In world’s biggest democracy, parliament doesn’t work

[somebozo]

In world’s biggest democracy, parliament doesn’t work
In world

By JOHN CHALMERS | REUTERS
Published: Nov 30, 2011 20:54 Updated: Nov 30, 2011 20:54

NEW DELHI: India’s parliament has always been a boisterous and chaotic place that, like the country itself, still somehow worked: these days, it’s not even muddling through.

Proceedings have been abruptly called off every day so far since the 21-day winter session of the bicameral parliament opened last week because of the din raised by legislators bawling at each other across the floor of the house.

Open debate is treasured in the world’s largest democracy. However, patience with members of parliament who head off for the day after a few minutes of bellowing is wearing thin. One TV news network asked watchers this week to answer if there should be a new rule for legislators: “No work - no pay.”

An estimated $50,000 in running expenses and MPs’ daily allowances is wasted for every hour of parliamentary time lost. But the biggest cost is caused by the legislature’s failure to introduce, debate and pass bills crucial to the functioning of the state and its economy.

Data compiled by PRS Legislative Research, an independent organization that tracks the functioning of parliament, shows that the government of Prime Minister Manmohan Singh had planned to pass 200 bills over the seven sessions since it was re-elected in 2009, but managed just 57.

Disruptions meant an average of 35 percent of sitting time was lost in the lower house of parliament over those sessions, and 17 percent of the bills passed there were done so after less than five minutes of debate.

“The purpose of parliamentary democracy is to provide a forum for reasoned deliberation,” the Times of India fumed in an editorial. “By wrecking this very platform, MPs can neither resolve contentious issues nor do their jobs as lawmakers.”



Policy paralysis

Amid the logjam, lawmakers found time on Wednesday to call for their status to be upgraded on a list of India’s VIPs. A committee submitted a report that called for MPs to have flashing lights put on their cars that would allow them to speed through the country’s clogged streets, local media reported.

Another recommendation was to teach civil servants to be more courteous to politicians, after “recurrent instances” of protocol violations, the Press Trust of India reported. The committee expressed its “displeasure” at lawmakers’ ranking, which was “much below their status,” the news agency said.

The latest stalemate in parliament has come over Singh’s decision to push through cabinet a new regulation that allows foreign supermarket chains to enter the country’s long-protected retail sector, with opposition lawmakers haranguing the government side from the moment proceedings get underway.

Hobbled by a string of corruption scandals, the government has dithered on reform in its second term, and Singh has lost much of his credibility as the reformer who turned India around from near-bankruptcy 20 years ago to an economic wonder.

The appearance of parliamentary dysfunction only adds to a sense of policy paralysis that puts investors off India at a time of slowing growth.

C.V. Madhukar, director of PRS Legislative Research, argues that the parliamentary rules of engagement need an overhaul. He suggests that India could take a leaf out of the rule book of its former colonial ruler, Britain, where the opposition is allotted 20 days per year when it can set the agenda.

“It’s not like that in India,” he said. “When the opposition wants to raise something the government has to agree.”

© 2010 Arab News

 

[Lyrical Mockery]

wonders of democracy

 

[IndoCarib]

The present logjam is because of FDA in retail move by the ruling UPA. The opposition BJP is just being opportunist. They themselves had mooted this retail FDA move during NDA regime. But there is nothing to worry. Similar deadlocks have happened in the past, and Parliament had sailed through each time. This can not be worse than the nuclear deal with US, when govt almost fell

 

[alphamale]

opposition stalling the parliament for 7 days. it is only possible in a true democracy. some governments in this world don't face any opposition which is the sign of dictatorship.

 

[IndoCarib]

FDI battle: Advani rejects Pranab's offer, impasse continues


Read more at: FDI battle: Advani rejects Pranab's offer, impasse continues

 

[InFn-0]

Few days back the opposition party in South Korea's parliament threw a tear gas inside the parliament, so i guess, the parliament debacles in South Asian countries is not too bad.

 

[The HBS Guy]

It's a part and parcel of democracy.

US senaters are also great at filibustering.

 

[Götterdämmerung]

You know why so far democracy works in Germany and many other European countries? It's because our population is generallty educated and we have the money to distribute. As long as these two factors are not fullfilled it's futile to talk about democracy.

 

[somebozo]

opposition stalling the parliament for 7 days. it is only possible in a true democracy. some governments in this world don't face any opposition which is the sign of dictatorship.

Better a productive government than an incompetent bunch doing nothing but protests..personally i hate protestors..i wish to run them over with tanks!

 

[beijingwalker]

a lot of infighting will surely slow you down.seems like you guys can never agree on anything.

 

[ashokdeiva]

You know why so far democracy works in Germany and many other European countries? It's because our population is generallty educated and we have the money to distribute. As long as these two factors are not fullfilled it's futile to talk about democracy.

Just don't compare a nation of small population such as yours and Indias.
Besides the education and development in your country is because you were a active participant of the INdustrial revolution and we are not.
It will take time for us to attain the level of education that you have attained, but when that happens you'll see not a simple nation but a mighty nation that commands the respect and honor of every nation in the world and that includes both friends and foes.

 

[Götterdämmerung]

Better a productive government than an incompetent bunch doing nothing but protests..personally i hate protestors..i wish to run them over with tanks!

There is nothing wrong to protest as long as it's constructive and ready for compromise.

 

[ashokdeiva]

a lot of infighting will surely slow you down.seems like you guys can never agree on anything.

never in a democracy you can arive at a concensus easily. but when they do it will be a policy for a life time that scrapes all the negatives of action.

 

[Zulkarneyn]

Just don't compare a nation of small population such as yours and Indias.
Besides the education and development in your country is because you were a active participant of the INdustrial revolution and we are not.
It will take time for us to attain the level of education that you have attained, but when that happens you'll see not a simple nation but a mighty nation that commands the respect and honor of every nation in the world and that includes both friends and foes.

True, but we gotta wait a long time for that day to come. With India's current gdp per capita and development, India will make it to industrialized level in maybe 60 years...

 

[alphamale]

Better a productive government than an incompetent bunch doing nothing but protests..personally i hate protestors..i wish to run them over with tanks!

i think ur mindset is very much influenced by the laws of land where u live. democracy is not a piece of cake for ppl like u. ppl like u like dictators over ur head.