What's new

India forgetting 1999 Kargil victory against Pakistan: Gen. V.P Malik

arp2041

BANNED
Joined
Apr 4, 2012
Messages
10,406
Reaction score
-9
Country
India
Location
India
Thirteen years ago, the Indian Army found itself drawn into a messy low-intensity conflict with Pakistan in the icy heights of Kargil in Jammu and Kashmir that cost it 527 soldiers. Today, Gen VP Malik, the then Army chief, laments that the major victory scored has all been forgotten.

Kargil was India's first television war and could have promoted a "strategic culture" in the country, but the gains were lost because of political compulsions, Malik says.

"We must celebrate the Kargil victory. Unfortunately, the Kargil war has become a political football," 74-year-old Malik, who lives in the Chandigarh suburb of Panchkula, told a news agency in an interview.

"Politics got into the Kargil victory and the celebrations became a political football. That's what we saw with political rivals celebrating and criticising the war for reasons that suited them," Malik said.

"The armed forces had tremendous support from the people and the media," he said, adding: "But politics got into all this and that's why there were good celebrations initially and there are hardly any celebrations. Slowly people are beginning to forget, because it is not providing much political mileage."

From 2000 to 2003, July 26, the day the war ended, was commemorated in a variety of ways. This, however, stopped when the United Progressive Alliance government came to power.

Calling for grander celebrations, Malik said, "We have to tell the people about these battles and if we want to build a strategic culture, we need to celebrate these victories and inform people how these battles were won."

The Kargil war in May-July 1999 saw India throwing back Pakistani regulars who had occupied key heights in the sector that had been vacated by the Indian troops during the harsh winter.

At the same time, Malik readily agreed that the victory in the 1971 war with Pakistan that saw the creation of the independent nation of Bangladesh was "much bigger" and "greater" than Kargil.

"The 1971 war was certainly a much bigger, greater victory for India, as we had fought on both (eastern and western) fronts. But that was 1971. In 1999, we were reacting to a situation, as in 1965, and were playing on the back foot.

"In 1971, we had taken the initiative in view of the refugees pouring in from the East and there was time for us to prepare for the war," Malik said.

But the situation in 1999 was different, he said, noting that the whole world was watching India with suspicion following its 1998 nuclear tests.

"We did exceeding well with the Army, Navy and the Air Force jointly working out a strategy in a limited war scenario," he added.

http://zeenews.india.com/news/nation/india-forgetting-1999-kargil-victory-against-pak_790440.html
 
.
Firstly respect to the army for their service and sacrifice to the country but I disagree. A war should never be celebrated, humans die on both sides. Its nothing to celebrate about.
 
.
Firstly respect to the army for their service and sacrifice to the country but I disagree. A war should never be celebrated, humans die on both sides. Its nothing to celebrate about.

A war would never be celebrated......but we should not forget the honour & Bravery which armed forces had shown to world by sacrificing their precious Lifes for Nation.
 
.
Firstly respect to the army for their service and sacrifice to the country but I disagree. A war should never be celebrated, humans die on both sides. Its nothing to celebrate about.
Its like saying dont celebrate for passing the exam because few persons didnt :P Gen VP Malik said the above for guys like you :woot:
 
.
Country;s try to forget the war which they lose ...
Same is the case here india lost the war and now they are trying to patch up with these kind of bullsheet newss.:D
 
. . . .
Firstly respect to the army for their service and sacrifice to the country but I disagree. A war should never be celebrated, humans die on both sides. Its nothing to celebrate about.

Then the world wouldnt celebrate WW2 against evil nazis? They are celebrating till now... Celebration is a mark of respect to those soldiers, who have given those lives, so you and me can live happily...
 
. . .
"victory" psssssst. then why does Pakistan still occupy several points in Kargil including point 5353?
The hills that you have, you captured those hills cowardly, when they were unguarded and Indian army was not present there.
Where as the hills that we have, we captured those hills after beating enemy's ***.
So we are victorious.
 
.
"victory" psssssst. then why does Pakistan still occupy several points in Kargil including point 5353?

Tiger Hill Point 5353 (Highest Peak in Kargil Region) Still in Control of Pakistan - YouTube

:hitwall:

kargil k baad hee pakisrtan k manhoos din shuru ho gaye thay, we were praised and u were lamblasted by international community for starting the war. and yet another humiliating loss for pakistan, in short Kargil was a terrible blunder by Master blunder parvez musharaff. (well tht guy was gem of idiot who made blunders after blunders :D
 
. .
India's Defence Minister was asked point-blank if India lost any territory at Kargil, and he was caught lying.

Despite all the media propaganda that India won, Pakistan actually gained territory. Kargil has exchanged hands three times since our independance, and until Kashmir is resolved and India doesn't stop mass-graves and terrorism, it can expect a hundred more Kargils.

The hills that you have, you captured those hills cowardly, when they were unguarded and Indian army was not present there.
Where as the hills that we have, we captured those hills after beating enemy's ***.
So we are victorious.

So... that's pretty dumb on the Indian Army's part. Are you also implying that India lost Tiger Hill without a friggin' fight? They fought for it till 2003 and still couldn't capture it.

Hills you have result in 300% more casualties at Siachen, than what Pakistan Army suffers. You can keep the propaganda benefit at the constant cost of human lives.
 
.

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom