How PTI managed Economic Crisis in his time?

[AZ1]

https://twitter.com/x/status/1631295468662673409

 

[fisher1]

>IMF loan
>Saudi loan
>Covid loan
>Loan loan loan
> Zero development projects

Mughl e Azam = mey prices control karne k lye mughl e Azam nahi bana

Difference this time is no country is willing to give us loans because they know this government is short lived.

PDM puppets decided to take the suicide mission for I don’t know why, probably blackmailed that they would be exposed. Everyone with half a brain knew that IK govt ouster was a favour upon him and breathing a new life into his politics. I just don’t know why PDM agreed to this suicide.

 

[AZ1]

>IMF loan
>Saudi loan
>Loan loan loan
> Zero development projects

Mughl e Azam = mey prices control karne k lye mughl e Azam nahi bana

Difference this time is no country is willing to give us loans because they know this government is short lived.

PDM puppets decided to take the suicide mission for I don’t know why, probably blackmailed that they would be exposed. Everyone with half a brain knew that IK govt ouster was a favour upon him and breathing a new life into his politics. I just don’t know why PDM agreed to this suicide.

Reserves $16 Billion
exports $30 Billion
remittance $29 Billion
GDP 5.9%

You dont have stats nor you are interested in learning due to obivious reason. If you have stats come and post otherwise your words would be just words due to your political hate towards imran khan thats call bughz

Dams are not development projects but metro lahore train development where pmln took loan of $1.6 billion and every year for 12 years $40 million as interest would be added and are now running on subsidies total $2.3 Billion this train cost with zero $ return earning and will run for ever on subsidy. Sherrrrrr, visionnn

As i said pmln supporter are enemy of pakistan and ever wonder why no country willing to give loan? because they are not blind and can see this govt is corrupt and second Dar manipulation and lies to Imf keeoing dollar 225 by burning reserves like in 2018. You cant fool ppl all the time.

 

[fisher1]

As i said pmln supporter are enemy of pakistan

This is why I will not engage with you. Stop lying, and have some honesty. The only party I ever supported was PTI and IK is the only person I voted for. I have told you this before but you keep making lies.

 

[AZ1]

This is why I will not engage with you. Stop lying, and have some honesty. The only party I ever supported was PTI and IK is the only person I voted for. I have told you this before but you keep making lies.

when did I say you are supporter of pmln here i said as i said pmln supporter are the enemy of pakistan and same goes to ppp supporters

I have pmln supporter friends in my circle i always tell them support the govt who increase our exports, remittance, reserves and if pmln does that i will support them too on this.

Rest are just show if govt cant do this then its useless to have trains, roads on loan where we wouldnt able to return its simple.math

 

[fisher1]

when did I say you are supporter of pmln here i

Finally! Some progress. Glad we established that.

I have pmln supporter friends in my circle i always tell them support the govt who increase our exports, remittance, reserves and if pmln does that i will support them too on this.

I tell my friends to abandon elections because there’s no difference between either of them. Remittance isn’t any achievement of the govt, it’s just expats sending money to Pakistan. GDP growth also doesn’t tell the whole story because PTI had negative gdp growth then it bounced back because it was down so long

Pakistan GDP Annual Growth Rate

The Gross Domestic Product (GDP) in Pakistan contracted 0.17 percent in the fourth quarter of 2023 over the same quarter of the previous year. This page provides - Pakistan GDP Annual Growth Rate - actual values, historical data, forecast, chart, statistics, economic calendar and news.

tradingeconomics.com

The real criteria is which party has reduced loans or paid off loans. That’s what it boils down to.

Pakistan Total External Debt

External Debt in Pakistan increased to 130502 USD Million in the second quarter of 2024 from 130412 USD Million in the first quarter of 2024. This page provides - Pakistan External Debt - actual values, historical data, forecast, chart, statistics, economic calendar and news.

tradingeconomics.com

You can take loans after loans and show good gdp, good economic indicators but that’s all fake, isn’t it? The real indicator is how deep you’re in loans. I don’t see PTI bringing that graph down rather exponentially making it jump. And one of the reasons I voted Ik was because he promised death before he would take loans and I thought nobody can make such a big promise if they weren’t serious.

 

[Imran Khan]

>IMF loan
>Saudi loan
>Covid loan
>Loan loan loan
> Zero development projects

Mughl e Azam = mey prices control karne k lye mughl e Azam nahi bana

Difference this time is no country is willing to give us loans because they know this government is short lived.

