What's new

Huge ancient shipyard unearthed on Turkey’s Dana Island

I'm calling Bull for that, Troy was no where near Etruria.

Well you dont know history so i dont blame you. Aeneas was from troy. He is seen as founding ancestor of rome. When troy did fall Aeneas led an expedition force to the italian peninsula with survivors. Romulus and Remus are seen as part of his family line.

You do realize that it was only a 8 day trip per ship back then? We are talking about the Mediterranean. How long do you think needed our troops to reach egypt when we conquered it? I tell you, exactly 5 days.

They aren't pyramids dumbass, More like over Glorified step-stones. Plus at the least the Pyramids of Giza are standing unlike your stupid step-stones.

P.S We have Monuments older then the Pyramids of Giza.


The Sphinx Enclosure:

Following a detailed examination of the severe, undulating erosion on the walls of the Sphinx enclosure, Dr Robert Schoch, together with other geologists and geophysicists, concluded that the Sphinx had been weathered mainly by rainfall before the Sahara became a desert, and must therefore be at least 7-9000 years old. Since we do not know exactly how much rainfall there has been in the distant past, the Sphinx could be of far greater antiquity.

Schoch argued that because the Nile valley experienced the 'Nabtian Fluvial' from 10,000 to 3,000 B.C., that it must have been in this time that the deep fissures in the sphinx enclosure were made.

sphinxerosion.jpg
Robert Bauval and Graham Hancock proposed that the Sphinx may have been built around 10,500 BC, during the last Age of Leo. Anthony West doubts this, because the earth was then in the midst of intense upheavals associated with the end of the last ice age, whereas everything on the Giza Plateau testifies to an advanced, secure, and long-settled civilization. He suggests that the Sphinx may have been built not in the last Age of Leo, but a whole processional cycle earlier, around 36,000 BC, a date more in keeping with the history of Egypt as chronicled by certain Egyptian king lists.

This particular argument sent shock-waves through the Egyptologist establishment, not because of the 10,500 BC date, but more because it was realised that there was no expanation for the erosion. There is little doubt that the Sphinx enclosure was subject to severe erosion in its life-time, and we know from analysis that the limestone blocks retrieved from the dig were used for the nearby Sphinx temple. We are left with conclusion that since it was dug out, the Sphinx must have undergone a prolonged period of rainfall in order to leave it the way it is today. We are told that the region has not suffered such downfalls since at least 3,000 BC, which places the original dig long enough before that time to create such resulting erosion.

Egyptologist John Anthony West argued that the sudden rise of Egyptian civilization in the third millennium BC points to the fact that it was not a new development but a legacy - a carry-over from an earlier, lost civilization. Further evidence of a pre-dynastic construction phase is suggested by the Sphinx Temple, 'Khafre's' Mortuary and Valley Temples, and 'Menkaure's' Mortuary Temple, which were all partly built from huge limestone blocks, weighing hundreds of tons removed during the carving of the Sphinx, and which have suffered similar erosional damage.

No other site in Egypt shows the same type or degree of erosion.

The 'Inventory stella' - Found at Ghiza by Auguste Mariette in the 1850's, in the ruins of the Temple of Isis clearly states that Khufu restored the Sphinx. This stone provides some of the strongest evidence that the Sphinx was constructed before Khufu and not by him. It says:

Long live The King of Upper and Lower Egypt, Khufu, given life

He found the house of Isis, Mistress of the Pyramid, by the side of the hollow of Hwran (The Sphinx)

and he built his pyramid beside the temple of this goddess and he built a pyramid for the King's daughter Henutsen beside this temple.

The place of Hwran Horemakhet is on the South side of the House of Isis, Mistress of the pyramid

He restored the statue, all covered in painting, of the guardian of the atmosphere, who guides the winds with his gaze.

He replaced the back part of the Nemes head-dress, which was missing with gilded stone

The figure of this god, cut in stone, is solid and will last to eternity, keeping its face looking always to the East '(10).

...Which implies that the Sphinx (and a temple to Isis), were extant before Khufu...

