external parties during wars.

Both India and Pakistan face serious threats from big and powerful countries like US, China and Russia. There are strong reasons for the two countries to join forces and cooperate to protect themselves from the three superpowers.

So the mystery remains. Is Indo-Pak enmity real or is it a facade classified by the intelligence agencies of the two countries?

- PRTP GWD

Pointing nukes at each, just for a drama is a bit too much...
Aisa kon kerta hai bhai?

 

[Ultima Thule]

Clue that Imran Khan also may be corrupt, no different from other politicians

I know nothing about Pakistani politics, society or people. But I know Pakistan cricket team very well. How the various generations of Pakistani cricketers between 1947 to 2015-16 behaved...

Traditionally Pakistani cricket team had been very strong. Just the efforts of two cricketers would be enough to beat India. Be it ODI or be it tests, if the Pakistan cricket team played genuinely to it's true potential the win-loss ratio against India would have been 99:1 without any draw.

But the official results produced were not so. Pakistan lost many matches and many were drawn. Only the first few defeats Pakistan suffered in 1950s were real and there are doubts about even that.

Clearly 1960 onwards it was a case of match-fixing.

Pakistan team's loss and draws against India happened even when Imran Khan was included in the team. Why did Imran Khan allow the defeats and draws?

This gives rise to suspicions. PMIK may be corrupt and he is no different from other politicians. And just as he allowed Pakistan's defeats in Indo-Pak cricket matches, he may be allowing Pakistan's defeats in Indo-Pak political disputes.

- PRTP GWD

stop These stupid theories of yours, may be he is corrupt but not like the other politicians like NAWAZ and ZARADARI which looted billions of $$$ from the countries

PRTP GWD

 

[Aswaklanta D]

Pointing nukes at each, just for a drama is a bit too much...
Aisa kon kerta hai bhai?

Dramabaaz log karta hei.
Un logo ne janta hei ki sabko ye drama dekh ke acha lagta hei. Bohut benefit bhi hota hei drama se. Isiliye ye drama chalta hei.

 

[SIPRA]

Pls don't blame to BJP........ more than 50 years, congress was in central (India), latest 2004-2014... Even if they will come in central for next 50 years than still nothing gonna to change....it is a state policy and does not matter who comes and go..

Read the history, People like Modi only can take such a bold decision. if any agreement will happen than only MODi is capable to fulfill. Congress will always drag as can as possible... and finally will ditch..

Forget about Political parties, a common people of both countries will not accept any agreement if they need to compromise from their part of J & K.

It is an extremely deep-rooted collective psychological conflict between Hindus and Muslims of the subcontinent. Kashmir is merely a symptom of that conflict. Such conflicts never resolve without a lot of bloodshed. That spilled during 1947 seems to be inadequate.

 

[fitpOsitive]

Dramabaaz log karta hei.
Un logo ne janta hei ki sabko ye drama dekh ke acha lagta hei. Bohut benefit bhi hota hei drama se. Isiliye ye drama chalta hei.

I agree on that.

 

[SIPRA]

I agree on that.

Theek hae. Peer Sahib.

 

[Jackdaws]

There is no smoke without fire. There are differences and those differences have been exploited. USA made Pak a part of SEATO/CENTO and gave it arms. USA used it for Afghans against the Soviets. China is currently using it. Internally, Indira Gandhi used it to pretty much label anyone who opposed her as a "CIA spy" much like Modi does it now to label anyone as "Pakistani spy". India despite being in NAM, had to import Soviet weapons side with the Soviets.