Is PA doing enough to Match this IA Soldier Modernization?

[Azadkashmir]

you do realise that the world is moving towards digital war domain with AI, space and robotics!

breeding superhumans is an outdated thinking. the thinking now is more terminator like than breeding biological people.

there are 0 guarantees that breeding people will yield a superhuman or master race of people. the genetic gamble cannot be controlled by man as well as thought. or better said trying to play God!

AI has big weakness we have nukes that will turn them off but not biological super soldier.

 

[Path-Finder]

AI has big weakness we have nukes that will turn them off but not biological super soldier.

everything has limitations and weaknesses. but AI will determine almost every thing including war. that alone will render humans inept from future conflict.

 

[TNT]

What most self proclaimed experts forget here is that its not just the training. There is a limit to how hard and advanced training u can give or how one is genetically strong and smart. The main factor in a war would be the morale and belief. If an army believes that heaven is just one bullet away then no one can beat them. If the ideology and belief is strong and morale is high, no amount of traning gives u that. We saw how highly trained and weaponized NATO forces were taken down by ordinary men but having strong belief and high morale. I have seen videos of NATO troops crying even with all the air support and logistics and facilities and i have seen taliban laughing and having fun while staring at certain death.
If u want to beat the numerically and financially superior indian army, have an army with strong emaan. The rest, history is a proof.

 

[Falconless]

you use bio technology to breed superhumans not mating. that is an outdated thinking.

Sperm farming race horsing and cattle breeding style.

 

[TheSolution]

IF I was in charge i would move towards breeding best of my commandos with best female commandos n then repeat again then i get super soldiers quality over quantity. india has quantity we have quality.

Selective breeding, done with desirable traits using animals all the time.

Grab the most fierce, most brave, intelligent soldier and impregnate as many females as possible, then train the kids with a specialised educational curriculum since childhood leading upto specialised military training, at the end give them an option to join the military, if not, with the education they can still be very useful in other sectors.

I'm sure this has been attempted before in history.

 

[Bilal Khan (Quwa)]

I think infantry modernization is difficult to achieve as there's often a huge gap between ideals or goals versus what people can practically do in a wartime situation. Passing down lots of sensors, networking, etc to the common soldier sounds great in theory during peacetime. However, in wartime, chaos ensues and the thing that matters most, IMO, is rapid, out-of-the-box thinking. In other words, education and skills matter more than gearing up.

That being said, I think there are a few low-hanging fruits the Army could leverage for the benefit of soldiers, i.e: (1) scalable-plate carriers; (2) assault rifle scopes, sights and grips; (3) individual comms gear; and -- maybe -- (4) an advanced sight with miniature ballistic computer. However, I think (4) would likely be more valuable paired with RPG-7s than with assault rifles. Still, some units (like marksmen) could benefit from it too.

However, I'd put more emphasis on building skills and critical thinking.

Otherwise, I think the next big area of growth is network-enabled warfare. It'll be interesting to see how the PA is linking infantry up to the wider system. I remember Western concepts from the early 2000s that tried giving infantry mini-computers. That was a huge deal and the most expensive component of the suite. Ironically, that input could be relatively trivial now as you'd just need a ruggedized smartphone (albeit with some key mods) to get mapping, info management, etc, into the hands of a soldier.

 

[RealNapster]

IF I was in charge i would move towards breeding best of my commandos with best female commandos n then repeat again then i get super soldiers quality over quantity. india has quantity we have quality.

Training Female commandos in PMA so that tomorrow they can breed multiple kids with other commandos. Were you near some German land in the past week ?

 

[Path-Finder]

Sperm farming race horsing and cattle breeding style.

it has been done on humans during the cold war. for some reason it never went beyond secret experiments.

 

[Azadkashmir]

Training Female commandos in PMA so that tomorrow they can breed multiple kids with other commandos. Were you near some German land in the past week ?

no germans were near my land

 

[MilSpec]

I think infantry modernization is difficult to achieve as there's often a huge gap between ideals or goals versus what people can practically do in a wartime situation. Passing down lots of sensors, networking, etc to the common soldier sounds great in theory during peacetime. However, in wartime, chaos ensues and the thing that matters most, IMO, is rapid, out-of-the-box thinking. In other words, education and skills matter more than gearing up.

That being said, I think there are a few low-hanging fruits the Army could leverage for the benefit of soldiers, i.e: (1) scalable-plate carriers; (2) assault rifle scopes, sights and grips; (3) individual comms gear; and -- maybe -- (4) an advanced sight with miniature ballistic computer. However, I think (4) would likely be more valuable paired with RPG-7s than with assault rifles. Still, some units (like marksmen) could benefit from it too.

However, I'd put more emphasis on building skills and critical thinking.

Otherwise, I think the next big area of growth is network-enabled warfare. It'll be interesting to see how the PA is linking infantry up to the wider system. I remember Western concepts from the early 2000s that tried giving infantry mini-computers. That was a huge deal and the most expensive component of the suite. Ironically, that input could be relatively trivial now as you'd just need a ruggedized smartphone (albeit with some key mods) to get mapping, info management, etc, into the hands of a soldier.

You are ruining the thread. The post quality expected is as follows.

IF I was in charge i would move towards breeding best of my commandos with best female commandos n then repeat again then i get super soldiers quality over quantity. india has quantity we have quality.

 

[Azadkashmir]

Selective breeding, done with desirable traits using animals all the time.

Grab the most fierce, most brave, intelligent soldier and impregnate as many females as possible, then train the kids with a specialised educational curriculum since childhood leading upto specialised military training, at the end give them an option to join the military, if not, with the education they can still be very useful in other sectors.

I'm sure this has been attempted before in history.
[/QUO

Selective breeding, done with desirable traits using animals all the time.

Grab the most fierce, most brave, intelligent soldier and impregnate as many females as possible, then train the kids with a specialised educational curriculum since childhood leading upto specialised military training, at the end give them an option to join the military, if not, with the education they can still be very useful in other sectors.

I'm sure this has been attempted before in history.

trait is to find most fit commando who gets the job done etc n breed with female with same trait. then once you have atleast minium 300 of them, locate them to a place where they will re-populate amongst themselves.

 

[TigerOfMysore]

My only question on this topic is what is PK mils rifle strategy. This issue has been ongoing for years.

 

[Bilal Khan (Quwa)]

You are ruining the thread. The post quality expected is as follows.

I honestly didn't notice until I posted...

Well, since we're here...

This is how you win guys. This:

r/BreedingDittos

r/BreedingDittos:

www.reddit.com

 

[TheSolution]

trait is to find most fit commando who gets the job done etc n breed with female with same trait. then once you have atleast minium 300 of them, locate them to a place where they will re-populate amongst themselves.

That's inefficient for two reasons. Firstly because a single woman can only have one baby a year, and she won't live for 300 years, so that isn't feasible and neither could her body handle that much. Secondly, we can't allow them to repopulate amongst each other because that's incest and the experiment will reverse, you will have extra chromosome soldiers.

Just find random women with good perceived traits using a few fitness, intelligence, etc, tests and use the best male soldier to mate them each time.

Hypothetically, of course.

 

[TigerOfMysore]

That's inefficient for two reasons. Firstly because a single woman can only have one baby a year, and she won't live for 300 years, so that isn't feasible and neither could her body handle that much. Secondly, we can't allow them to repopulate amongst each other because that's incest and the experiment will reverse, you will have extra chromosome soldiers.

Just find random women with good perceived traits using a few fitness, intelligence, etc, tests and use the best male soldier to mate them each time.

Hypothetically, of course.

How about building a robotic army. Enough with human procreation.