While it is believed by traditional Egyptologists that this stella was carved in the 26th dynasty (664-524 BC), the reason why the statement that Khufu restored it is ignored by modern Egyptologists is a mystery, as the other information on it is regarded by the same people as historical fact.

inventory.gif


The 'Dream Stela of Thutmosis IV, who also restored the Sphinx.

In fact, the French Egyptologist and Director General of Excavations and Antiquities for the Egyptian government, Gaston Maspero, who surveyed the Sphinx in the 1920s asserted that:

'The Sphinx stela shows, in line thirteen, the cartouche of Khephren. I believe that to indicate an excavation carried out by that prince, following which, the almost certain proof that the Sphinx was already buried in sand by the time of Khafre and his predecessors'. (5)



Zahi Hawass on the restoration of the Sphinx:

'On the upper part of the body we found old kingdom blocks, of the same quality used to face the causeway of Khafre, reset against a badly weathered old kingdom core'.

The fact that the same Old kingdom blocks (contemporary with Khafre), were not found over the lower courses too, which were protected by sand over most of their life, confirms that the top part of the structure only was restored in the 4th dynasty. Also, and very importantly - the fact that old kingdom blocks had already been re-set against a 'badly weathered' core clearly suggests that the structure was already extant in the 4th dynasty.



Restoration by Thutmosis IV (c.1400 BC): The Dream Stele.

Evidence for Thutmosis IV's campaign is preserved in the so-called dream Stele he erected between the two paws of the Sphinx in ca. 1400 BC. According to the story inscribed in the Stella, the Sphinx spoke to him in a dream and asked the prince to free him from the sand. The Sphinx (Hor-em-Akht) offered in return the crown of Upper and Lower Egypt. It is often quoted as associating the sphinx with Khafre.

When the Dream stele was discovered, however, the lines of text were incomplete, only referring to a “Khaf,” and not the full “Khafra.” The missing syllable “ra” was later added to complete the translation by Thomas Young, on the assumption that the text referred to “Khafra.” Young’s interpretation was based on an earlier facsimile in which the translation reads as follows:

...which we bring for him: oxen... and all the young vegetables; and we shall give praise to Wenofer ...Khaf.... the statue made for Atum-Hor-em-Akhet.

From this story we know that the Sphinx was buried up to its neck again in 1400 BC.


Comment - Apart from the above testimonies, there is no contemporary record of the construction of the sphinx (or the main three Ghiza pyramids), which seems to elude a historical context. It is noted that the sphinx is linked via a causeway, to the pyramid of Khafre, not Khufu.

Erosion Features in the Sphinx enclosure:

Following a detailed examination of the erosion features on the walls of the Sphinx enclosure, Dr Robert Schoch, together with other geologists and geophysicists, concluded that the Sphinx had been weathered mainly by rainfall before the Sahara became a desert, and must therefore be around 7,000 - 9,000 years old. (1)

Schoch argued that because the Nile valley experienced the 'Nabtian Fluvial' from 10,000 to 3,000 B.C., that it must have been in this time that the deep fissures in the sphinx enclosure were made. Schoch and a colleague also took seismic readings to determine sub-surface water penetration in the bedrock of the Sphinx.

(It is known that the pace of water penetration slows the deeper it seeps into the bedrock).

sphinxerosion.jpg
These erosion features have led some people to question the age of the Sphinx.

'They found that their seismic readings showed sub-surface water penetration at six to eight feet deep in the front half, and four feet at the rear. This differential could only be explained by presuming that the Sphinx had been carved in different stages; the head and the forepart first, and the hindquarters last. It is known that the Sphinx has been renovated at least three times in history, and they argue that the rear part was carved by Khafre (Chephren), which accounts for the tradition linking Khafre with the Sphinx'. (1)



sphinxside2.jpg
It is immediately noticeable that the head of the Sphinx is proportionally smaller than the body. It is suggested that this has been caused by the head remaining above the level of the sand whilst the body has been covered over for much of its existence. Re-carving the sand-eroded head has led to a decrease in size over time.
Note - the head is in far better condition than the rest of the body, which was buried for most of its life in sand...

