What's new

India’s unfair trade practices lambasted

ameer219

FULL MEMBER
Joined
Jan 30, 2010
Messages
977
Reaction score
3
Country
Pakistan
Location
Singapore
India’s unfair trade practices lambasted

buine-640x480.jpg


KARACHI: Pakistan has threatened to respond in kind if India continues to obstruct exports through the use of non-trade barriers. This was asserted by Pakistan’s High Commissioner to India, Shahid Malik, on Thursday.

“In theory, they have no trade barriers against us but in practice, they have employed a number of non-trade barriers against our products,” he told a press conference at the Karachi Chamber of Commerce and Industry (KCCI).

Malik explained that the Indian government has created an extremely complicated schedule of duties and tariffs for imports which has made it impossible to calculate the exact landing cost of exports to the country.

He pointed out that the neighbouring government has ignored the development of its customs facilities at the Wagah border
. “While we have the capacity to handle 30 to 40 trucks simultaneously, the Indian side can only facilitate two trucks at a time,” he highlighted.

Malik also pinned responsibility for the absence of a direct banking system on India. All transactions between Pakistan and its eastern neighbour are currently either routed through third-party banking channels or the illegal ‘hundi’ system.

The high commission has received many complaints from local businesses regarding the unfair barriers erected by the Indian authorities to restrict the entry of good coming from Pakistan.

Participants at the event highlighted that Pakistani cement manufacturers had lost out on export opportunities after the Indian government refused to accept certifications issued by the Pakistan Quality Control Authority. Instead, the government insisted that certification be acquired from a quality control authority belonging to a third country.

Attendees also complained that Pakistan’s delegations to the international trade fair in Delhi received unfair treatment and were ignored by their hosts.
“The stalls allotted to our business delegates were small and in a distant corner of the trade fair,” explained KCCI chairman Abdul Majid Haji Mohammad.

He urged the speaker to request his Indian counterpart to assure that Pakistani businessmen would receive better treatment during this year’s fair, scheduled to be held in November.

It also surfaced that the Indian embassy was delaying visa applications and in many cases, denying visas altogether without assigning any reason. “Indian visas used to be processed in two days but now it takes more than 40 days and often, visas are refused without any justifiable explanation,” remarked former chairman KCCI Anjum Nisar.

Nisar suggested that similar treatment be meted out to Indian businesses until the Indian government sorted out the ‘diplomatic and technical hurdles’ created by it.

Trade between the two countries is currently heavily skewed in India’s favour. According to the high commissioner, Indian exports to Pakistan were valued at approximately $2 billion last year while Pakistan’s exports were only about $400 million.

Many Pakistani products have the potential to compete in Indian markets, particularly the southern states. These are especially lucrative for exporters because goods can be provided at a much lower cost than those shipped to these states from the northern parts of India. During a recent trip to Pakistan, the Indian Finance Minister Pranab Mukherjee commented that the sky was the limit for trade between India and Pakistan. However, Pakistani business owners are of the opinion that this is only possible if unfair trade practices are stopped and competitive forces are allowed to shape market trends.

Malik assured the audience that Pakistan would respond with similar barriers if the Indian authorities continued to employ unfair trade practices. “India has granted the status of most preferred nation to Pakistan but it is still using technicalities to limit market access to our firms,” he commented.

Published in The Express Tribune, July 30th, 2010.
http://tribune.com.pk/story/32617/india%E2%80%99s-unfair-trade-practices-lambasted/





Before you guys start commenting on this thread. I would like to remind you guys to debate this topic in a constructive manner. This thread was created not to blame India or to malign its actions. So I suggest you guys to not only reply to the actions stated, but to create ideas to solve this problem. Sarcasm,trolling,and one liners will not be tolerated. I hope we will discuss this is a very orderly fashion.
 
what do indian officials have to say about this. whats their side of the story?
 
I think pakistan officials are smart enough to know, if the trading benefits their nation or not. Otherwise they just wouldn't do the trading.
 
Trade can help solve mistrust between India and Pakistan. I hope the trade grows.
 
Non-tariff barrier
Indian embassy delaying visas to Pak businessmen
By Salman Siddiqui

KARACHI: The unnecessary delay in the issuance of visas by Indian embassy has created another non-tariff barrier for Pakistani businessmen, keeping the balance of trade in favour of the bigger neighbour.

President of Karachi Chamber of Commerce and Industry (KCCI) Abdul Majid Haji Muhammad said this to Shahid Malik, Pakistan’s High Commissioner to India, who visited the chamber on Thursday.

Malik assured the office bearers and members of KCCI that he would take up this issue with authorities in India and play his role in creating a ‘level-playing field’ and boosting balanced trade between the nuclear-armed neighbours.