PDM puppets decided to take the suicide mission for I don’t know why, probably blackmailed that they would be exposed. Everyone with half a brain knew that IK govt ouster was a favour upon him and breathing a new life into his politics. I just don’t know why PDM agreed to this suicide.

Nope stability is most important rest can be managed . Bajwa isi unstabled the country as army doing since 1948

 

[Waterboy]

Reserves $16 Billion
exports $30 Billion
remittance $29 Billion
GDP 5.9%

You dont have stats nor you are interested in learning due to obivious reason. If you have stats come and post otherwise your words would be just words due to your political hate towards imran khan thats call bughz

Dams are not development projects but metro lahore train development where pmln took loan of $1.6 billion and every year for 12 years $40 million as interest would be added and are now running on subsidies total $2.3 Billion this train cost with zero $ return earning and will run for ever on subsidy. Sherrrrrr, visionnn

As i said pmln supporter are enemy of pakistan and ever wonder why no country willing to give loan? because they are not blind and can see this govt is corrupt and second Dar manipulation and lies to Imf keeoing dollar 225 by burning reserves like in 2018. You cant fool ppl all the time.

GDP growth is not a measure of economy. That 5.9% GDP growth is part of the boom and bust cycle where we subsidize imports and consumption based GDP grows. Eventually we have a large trade deficit and we have another economic crisis.

We run towards the IMF with the tail between our legs, devaluing the currency and unleashing new waves of unprecedented inflation. Impose more indirect taxation, give amnesty schemes and subsidize industries of seths.

Rinse and repeat. Literally whether it's PTI or PMLN it's a clusterfuck because no one actually wants to structurally change the system. Even PTI doesn't have an economic policy and shuakat tarin is in the same league as dar.

jo marzi kursi par ajai, hawai loray hi lagnai hain

 

[AZ1]

Finally! Some progress. Glad we established that.



I tell my friends to abandon elections because there’s no difference between either of them. Remittance isn’t any achievement of the govt, it’s just expats sending money to Pakistan. GDP growth also doesn’t tell the whole story because PTI had negative gdp growth then it bounced back because it was down so long

Pakistan GDP Annual Growth Rate

The Gross Domestic Product (GDP) in Pakistan contracted 0.17 percent in the fourth quarter of 2023 over the same quarter of the previous year. This page provides - Pakistan GDP Annual Growth Rate - actual values, historical data, forecast, chart, statistics, economic calendar and news.

tradingeconomics.com

The real criteria is which party has reduced loans or paid off loans. That’s what it boils down to.

Pakistan Total External Debt

External Debt in Pakistan increased to 130502 USD Million in the second quarter of 2024 from 130412 USD Million in the first quarter of 2024. This page provides - Pakistan External Debt - actual values, historical data, forecast, chart, statistics, economic calendar and news.

tradingeconomics.com

You can take loans after loans and show good gdp, good economic indicators but that’s all fake, isn’t it? The real indicator is how deep you’re in loans. I don’t see PTI bringing that graph down rather exponentially making it jump. And one of the reasons I voted Ik was because he promised death before he would take loans and I thought nobody can make such a big promise if they weren’t serious.

Wrong, pti worked on remittance specially overseas pakistani are assets and make huge impact Roshan digital account is example of pti works on remittance. Dollar is what we need better to have as remittance rather taking more loans

We have grown from $24 Billion to $30 Billion in exports that is progress if not then what is? pti also set target to take it to $37 Billion by 2022-2023

Imran khan made promise in 2013 while pakistan almost bankrupt by 2018 due to dar used all our reserves just like he did now but people are now well aware "Shaour" is what imran khan has given to the nation and its a big gift.

You should see his 2018 august video with arshad sharif interview on ary before he was going to take oath he said we have to go imf now no money left by pmln. before going to imf he tried to manage loan from other as well saudia, china so that can manage negotiation with imf took him 3-4 months

GDP growth is not a measure of economy. That 5.9% GDP growth is part of the boom and bust cycle where we subsidize imports and consumption based GDP grows. Eventually we have a large trade deficit and we have another economic crisis.

We run towards the IMF with the tail between our legs, devaluing the currency and unleashing new waves of unprecedented inflation. Impose more indirect taxation, give amnesty schemes and subsidize industries of seths.