Which has led many to suggest that it may have been re-carved at least once...

http://www.ancient-wisdom.com/egyptsphinx.htm

our stepstones are standing as well.

What is your Problem amigo? Do you have so little in present days, that you need to belittle ones ancestors to feel better? I care about my ancestors, yours are irrelevant for me. Does it change anything for you that my ancestors build temples and pyramides 3000 years before egypt?

You can be proud for yours without belitteling others.

Can you expand on that. Am going to Firenze next spring. Would be interesting to know more about the Etruscans and their cultural affect on regions previously inhabited by them.

the way our cities are build. You see it more on some tuscany cities that the central place is round, which is typical for etruscian style.
 
.
@MarkusS

One example :

What are the ethnic origins of Southern Italians?

Costanza Gallo, born and raised in Rome
Written Aug 8, 2015
Europeans all migrated from Africa thousands of years ago, so on a superficial level, same as other Europens.

Going a bit deeper, there is no such a thing as "Southern Italy", since there are a lot of differences between regions in the South of Italy.

Sicily for instance was colonized by the Scandivian and by the Arabs, so it is a mix. In my family, direct blood line, there are people with crystal clear Arab roots: dark hair and eyes, olive skin, and people who look Swedish: tall, blonde and fair skin.

https://www.quora.com/What-are-the-ethnic-origins-of-Southern-Italians
 
. . . .
build temples and pyramides 3000 years before egypt?

You don't have Pyramids.


There are Numerous things that prove his exsitence like Treaties,Constitution,Letters,Actual Descendants(Not Rumors or Sayings of Romans),Artifacts,etc. Do you have that for Anneas?

Are we talking about the same Anneas that descended from Venus? LOL!

The same Aeneas that had his Patron gods tell him to move to Italy?LOL

The same Aeneas that Juno bribed a Nymph to Make a Storm to kill?LOL

The same Aeneas that landed in Carthage and Juno attempted to keep him there?LOL

The same Aeneas that Jupiter commanded to leave Carthage and sent Mercury to tell him to leave?LOL

The same Aeneas that went down to his dead father in the underworld?LOL

The same Aeneas that got help from the already living Etruscans and an exiled Etruscan king?LOL

So your's is LITERAL mythology.

"In Greco-Roman mythology, Aeneas (/ᵻˈniːəs/;[1] Greek: Αἰνείας, Aineías, possibly derived from Greek αἰνή meaning "praised") was a Trojan hero, the son of the prince Anchises and the goddess Venus (Aphrodite). His father was a first cousin of King Priam of Troy (both being grandsons of Ilus, founder of Troy), making Aeneas a second cousin to Priam's children (such as Hector and Paris). He is a character in Greek mythology and is mentioned in Homer's Iliad. Aeneas receives full treatment in Roman mythology, most extensively in Virgil's Aeneid where he is an ancestor of Romulus and Remus. He became the first true hero of Rome."
 
Last edited:
.
You don't have Pyramids.



There are Numerous things that prove his exsitence like Treaties,Constitution,Letters,Actual Descendants(Not Rumors or Sayings of Romans),Artifacts,etc. Do you have that for Anneas?

Are we talking about the same Anneas that descended from Venus? LOL!

The same Aeneas that had his Patron gods tell him to move to Italy?LOL

The same Aeneas that Juno bribed a Nymph to Make a Storm to kill?LOL

The same Aeneas that landed in Carthage and Juno attempted to keep him there?LOL

The same Aeneas that Jupiter commanded to leave Carthage and sent Mercury to tell him to leave?LOL

The same Aeneas that went down to his dead father in the underworld?LOL

The same Aeneas that got help from the already living Etruscans and an exiled Etruscan king?LOL

So your's is LITERAL mythology.

"In Greco-Roman mythology, Aeneas (/ᵻˈniːəs/;[1] Greek: Αἰνείας, Aineías, possibly derived from Greek αἰνή meaning "praised") was a Trojan hero, the son of the prince Anchises and the goddess Venus (Aphrodite). His father was a first cousin of King Priam of Troy (both being grandsons of Ilus, founder of Troy), making Aeneas a second cousin to Priam's children (such as Hector and Paris). He is a character in Greek mythology and is mentioned in Homer's Iliad. Aeneas receives full treatment in Roman mythology, most extensively in Virgil's Aeneid where he is an ancestor of Romulus and Remus. He became the first true hero of Rome."