India’s exports to Pakistan stood at $2 billion last year, while Pakistan’s exports to India a mere $400 million.

Responding to a proposal made by Anjum Nisar, a former president of the chamber, that Pakistan should reciprocally delay the issuance of visas to Indian businessmen, Malik said, “You, the Pakistani business community, would be the first to criticise us for this action.”

Nisar said that India was issuing visas to Pakistan’s businessmen after 40 days. Previously, these visas were issued in three to four days, he said.

Malik said that India had not allowed Pakistani cargo trucks to enter its territory via Wagah border for about two years.

He further said that India did not work on developing its infrastructure to facilitate Pakistan’s exporters.

“The capacity of unloading cargo on the Indian side of Wagah border is just of two trucks. Pakistan can facilitate 30-40 trucks at one time on its side of the border. This is an example of non-tariff barriers that India uses.”

He added that India organised an international exhibition last year, in which Pakistan’s participants were allowed to set up stalls. But, Indian Customs did not clear their containers till the exhibition concluded. There were many other examples of non-tariff barriers put up by India, he said.

He asked Pakistan’s business community to identify those items that faced non-tariff barriers from India, promising that he would talk to Indian authorities to have them removed.

“But I believe that political issues have to be resolved first for business relations to be sustainable.”

He advised Pakistani business community to conduct market research to know the demand for Pakistan’s goods in India. Pakistani manufacturers should participate in all exhibitions in India to increase their exports, he suggested.
 
so whats greasing the palm on the pak side to allow smooth imports. traders who give kickbacks to pak government for efficient import or something?

because clearly the pak government would want to maintain parity.
 
I think India does this to every other country. Not just to Pakistan. There are certain taxes and tariffs that are imposed on imports that need to meted out by every body. Pakistan feels that it is unfair for its exports but it is the same unfairness given to anyone who does the business with india. I am not an authority on this. But I am sure India does not have Pakistan specific tariffs.

If Pakistan want to do business with India, then why not ratify SAFTA, in which preferential tariffs were given. But due to political differences, they have not signed it also scapegoating all other SAARC countries along with it.

India is ready to open up, I ask you if Pakistan is ready to give up its insecurities and engage in full scale trade. Pakistan tradesmen seems to thinks so, just not GoP!
 
Last edited:
visa's ....there is no way we can just give them ........you guys give them because india dosent have terrorists waging war on other countries...i.e...no indian crosses border to bomb your nation......but its not the same otherwise.....................this arguement will also hold good for all the above questioning....

Visa issue is the easiest to solve. If Pakistan and India could vouch for its citizens that are coming through, that they are not terrorists. If he indeed found to be a terrorist, we could defame the corresponding country as a terrorist state and that state actors are involved in terrorism. This would solve the issue. Now that I think about it, it is a bit complicated.

No country should deal like this and shouldn't vouch for anyone. But India and Pakistan are exceptional. We should implement this for time being, we could relax this after say 5-10 years.

Trade is important for both the countries. There is no other way to prosperity. Although it is more important to Pakistan than India. I hope common sense will prevail on both sides and will see trade increasing multi-fold, along with it peace and prosperity.
 
Last edited:
First accord MFN status to India then we will talk.
 
This is not only pakistans complain but also of other small south asian countries. The indians heavily favour export while like to artifically limit import.
 
This is not only pakistans complain but also of other small south asian countries. The indians heavily favour export while like to artifically limit import.

Can you put any source about your BS ..... that India doing unfair

Thanks in advance
 
India’s unfair trade practices lambasted

buine-640x480.jpg


KARACHI: Pakistan has threatened to respond in kind if India continues to obstruct exports through the use of non-trade barriers. This was asserted by Pakistan’s High Commissioner to India, Shahid Malik, on Thursday.

“In theory, they have no trade barriers against us but in practice, they have employed a number of non-trade barriers against our products,” he told a press conference at the Karachi Chamber of Commerce and Industry (KCCI).

Malik explained that the Indian government has created an extremely complicated schedule of duties and tariffs for imports which has made it impossible to calculate the exact landing cost of exports to the country.

He pointed out that the neighbouring government has ignored the development of its customs facilities at the Wagah border
. “While we have the capacity to handle 30 to 40 trucks simultaneously, the Indian side can only facilitate two trucks at a time,” he highlighted.

Malik also pinned responsibility for the absence of a direct banking system on India. All transactions between Pakistan and its eastern neighbour are currently either routed through third-party banking channels or the illegal ‘hundi’ system.

The high commission has received many complaints from local businesses regarding the unfair barriers erected by the Indian authorities to restrict the entry of good coming from Pakistan.