Rinse and repeat. Literally whether it's PTI or PMLN it's a clusterfuck because no one actually wants to structurally change the system. Even PTI doesn't have an economic policy and shuakat tarin is in the same league as dar.

jo marzi kursi par ajai, hawai loray hi lagnai hain

idher udher na ghomao why pmln never worked on exports? they made our country based on import and kept cutting down our exports.
All nawaz cared and talk in meeting was nihari pai non serious guy love with food this is what a cabinet guy said when he was there in the meeting with nawaz.

 

[Ssan]

PDM folk don’t care about numbers. The numbers you throw at them, they swat off like flies.

Lekin SHHHHEEEERRRRR!!!!

 

[fisher1]

Wrong, pti worked on remittance specially overseas pakistani are assets and make huge impact Roshan digital account is example of pti works on remittance. Dollar is what we need better to have as remittance rather taking more loans

We have grown from $24 Billion to $30 Billion in exports that is progress if not then what is? pti also set target to take it to $37 Billion by 2022-2023

Imran khan made promise in 2013 while pakistan almost bankrupt by 2018 due to dar used all our reserves just like he did now but people are now well aware "Shaour" is what imran khan has given to the nation and its a big gift.

You should see his 2018 august video with arshad sharif interview on ary before he was going to take oath he said we have to go imf now no money left by pmln. before going to imf he tried to manage loan from other as well saudia, china so that can manage negotiation with imf took him 3-4 months

All this is just cultist talk from you, PTI was so vicious and draconian that they tried to tax remittances.

What matters is loans and boy oh boy, did PTI take loans and then some. This is the same party that came to power by promising that they would commit suicide, that they felt ashamed when they saw other leaders sit in Saudia begging and then we saw IK become a cheap driver of MBS, the shame.

Pakistan wouldn’t be in this mess today if PTI had paid off loans like they promised and not taken anymore but we all know what happened.

If PTI was so good and different, tell me why did they add to the burden of loans? and what did they do with those loans since no mega project has been done by PTI

 

[AZ1]

All this is just cultist talk from you, PTI was so vicious and draconian that they tried to tax remittances.

What matters is loans and boy oh boy, did PTI take loans and then some. This is the same party that came to power by promising that they would commit suicide, that they felt ashamed when they saw other leaders sit in Saudia begging and then we saw IK become a cheap driver of MBS, the shame.

Pakistan wouldn’t be in this mess today if PTI had paid off loans like they promised and not taken anymore but we all know what happened.

If PTI was so good and different, tell me why did they add to the burden of loans? and what did they do with those loans since no mega project has been done by PTI

this is what you think but stats said otherwise you cant expect exports go grow overnight it takes decades and continously increase with stability of govt take example of bangladesh.

"Mai na mano baat se kuch nahi hota"

2nd you said you voted for pti and i have never seen you posted anything against pmln or pdm, a friend of mine is just like that from inside he is with pmln and pdm and were crying out loud when inflation just 12% and today is 31% and he is no where to be seen. May be this is the case let me know if you ever posted against pmln like you do against pti

 

[fisher1]

2nd you said you voted for pti and i have never seen you posted anything against pmln or pdm, a friend of mine is just like that from inside he is with pmln and pdm and were crying out loud when inflation just 12% and today is 31% and he is no where to be seen. May be this is the case let me know if you ever posted against pmln like you do against pti

Probably because you ignore posts where I speak against other parties and get mad when I criticise PTI.

PTI also tends to be in news a lot, literally everyday is a speech on TV so they get the most attention.

 

[AZ1]

Probably because you ignore posts where I speak against other parties and get mad when I criticise PTI.

PTI also tends to be in news a lot, literally everyday is a speech on TV so they get the most attention.

Imran khan is most popular leader today more than bhutto thats why.

 

[Thevilone]

In my opinion PTI got lucky. Covid hit and that gaave the govt. some breathing space because most lenders became extremely lenient.

During their tenure, they kept on taking loans. Pakistan was on path to default by 2018, but PTI made sure that recovery would be very very slow by taking immense loans @USD 17 billion every single year. https://theprint.in/world/imran-khans-erstwhile-government-procured-usd-52-billion-in-loans/958873/ I believe Pakistan would take 2-3 decades to fully recover from this crisis, especially considering the CPEC payments to be made every single year. At least one generation would live in extreme poverty which is only seen in sub-Saharan Africa.

Every time there was an economic issue, IK simply replaced the Finance Minister, this reshuffling meant that every Finance minister was only looking at 2-3 months at a time and could never take strong unpopular decisions which were crucial for a possible recovery. When the history of Pakistan's default is written, the period of 2015-2023 would be most important, from the year CPEC started to the year of the default.