If surgical strike was real, why didn't India have the capability to prevent Manipur ambush in 2015?

[Kamikaze Pilot]

If surgical strike was real, why didn't India have the capability to prevent Manipur ambush in 2015?

The supposed cross-LOC surgical strike involved great planning and intelligence gathering. If India indeed had such capability, why couldn't it prevent the simple Manipur ambush in 2015?

 

[Hammad Arshad Qureshi]

Lol becareful you are inviting the wrath of Modi and Raw trolls to unleash on you haha

 

[Chhatrapati]

If america was super power why couldn't they prevent 9/11.

If Pakistan was fighting terrorism, why couldn't they prevent Peshawar School attack.

If UK was so powerful and one of P-5 why the couldn't prevent London bombings.

Answer to all these is intelligence failure.

Rather than opening these kind of threads, do some surfing and post some news that everybody can read. Or make some plausible threads where discussions are possible rather than opening a troll thread to invite trolls.

Where is his echo-chamber Bharat Muslim?

 

[AnnoyingOrange]

If surgical strike was real, why didn't India have the capability to prevent Manipur ambush in 2015?

The supposed cross-LOC surgical strike involved great planning and intelligence gathering. If India indeed had such capability, why couldn't it prevent the simple Manipur ambush in 2015?

Do you know what happened after that... India entered Myanmar and destroyed the whole fucking camp... You can not check Ambush.... but you can retaliate as hell...
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2015_Indian_counter-insurgency_operation_in_Myanmar

 

[Hammad Arshad Qureshi]

If america was super power why couldn't they prevent 9/11.

If Pakistan was fighting terrorism, why couldn't they prevent Peshawar School attack.

If UK was so powerful and one of P-5 why the couldn't prevent London bombings.

Answer to all these is intelligence failure.

Rather than opening these kind of threads, do some surfing and post some news that everybody can read. Or make some plausible threads where discussions are possible rather than opening a troll thread to invite trolls.

Ok then I am going to ask you one tactical question instead. If surgical strike was real and as effective as indian government mentioned it was then what had India achieved? Has militant attacks in Kashmir stopped? Has cross border shelling by Pakistan stopped. So genius in dehli thought it would be wise to perform surgical strikes on unknown mountains then to strike Hafiz Saeed living few KM away from wahagah border in Lahore? Instead of eliminating leadership they decided to kill unknown militants lol?

 

[AnnoyingOrange]

Ok then I am going to ask you one tactical question instead. If surgical strike was real and as effective as indian government mentioned it was then what had India achieved? Has militant attacks in Kashmir stopped? Has cross border shelling by Pakistan stopped. So genius in dehli thought it would be wise to perform surgical strikes on unknown mountains then to strike Hafiz Saeed living few KM away from wahagah border in Lahore? Instead of eliminating leadership they decided to kill unknown militants lol?

Surgical Strike did what it was intended to .. it shocked Pakistani Military leadership... now they will always be on lookout for something like that in near future... look how it has impacted Pakistan global image... so much so that Pakistani leadership is running like headless chicken..
In Kashmir.. we are killing terrorists at the rate of 2 a day.. that is amazzing for us...

 

[Chhatrapati]

Tactical question. If surgical strike was real and as effective as indian government mentioned it was then what had India achieved? Has militant attacks in Kashmir stopped?

You call that a tactical question. Great.

Has cross border shelling by Pakistan stopped. So genius in dehli thought it would be wise to perform surgical strikes on unknown mountains then to strike Hafiz Saeed living few KM away from wahagah border in Lahore? Instead of eliminating leadership they decided to kill unknown militants lol?

I can ask the same question about TTP. Do they still exist? Has attacks on pak soil stopped? LOL!

 

[Hammad Arshad Qureshi]

Surgical Strike did what it was intended to .. it shocked Pakistani Military leadership... now they will always be on lookout for something like that in near future... look how it has impacted Pakistan global image... so much so that Pakistani leadership is running like headless chicken..
In Kashmir.. we are killing terrorists at the rate of 2 a day.. that is amazzing for us...

Lol the only people it shocked were the Indian Civilians living close to international border. As soon as they heard of surgical strikes they decided to run for their lives.
And dude I know you Indians are inspired by Nazi Germany propaganda minister Joseph Gobbles but 2 per day is completely false statement. Or if you are doing that then this means that there is an uprising of massive scale in IOK where hundred of thousands of public has picked up guns against Indian state. which is again In favour of Pakistan. So it's a win win situation for Pakistan in any case if we agree or disagree with your comment.