Participants at the event highlighted that Pakistani cement manufacturers had lost out on export opportunities after the Indian government refused to accept certifications issued by the Pakistan Quality Control Authority. Instead, the government insisted that certification be acquired from a quality control authority belonging to a third country.

Attendees also complained that Pakistan’s delegations to the international trade fair in Delhi received unfair treatment and were ignored by their hosts.
“The stalls allotted to our business delegates were small and in a distant corner of the trade fair,” explained KCCI chairman Abdul Majid Haji Mohammad.

He urged the speaker to request his Indian counterpart to assure that Pakistani businessmen would receive better treatment during this year’s fair, scheduled to be held in November.

It also surfaced that the Indian embassy was delaying visa applications and in many cases, denying visas altogether without assigning any reason. “Indian visas used to be processed in two days but now it takes more than 40 days and often, visas are refused without any justifiable explanation,” remarked former chairman KCCI Anjum Nisar.

Nisar suggested that similar treatment be meted out to Indian businesses until the Indian government sorted out the ‘diplomatic and technical hurdles’ created by it.

Trade between the two countries is currently heavily skewed in India’s favour. According to the high commissioner, Indian exports to Pakistan were valued at approximately $2 billion last year while Pakistan’s exports were only about $400 million.

Many Pakistani products have the potential to compete in Indian markets, particularly the southern states. These are especially lucrative for exporters because goods can be provided at a much lower cost than those shipped to these states from the northern parts of India. During a recent trip to Pakistan, the Indian Finance Minister Pranab Mukherjee commented that the sky was the limit for trade between India and Pakistan. However, Pakistani business owners are of the opinion that this is only possible if unfair trade practices are stopped and competitive forces are allowed to shape market trends.

Malik assured the audience that Pakistan would respond with similar barriers if the Indian authorities continued to employ unfair trade practices. “India has granted the status of most preferred nation to Pakistan but it is still using technicalities to limit market access to our firms,” he commented.

Published in The Express Tribune, July 30th, 2010.
India?s unfair trade practices lambasted – The Express Tribune


Before you guys start commenting on this thread. I would like to remind you guys to debate this topic in a constructive manner. This thread was created not to blame India or to malign its actions. So I suggest you guys to not only reply to the actions stated, but to create ideas to solve this problem. Sarcasm,trolling,and one liners will not be tolerated. I hope we will discuss this is a very orderly fashion.

I appreciate that it seems Inflammatory but I would rather term my following statement "Drastic to get the Right Decision" :

Pakistan should stop all trade with India until India treats trading with Pakistan on Pakistan's Terms. Alternatively, Pakistan can treat India in a "Tit for Tat" manner. This should bring Pakistan the results it desires.

Regarding Cement : The Indians, I believe, have been closing down "Polluting" Cement Plants and at the same time have gone into a Programme of "Heavy" expansion by building large modern Cement Plants (which cause minimal pollution).

This might be the most likely reason for India reducing its Import of Cement - be it from Pakistan or other countries of origin.
 
The main point of discussion is somewhere lost and whole attention has been diverted to issuing visas and same old things terroritst.

There was no delay in issuance of visa before 10 Pakistani gunmen landed on the shores of mumbai on 26/11/08 and started killing people in cold blood.

This shows lacking in security measures or abilities on your part. And for your information India claims that they came illegally through a boat.

So, it doesn't really make any sense to expect terrorists asking for a visa when we are having a border of 2400km. So in reality those delay in visa times won't bring any benefit.

The main point of concern and the center of this topic is "Non-Trade Barrieres" so please discuss them.

He pointed out that the neighbouring government has ignored the development of its customs facilities at the Wagah border. “While we have the capacity to handle 30 to 40 trucks simultaneously, the Indian side can only facilitate two trucks at a time,”

“In theory, they have no trade barriers against us but in practice, they have employed a number of non-trade barriers against our products,”

Attendees also complained that Pakistan’s delegations to the international trade fair in Delhi received unfair treatment and were ignored by their hosts. “The stalls allotted to our business delegates were small and in a distant corner of the trade fair,” explained KCCI chairman Abdul Majid Haji Mohammad.

So please everyone discuss this rather than visa visa terrorist stuff.

Now this is called Bhaghal mein churri Moonh mein raam raam

If India wants to limit the trade then they should announce formally, We want no or limited trade with Pakistan. That's it!
Its your country your wish. But the current tactics only represent dishonesty and shows the intention of just to take the credit for nothing.
 
IMHO Pakistan shouldn't be issuing warnings. It should simply follow the Quid Pro Quo to them. That's the best way to covey your message.
 
i agree. india has given pakistan MFN status for trade. why cant pakistan do the same?
 

Latest posts

Back
Top Bottom