India lost in Afghanistan , pakistan won

[s@@d]

Kabul, Herat, Mazar e sharif, Jalalabad, Kandahar, Lashkar Gah, Nimruz, Ghazni.l and all provincial capitals.

which cities you mentioned as controlled by AFg are disputed.

USAF killed 20K Taliban fighters.

again by killing 20k taliban did USA won the war?? or is it on the losing side?? why are they negotiating to Taliban?? why is India worried because americans want to leave??

Will never happen

well the start has happened.. 5k taliban prisoners?? or you have a short time memory loss

It is Taliban which only exists in some desolate villages

look above map

Read the draft again.
Mentioned 16 times there US does not recognize Taliban as state

Amarat Islami Afghanistan....... and still not

 

[fitpOsitive]

Lol.
A random youtuber who can not even speak English properly.

Fact is Pak caused huge self harm by politically backing the Taliban causing them to lose all support from the most powerful and mightiest faction in Afghanistan (the Afghan govt).
Whereas India now has a friendly Prez Ghani and Vice Prez Amrullah Saleh.
Pak has got only semi literate Baradar and Haibatullah.

Who are Amrullah Saleh and Ashraf Ghani?

 

[SIPRA]

Who are Amrullah Saleh and Ashraf Ghani?

Ashraf Ghani and Amrullah Saleh are Mayor and Municipal Commissioner of Kabul, respectively.

 

[newb3e]

-Taliban does not control even one of Afghanistan's 50 largest cities & town.
-Afghan govt controls 50% of area and Taliban only 15% (rest is contested)
-Taliban does not have a single aircraft or heavy weapons. Meanwhile ANA has super tucano attack planes, helicopters and transport air craft. Taliban haslve Zero APCs , ANA has hundreds.
- Taliban is not recognized as ruler by a single country but Afghan givt is recignizwd by all and is the one holding Afghan membership at UN.
-Afghan govt revenue is 50 times larger than Taliban.
-Afghan govt runs a 50 times larger and modern admin setup and orgs than Taliban.

is tiranga flying high in afghanistan?

 

[N.Siddiqui]

Ashraf Ghani

Kabul is quite big, he is just a lapdog and relegated to move around in presidential palace, Kabul.

 

[fitpOsitive]

Ashraf Ghani and Amrullah Saleh are Mayor and Municipal Commissioner of Kabul, respectively.

Aik bar America bahadur niklay tu, then we will see these two most powerful men.

 

[s@@d]

Ashraf Ghani and Amrullah Saleh are Mayor and Municipal Commissioner of Kabul, respectively.

no one can beat us in sarcasm

 

[Arulmozhi Varman]

The title is childish to say the least. It's not India's war, but US and Pakistan's.

India expects US to stay till peace completely returns and Taliban helds their part of their bargain. Complete honest expectations. But if Taliban were to return to power through democratic or other means, then there is nothing India can do. We will do with what means we have to protect our interest. But historically, Taliban partnership with Pakistan has only bought her misery. It's upto Pakistan to play the risks accordingly and the history will tell the rest.

 

[s@@d]

The title is childish to say the least. It's not India's war, but US and Pakistan's.

India expects US to stay till peace completely returns and Taliban helds their part of their bargain. Complete honest expectations. But if Taliban were to return to power through democratic or other means, then there is nothing India can do. We will do with what means we have to protect our interest. But historically, Taliban partnership with Pakistan has only bought her misery. It's upto Pakistan to play the risks accordingly and the history will tell the rest.

 

[Mighty Lion]

which cities you mentioned as controlled by AFg are disputed.

Read again:

The Afghan National Defense and Security Forces remain in control of most of Afghanistan's population centers and all of 34 provincial capitals

http://www.xinhuanet.com/english/2020-02/18/c_138795726.htm.

Talibs are now forced to release all 1000 prisoners in their custody.

Amarat Islami Afghanistan....... and still not

Mentioned everytime in bracket that US does not recognize it as a state

Who are Amrullah Saleh and Ashraf Ghani?

You need to improve your knowledge on your neighbours
Two of the most powerful Afghans (Ghani is #1 ; Saleh is #3 or #4).

 

[fitpOsitive]

Read again:

http://www.xinhuanet.com/english/2020-02/18/c_138795726.htm.

Talibs are now forced to release all 1000 prisoners in their custody.


Mentioned everytime in bracket that US does not recognize it as a state


You need to improve your knowledge on your neighbours
Two of the most powerful Afghans (Ghani is #1 ; Saleh is #3 or #4).

Roasted bodies have no power, and I already am seeing at least two bodies roasted in Afghanistan. As said before, let see who is more powerful.

 

[krash]

Lol.
A random youtuber who can not even speak English properly.

Lol.
A random poster who can not even make sense properly.

causing them to lose all support from the most powerful and mightiest faction in Afghanistan (the Afghan govt). Whereas India now has a friendly Prez Ghani and Vice Prez Amrullah Saleh.
Pak has got only semi literate Baradar and Haibatullah.

Ah yes. That puppet city state that exercises control over a whopping 30% of the country only on paper by proxy of foreign soldiers, foreign soldiers who are about to run back home after negotiations with the not so "powerful and mighty" faction of Afghanistan, negotiations which "the most powerful and mightiest faction in Afghanistan" was not invited to and left only to pass desperate statements to the media while the rest of the world decided their fate elsewhere. I see what you mean. Good job, India. Keep it up.

Wrong answer. Back in the day you had no problems dealing with the USA either, on one hand, you got US and NATO helping you with mil equipment and training on the other you had Taliban working along with you helping them set up madrassas in Pakistan to train Muj fighters. How did that work out for you?

Speaking of wrong answers, that is not the 'Taliban era'. The Taliban did not exist back then. Please educate yourself on the matter and only then come back.

 

[ghazi52]

https://www.facebook.com/

 

[CrazyZ]

Most of the gains of this conflict are amoung the Kabul elites (and why they don't want to end the conflict). Most of costs of this conflict have been beared by the Americans.

Overall, India has gained little in Afghanistan...but
also lost little in Afghanistan (costs have largely been by the USA). Pakistan has gained tactically in Afghanistan but strategically.....has gained little up this point.

A solid peace and a Pakistan-Afghanistan-Central asia energy/goods trade corridor must be created before we can say it has been a success.

 

[Longhorn]

So Soviet bases all along our Western flank and india on our east....somehow this would be a safe place for Pakistan to exist? As we know, Russians have no qualms about assisting barrel bombing dictators in massacring their own people - you think they wouldn't green light India in invading Pakistan?

There is just no way Pakistan would have survived as anything more than a Soviet puppet and worst case scenario, it would have been overrun by India while the Soviets offered full support from the west and the Indian ocean.

You're absolutely right.
We did what we had to do to survive. They, the Indians, had us where they wanted us and we managed to turn the tables, twice, if the Americans **** off as they say they will.