Did Aeneas fly with a horse in one night to Jerusalem? Whats the difference in talking with Jupiter or get a book dictated by another god? :)

And yes we do have pyramides.

Our own on sardinia and even those great, useless ones in egypt...when we made it our province and corn chamber.

Does it hurt your little heart when you realize that egypt was longer a roman province than any egyptian dynasty lasted? :)
 
.
Did Aeneas fly with a horse in one night to Jerusalem? Whats the difference in talking with Jupiter or get a book dictated by another god? :)

And yes we do have pyramides.

Our own on sardinia and even those great, useless ones in egypt...when we made it our province and corn chamber.

Does it hurt your little heart when you realize that egypt was longer a roman province than any egyptian dynasty lasted? :)

You can consider that a intepretation of him travelling really fast and it was emblished and lot's of other things but YOUR IS LITERAL MYTHOLOGY AND IS FAKE!

It is acknowledged and recongized as fake and a Myth,stop clinging to it. You are not the descendants of Troy especially considering that during that time Escrutans already existed as said in the Story. It is a story, stop pretending it is fact.


Sardinia is a shit hole and a bunch of step-stones. Don't delusion yourself with your bullshit.

Also those Pyramids of Giza belong to Egyptians not you bumbling idiots. We were also a province of ROME not a colony of ITALY idiot. You can claim anything you want from Ethopia. But Grandpa rome is different from Fragile Weakling Italy that has lost nearly every battle it has ever fought in even FRANCE HAS WON MORE BATTLES THEN YOU!
 
Last edited:
.
You can consider that a intepretation of him travelling really fast and it was emblished and lot's of other things but YOUR IS LITERAL MYTHOLOGY AND IS FAKE!

It is acknowledged and recongized as fake and a Myth,stop clinging to it. You are not the descendants of Troy especially considering that during that time Escrutans already existed as said in the Story. It is a story, stop pretending it is fact.


Sardinia is a shit hole and a bunch of step-stones. Don't delusion yourself with your bullshit.

Also those Pyramids of Giza belong to Egyptians not you bumbling idiots. We were also a province of ROME not a colony of ITALY idiot. You can claim anything you want from Ethopia. But Grandpa rome is different from Fragile Weakling Italy that has lost nearly every battle it has ever fought in even FRANCE HAS WON MORE BATTLES THEN YOU!


Sardinia a shithole? Sardinia is considered one of most beautiful places on this planet and a top tourst destination in europe.

If you call Sardinia a shithole...how would you label any place in egypt?

I assume you dont mean Sardinia as whole but the monuments from that time period. Keep in mind they are 3000 years older than anything in egypt. There are no know artifacts in egypt with that age.

Also i like to add that we have more egyptian artifacts in italy than egypt has itself.

You know who bombed the pyramide open? italian adventurer Belzoni. He used dynamite to gain entry and took what he could get.


I would like to bring one thing up amigo, why are you so desperate and negative? Do you feel so small and sad about your peoples fate that you try to belittle my ancestors?

I love our history and my ancestors, just as you like yours.

Our countries share much history. Your country for many hundred years was an important part of our empire. Our people lived together and shared culture ect.

I saw mummy portraits from the roman time period and its so amazing because how realistic it looks. Also amazing to see how egyptians lived in the roman period.

593766046_8f3a3e526c.jpg


db2e202df950401e4b7bc3db5c1ea3a1.jpg


It is not up to you what we consider our ancestors. We decide that my friend. I see our ancestors as mix of etruscians and troy. All my people saw it always that way and its a story deep in our hearts.

In your signature you quote a famours greek philosopher:

"“Any man may easily do harm, but not every man can do good to another.”
― Plato"

Maybe you should learn this advice and be more positive.
 
.
Sardinia a shithole? Sardinia is considered one of most beautiful places on this planet and a top tourst destination in europe.

If you call Sardinia a shithole...how would you label any place in egypt?

I assume you dont mean Sardinia as whole but the monuments from that time period. Keep in mind they are 3000 years older than anything in egypt. There are no know artifacts in egypt with that age.

Also i like to add that we have more egyptian artifacts in italy than egypt has itself.

You know who bombed the pyramide open? italian adventurer Belzoni. He used dynamite to gain entry and took what he could get.


I would like to bring one thing up amigo, why are you so desperate and negative? Do you feel so small and sad about your peoples fate that you try to belittle my ancestors?

I love our history and my ancestors, just as you like yours.

Our countries share much history. Your country for many hundred years was an important part of our empire. Our people lived together and shared culture ect.

I saw mummy portraits from the roman time period and its so amazing because how realistic it looks. Also amazing to see how egyptians lived in the roman period.

593766046_8f3a3e526c.jpg


db2e202df950401e4b7bc3db5c1ea3a1.jpg


It is not up to you what we consider our ancestors. We decide that my friend. I see our ancestors as mix of etruscians and troy. All my people saw it always that way and its a story deep in our hearts.

In your signature you quote a famours greek philosopher:

"“Any man may easily do harm, but not every man can do good to another.”
― Plato"

Maybe you should learn this advice and be more positive.

When did I hate on the Romans? I respect your ancestors but you have to learn to respect mines. Egypt has tons of Temples. and Monuments that date 4000-6000+ years old so don't presume yours is the oldest.

You should also learn that claiming other peoples heritage is an insult to them and their ancestors who had nothing to do with yours.


oct2015_d06_pyramids.jpg__800x600_q85_crop.jpg






This is what my ancestors made, simply because your ancestors conquered it does not make it yours. If you do not wish to be treated negatively then do not make such Ridiculous remarks.
 
.
When did I hate on the Romans? I respect your ancestors but you have to learn to respect mines. Egypt has tons of Temples. and Monuments that date 4000-6000+ years old so don't presume yours is the oldest.

You should also learn that claiming other peoples heritage is an insult to them and their ancestors who had nothing to do with yours.


oct2015_d06_pyramids.jpg__800x600_q85_crop.jpg






This is what my ancestors made, simply because your ancestors conquered it does not make it yours. If you do not wish to be treated negatively then do not make such Ridiculous remarks.

The temple on that island is the Philae temple. It was build in roman times. The other temple you show is the temple in Edfu, build shortly before under greek rule.

So at least those two temples you showed here are an example of shared history between our people.

You know how you can see the difference? Look at the walls, when i visited egypt out guide explained it. In roman times we prefered it easy, That means the pictures were simply carved into the stone. In pure egyptian times before that they made it more complicated. They removed the stone around it so the figures are higher than the stone around it. That was far more hard work than in roman times.

The rason is our emperors had not such close connection to your old gods and the temples bulld there were build with lower quality to speed up the process.

I dont presume mine as the oldest. Archaeologists say that monument on Sardinia is one of oldest in world.

It was build by my ancestors and when you use bad words towards it do you think that feels nice? I know its not so big as the pyramides in egypt but it withstand such a long time and was special for our ancestors so its also special for me.
 
.
@EgyptianAmerican

btw dont know how much you are into history. But do you know that the roman emperor automatically had the title as pharao from egypt?

When the persians conquered egypt they exploited it brutal. They showed zero respect. I think you know they killed your ancestors holy animals and destroyed temples.

When rome conquered egypt it did not do that. My ancestors were interested in it and integrated egypt into our empire. It was not just a provice. Alexandria for example propably was under the top 3 cities of the empire.

When a roman emperor visited egypt he tried to fullfill his duty as pharao.

This was very hard to do because its a totally different culture.

He led festivals for egyptian gods. Offered tribute to egyptian gods.

And even dressed like a Pharao. Which not always worked 100%.

as far as i know egyotian pharao shaved their head, right? A roman did not do that...so the egyptian crown looked a bit funny like a baseball cap:

db1e238d6483c2b2fed144e9e755b973.jpg


So i hope you at least admitt that our ancestors share much history. That it was with much respect and a good time. :)
 
.

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom