What's new

India's Rustom UAV crashes during first flight

XYON

SENIOR MEMBER
Joined
Jan 20, 2008
Messages
1,719
Reaction score
2
Country
Pakistan
Location
Pakistan
India's Rustom UAV crashes during first flight

India's attempts to develop an indigenous unmanned air vehicle capability have suffered an early setback, with the nation's Rustom technology demonstrator having crashed on its first flight.

The UAV - the result of work by India's Aeronautical Development Establishment - came down during its debut sortie, performed at Hosur near Bangalore on 16 November.

India has funded the development of the medium-altitude, long-endurance Rustom to meet the surveillance requirements of its armed forces. The design should provide an alternative to imported systems such as the Israel Aerospace Industries Heron now flown by the nation's army.

The ADE says the crash was the result of "a misjudgement of altitude", with one local media report saying the UAV hit coconut trees after its engine was intentionally switched off.

Despite the mishap, the state-owned Defence Research and Development Organisation says: "The flight proved the functioning of a number of systems such as aerodynamics, redundant flight control, engine and datalink, which go a long way towards the development of a complex UAV."

At least 10 more test flights of the Rustom design are expected before the system can be taken up for production. The test work is being performed using a sub-scale version of the air vehicle with a 1.5m (4.9ft) wing span and an overall length of 3m.

Nuke Plants leaking (due to disgruntled employees!) (and Kapoora is worried about our nukes :rofl:)

Sukhoi's Crashing, Missile Tests Failing, UAV's crashing! This has to be some kinda Guiness Book World record in incompetency here! BUT INDIA SHINNING! :woot:
 
.
Old news.

If you start digging history you will find far more embarassing moments for other countries/militaries.

My Freind Take any 10 Years of history and any place in the world, You will find Good and Bad Moments. Both.

I wont even take 10 years - Just take Today - In your above post your forgot to mention that India in second quarter india has got 7.9% rate of GDP development - A Superb achievement on World Level in this time of recession.

We never forget that Pakistan Made a Gr8 Work by Making the successful Jf17 or The Positives of Pakistan.
Then why you see only Negatives ?
 
Last edited:
.
Old news.
If you start digging history you will find far more embarassing moments for other countries/militaries.

Maybe, but not such essential string of touted local technology failures in such a short span of time! :lol:
 
.
Maybe, but not such essential string of touted local technology failures in such a short span of time! :lol:

The UAV you talk about was a First - How many countries have made 100% Perfection in UAV technology in First Flight ?

India Has 20 Nuclear Reactors - Has Nuclear Deals with Us, Canada, France and Russia - and is Master of Thorium Technology - Still Question our Technology ? - Where does Any country in SA including Pakistan Stand ?

IAF has 200 ( MKI + Mig 29 + Mirage 2000 ) Superb Fighters while Pak has Just 20-40 F16s : Probability Says India will have more chances of crashes as Indians will have more planes in Air.

I dont Disagree that The Incidents u mention SHOULD NOT be Checked BUT, Considering them Technological failure by some one who Does net have that depth of Technology is some what Inappropriate.
 
.
Old news.

If you start digging history you will find far more embarassing moments for other countries/militaries.

My Freind Take any 10 Years of history and any place in the world, You will find Good and Bad Moments. Both.

I wont even take 10 years - Just take Today - In your above post your forgot to mention that India in second quarter india has got 7.9% rate of GDP development - A Superb achievement on World Level in this time of recession.

We never forget that Pakistan Made a Gr8 Work by Making the successful Jf17 or The Positives of Pakistan.
Then why you see only Negatives ?

Actually you are over asking for the appreciation. Every country suffers from problems and every projects is built on series of failures BUT it is different story when it comes to India. UAV could have disconnected from its ground station, or its camera lens might had got broken or it might had not attained the altitude you were looking it to achieve. If issues would have been like that, you could ask for technological indemnity but this is BLUNDER my friend.. and unfortunately, not the first one. Unfortunate aspect is that you are still expecting to be appreciated.
 
.
****************

******************

Your rockets are based on American tech

Your missiles are copies of Russian tech

Your UAV program is heavily influenced by the Israelis

Your local make aircraft TEJAS or whatever is a total failure

Your local made tank ARJUN is rejected by your own Army

You do not use one single military hardware that has been made in your country
 
.
The UAV you talk about was a First - How many countries have made 100% Perfection in UAV technology in First Flight ?

India Has 20 Nuclear Reactors - Has Nuclear Deals with Us, Canada, France and Russia - and is Master of Thorium Technology - Still Question our Technology ? - Where does Any country in SA including Pakistan Stand ?

IAF has 200 ( MKI + Mig 29 + Mirage 2000 ) Superb Fighters while Pak has Just 20-40 F16s : Probability Says India will have more chances of crashes as Indians will have more planes in Air.

