Indecent writing included in urdu literature book- Sargodha University

[Divergent]

I don’t understand or can read it

 

[El Sidd]

I don’t understand or can read it

Anghota chaap angrez

 

[Divergent]

Anghota chaap angrez

Huh? What? It’s in Urdu.

 

[somebozo]

They are trying to spice up some adult life for Pakistanis, as they go directly from 19 to 60!

 

[El Sidd]

Huh? What? It’s in Urdu.

No shit Einstein !!

 

[Ocean]

Bro, It not an ORIGINAL letter!! It is a fake one, answer is written by Anwar Sb himself! Listen to it, he clearly states as "Manto saying to him that sadly i was not able to meet you on earth"

Bhai if you can miss this, no offense, you should not even think of understanding Manto or his work (again, vulgar, YES, only vulgar, NO)

Yes i know its not an original letter i mentioned that in my post u quoted that the format shows that letter was sent by him but its a sarcastic take the letter is actually compised by anwar.
I think u missed that in my post.

As of manto bhai i have read multiple writers and its due to their efforts plus my own experiences that i have come to know about our societal issues in quite depth. But manto never struck those chords in me ,he always came across as vulgar and just vulgar and as of his hard hitting messages i have really found some very hard hitting messages in tonnes of other writers work pieces who wrote about various sections of society like amina mufti but manto never came as strong as them.

 

[Ocean]

Fuhash nigar is the term used for this person. Did nothing else besides writing erotic novels and drowning himself in alcohol.
It is beyond common sense why his erotic pieces are taught in universities? What educational value does his rubbish offers? Can university girls and boys read this cr@p in front of each other?


An upright and honest officer banned many of his short stories which were intended to be published in a magazine, he was demonized and presented as a villain in a recent movie about manto.

View attachment 462670
@Desert Fox

The guy chaudhry hussain mentioned in this attachment who was against mantos vulgarity and was depicted negatively in manto biopic drama , watch these two timestamps to see how they showed him

23::18-27-5

Second time stamp from below video

2-52-5-52

@Desert Fox

 

[AZADPAKISTAN2009]

A bit overthe top Sexual encounter between man and virgin women on a rainy wet Summer



How much tharak can be allowed is debatable, I never remember reading anything remotely close to this item before in school perhaps on internet website

It's debatable considering Belly Dancing is a cultural aspect across North Africa(open and public affair) and Arabia (behind closed doors) from Morocco , Tunis , Libya, Egypt , Turkey , Gulf countries (in homes and priavte parties) ....such and such

Some may consider it feminine some may say it is over the top
For me I don't see an issue with Belly Dancers I find them irreresistable

But would a 14-15 year old should be reading about Sexual encounter in a grade 9 short story hmmm interesting talk point

 

[Tps43]

A bit overthe top Sexual encounter between man and virgin women on a rainy wet Summer

How can u say the woman was virgin?

 

[punit]

ohhh bhai its manto if they are kids why they are here ? manto wrrite like this buy it or leave it ۔ ye afsaana boo
بُو
se hai

Boo
Thanda gosht
Salwar khol do.

 

[AZADPAKISTAN2009]

How can u say the woman was virgin?

Trust me she was virgin it was stated in the script but in a articulate way

 

[Tps43]

Trust me she was virgin it was stated in the script but in a articulate way

Ok if u say so

 

[AZADPAKISTAN2009]

If there is Doubt ask Manto

I can see this being a Metric question 10 marks if you can figure out it was a the first encounter

 

[Desert Fox]

The guy chaudhry hussain mentioned in this attachment who was against mantos vulgarity and was depicted negatively in manto biopic drama , watch these two timestamps to see how they showed him

23::18-27-5

Second time stamp from below video

2-52-5-52

@Desert Fox

The fact that nobody in Pakistan has yet torched these production studios is testament that we as a nation have accepted this as a norm.

 

[Skies]

Dont know what is written but It's Ramazan pls