You call that a tactical question. Great.


I can ask the same question about TTP. Do they still exist? Has attacks on pak soil stopped? LOL!

Well we never made claims that we have crossed inside Afghanistan and did this or that. But always respect the border between Afghanistan and Pakistan in some moments we retaliate the same way we retaliate the Indian forces on LOC via Artillery and mortor fire.
But problem I find with Indian claim is instead of targeting the leadership they decided to strike unknown targets and I am still trying to make sense of it. And more I think of it the more i feels it is a bogus claim from Indian side

 

[Chhatrapati]

Well we never made claims that we have crossed inside Afghanistan and did this or that. But always respect the border between Afghanistan and Pakistan in some moments we retaliate the same way we retaliate the Indian forces on LOC via Artillery and mortor fire.
But problem I find with Indian claim is instead of targeting the leadership they decided to strike unknown targets and I am still trying to make sense of it.

Hmm, you backtracked from stopping attacks.

The purpose of attack is not stopping the infiltration once and for all but sending a message.

Since pathankot, how many serious attacks on Indian bases have happened?

The ceasefire violations are dealt in another suitable way. Infiltration are dealt in it's own respective way.

 

[Hammad Arshad Qureshi]

Hmm, you backtracked from stopping attacks.

The purpose of attack is not stopping the infiltration once and for all but sending a message.

Since pathankot, how many serious attacks on Indian bases have happened?

The ceasefire violations are dealt in another suitable way. Infiltration are dealt in it's own respective way.

Wow this is the best defense you can come up with. Sending a message?
And how is the sending of message actually worked? And maybe you are mistaken after Pathankot , Uri had happened and after URI Indians have decided to perform the famous surgical operation. And after that there were countless attacks by insurgents in kashmir. And still ongoing attacks . The insurgency had not died off. But instead it is gaining momentum.
And again I want to ask you the question. What better way was there to send message to Pakistan then to attack Hafiz Saeed living few KM away from border then attacking unknown mountains? Please elaborate.

This question makes no sense, but there is an answer.

..because executing a cross border ambush/strike is easier than preventing an ambush.

put another way, it is easier to shoot someone with a gun that it is to dodge a bullet when being shot at.

the strike was real, and not the first time such an operation had been carried out, just the first time it was made public.

it hasn't stopped the cross border jihadi terror because the ISI/pak army uses punjabi wahabi cannon foder scum, of which they have no shortage of, to try and hurt India. The daura-e-khas trained loons have zero regard for their life, a suicide mission is their ticket to islamic heaven.

it was never meant to stop the cross border jihad, just to send a message.

@wazz @The Eagle for your kind review of involving and defaming religion thank you.

 

[Flash_Ninja]

the death craving punjabis your army trains and sends over believe in exactly that, that is factually correct.

700,000 soldiers cant even stop some "suicidal punjabis", and yet somehow you people believe you have the capabilities to do a cross border raid.

Talk about delusion

 

[Chhatrapati]

What better way was there to send message to Pakistan then to attack Hafiz Saeed living few KM away from border then attacking unknown mountains? Please elaborate.

Again you are clinging to the same stuff. We don't have the capability to go deep into Pakistan. The strike was close to the LOC, not deep inside your country.

And we want Hafiz Saeed alive, not dead. Let him spill the beans we wanna know who all are involved.

And by sending a message, of course, how many attacks have been followed after the strike on Indian bases? There may be still insurgents, but neither of them dare an attack on army posts. Although many of them now try to infiltrate into Kashmir. Cause internal scuffles rather than engaging the army.

 

[recon scout]

700,000 soldiers cant even stop some "suicidal punjabis", and yet somehow you people believe you have the capabilities to do a cross border raid.

Talk about delusion

the delusion is entirely on your end if you think that your establishment does not use these zealots as cannon fodder to throw across the border.

 

[Flash_Ninja]

the delusion is entirely on your end if you think that your establishment does not use these zealots as cannon fodder to throw across the border.

Yeah because Burhan Wani and Zakir Musa are Punjabi Pakistanis.

Face it, your moronic occupation policies led to people becoming unhappy and joining in the resistance. The stone throwers, Pakistani flag wavers, and militants are all born and bred in IOK.

 

[El Sidd]

Surgical strikes are not a Bollywood movie. It is a tactical term.

What Sanskrit level of shizz is this?

Are you guys like owning a phrase?
Way to go atleast Bongladeshiz chose a fish named hilsa.

Indians