I dont Disagree that The Incidents u mention SHOULD NOT be Checked BUT, Considering them Technological failure by some one who Does net have that depth of Technology is some what Inappropriate.

USAF has far more aircraft that the Indians and yet their attrition rate is extremely low. So its not how many aircraft you have, its the QUALITY of your personnel and procedures to up-keep them. So while we have our JF-17 JV with China, Al-Khalid JV with China and other such similar JV's running very successfully, you Indians are stupid stubbing your toes even to come up with a single JV tech in your country that has been adopted by your military.
 
.
The UAV you talk about was a First - How many countries have made 100% Perfection in UAV technology in First Flight ?

India Has 20 Nuclear Reactors - Has Nuclear Deals with Us, Canada, France and Russia - and is Master of Thorium Technology - Still Question our Technology ? - Where does Any country in SA including Pakistan Stand ?

IAF has 200 ( MKI + Mig 29 + Mirage 2000 ) Superb Fighters while Pak has Just 20-40 F16s : Probability Says India will have more chances of crashes as Indians will have more planes in Air.

I dont Disagree that The Incidents u mention SHOULD NOT be Checked BUT, Considering them Technological failure by some one who Does net have that depth of Technology is some what Inappropriate.

Had you and many Indians like you not been defending blunders, India would have been a lot better. You are not pressurizing your scientists not IAF to reach testing standards that rest of the world is using. Remember it is poor testing an poor maintenance which is resulting in failures and that is in your full control. You cannot give technological parity as an excuse here.
 
.
Dude lets not go this route, lets respect others, if you have a point discuss with facts. There can never be a situation where people will not laugh at your failure, you should learn to face it.
 
.
Had you and many Indians like you not been defending blunders, India would have been a lot better. You are not pressurizing your scientists not IAF to reach testing standards that rest of the world is using. Remember it is poor testing an poor maintenance which is resulting in failures and that is in your full control. You cannot give technological parity as an excuse here.

I dont Disagree that The Incidents u mention SHOULD NOT be Checked

Did i intend to Defend ?

Talk Real. How many Forum members here are Diplomats and Scientists who can actually Talk to the concerned Ones ?

And Do the Scientists and IAF really worries the Forum Posts and Act accordingly ?
Do they really get Defended by Me ... Can they ?

When a $50 Million Plane is Lost The Procedures are Automatic. The Investigations are Automatic.

You need NOT worry about Indian Investigations.
It may Take 17 Years but In a Countriy of 80%+ Hindus, Investigations are Made for Every thing even Religious Issues and Culprets are Named Be it a Hindu in BJP or any Scientific Entity.
 
.
******************

Your rockets are based on American tech

Your missiles are copies of Russian tech

Your UAV program is heavily influenced by the Israelis

Your local make aircraft TEJAS or whatever is a total failure

Your local made tank ARJUN is rejected by your own Army

You do not use one single military hardware that has been made in your country


If India could Get Missile Tect From US way back in 80s, i Thnk getting a ToT on F16 was Far more easiser ...
[ The Other lines you mention have been discused in dedicated Threads ]

Americans Giving Misile to India ... Un Imaginable.

You May NOT have heard of Cryo Engines ; Normally Used in Geo Stationary Launch Vehicles and Long Range Missiles.

Leave US, Russia was willing to transfer the ToT but US didnt allow it, Its Just This Year That after almost 15 Years we will test owr own Cryo Engine.

Btw, Going by Facts ...

USS Enterprize didnt came in BoB for India - It was in Pakistan's Favor
F16 were NOT sold to India..
Heavy Aids were NOT given to India..


And You say US Gave Missile Tech to India ? : Prove it if Your Can

Why do u have a laughable habit of speaking all that comes to ur mind even without thinking once ?
 
.
Ha hahahaha :lol:

This thread is a joke.

Do you honestly believe if you make stuff up they become true or what.

Sure the Rhustom TD crashed big deal, We already had a UAV before that to prove we can make UAV's.

Su-30 crash, 2 crashes in the last 12 years. Big deal.

Tejas even in its underpowered state it outperforms the JF-17

Arjun, 120 inducted and possibly more for Mk-2. which uses a jet engine instead of Diesel.
There isnt a Single tank is the PA, that can even pierce the Arjun's armor
Army does'nt want the current generation tanks like Arjun, they want the next generation of tanks. and have shown interest to work with the Russian for A new tank altogether.

India uses a lot of indigenous hardware, it Infantry weapons systems are all Made in India, Except for A few guns used by special forces that are imported.
Our Entire Nuclear arsenal and its delivery systems are Also Indian.

If their is something that we is that is foreign there is also a project to make it Indigenous.
 
. .
I'm happy that it crashed now so that we can assure that it wont crash during a crisis time.
 
. .

Latest posts

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom