Nilgiri
BANNED
- Joined
- Aug 4, 2015
- Messages
- 24,797
- Reaction score
- 81
- Country
- Location
1) The "unspoken promise" between an officer/captain and his men in the IN exists in a similar form in the IA. The IA imparts a proud "lead from the front" warrior tradtion in its officers and has a concept of "unlimited liability".
Yes its a broad ethos in the whole military. However it has been present in a special way in the Navy above all...given the psychology of being in a large tin can with significant numbers of fellow warriors.
2) On your final part about an Admiral wanting a ship from their shores for reasons relating to pride. I'm sure this plays a part in the compulsions of the Admiral however I think the true reason is one you have stated earlier. The fact that a ship will go to sea for extended periods of time and it is up to the crew to keep her sea worthy during that time means that it will be a far easier task if these ships were indegenious and of your own design. Naturally a ship that you have designed yourself (as the NDB does), built and, just as importantly, maintained in your country by your people is inherently advantageous when it comes to things going wrong/troubleshooting and skilling your crew because at the end of the day that is the most important thing- being able to perform on your own as a self-contained unit and thus the skills have to exsist within your own unit. The IA and IAF on the other hand have the luxery of working with foreign OEMs on the mainland with no issues whatsoever- they can bring in their people or can at least work with you (IAF/IA), the IN needs to be able to do itself.
Yup thats basically the very pragmatic analysis of the issue. It's one reason I also regret Indian does not have a proper Marine force like the US and UK. In times of war, it is important to always assume everything that can go wrong...will...and prepare for it....and whoever can best "localise" the problem-solving will prevail.....because supply chains and logistics are best had as short as possible for any military. Its how the best commanders in any era prevailed (when they didn't necessarily outclass their opponents in numbers and technology - just refer to Napoleon!).