What's new

How many Indians have reservations or are opposed to Citizenship Amendment Bill?

Are you as an Indian or a Pakistani opposed to the India wide NRC or Citizenship Amendment Bill?

  • Indian Muslim and I support nationwide NRC

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Indian Non-Muslim and I support nationwide NRC

    Votes: 7 31.8%
  • Indian Muslim and I donot support Nationwide NRC

    Votes: 2 9.1%
  • Indian Non-Muslim and I donot support Nationwide NRC

    Votes: 4 18.2%
  • Pakistani and I support Nationwide NRC

    Votes: 5 22.7%
  • Pakistani and I donot support Nationwide NRC

    Votes: 4 18.2%

  • Total voters
    22
  • This poll will close: .
Its not our Problem .. They choose it for themselves, no pity or sympathy for those who's ancestors hate and abuse Jinnah .

Its more of ethnic issue. India want to run over NE states with gangu hindus. But BJP rather turn in to hindu vs muslim for politics. Remember how BJP home state Gujarat beat up people from north India recently? Hell Maharashtra shiv sena government hate north Indian migrants. But its ok to do ethnic cleansing of NE states because they are weak.
 
.
The best thing to have ever happened is the complete lack of terror attacks on civilians after the 2008 Mumbai attacks...previously what used to happen is 20 or so mostly Hindus would get killed in a bomb blast which would lead to 50-60 Muslims getting killed in return ...In the attack of Mumbai, big banking billionaires like Yes Bank chiefs got killed..This led to complete revamp of anti-terror monitoring...for the longest time therefore there has not been any Hindu-Muslim riot with 100+ killed, and it would stay that way in the near future...revamping of security measures in order to protect the richest of Hindus has led to a lot of security for the most vulnerable of Muslims

You must have somehow gotten mixed up in your replies. Because that was not a reply to my post.
 
.
The purpose of bill is simple. To deport muslims only who were half of those found in recent such verification.
 
.
The purpose of bill is simple. To deport muslims only who were half of those found in recent such verification.


The tensions in the North-East is ethnic and not religious...North East people especially North East tribal people hate outsiders especially Bengalis...The recent Assam only NRC netted more Bengali HIndus as non-citizens..CAB bill is a way to fast track their citizenship in India and to resettle them elsewhere
 
.
An elite class that is not sympathetic to the needs of the people and on top of that wholly and fully unproductive.

I voted :
Indian Muslim and I do not support Nationwide NRC

And as you pointed out, the problem that is regional here is climate change.

Also particularly in the case of India, an elite bureaucracy doesn't seem to solve such simple issues like farmer suicides. Add to that the apathy of the middle class.

@The_Showstopper , please add your vote.
 
.
Nationwide NRC is a waste of resources tbh. Better ways to weed out illegal BDeshis should be made possible. Say check the migrant labors, who come in droves.
 
. . .
I am getting the first details. I mean let's be honest here, it will unnecessarily harass those parts of the population that have very little access and very little understanding of official documents. It's kind of targeted against Muslims, but as in the NRC Assam case a lot of Hindus also got caught in the mix. I could have accepted such a bill after the Modi govt had delivered 15 years of 8%+ growth but not as of now..The biggest problem lurking as leviathan on the borders of the subcontinent is climate change, which will affect 300 million at least, most of them in the Bangladesh,West Bengal region...

If Indian subcontinent doesnot tackle that collectively, a blot will forever remain on the population group of South Asia..Untold suffering wrought upon eachother, as people will be denied to pursue life,liberty and property in higher grounds

It is in this context, that behoves upon Muslims of the subcontinent to tone down Islamic triumphalism and on Hindus to lay off with historical injustices. Either we can be at the frontline of Global climate change or we can be at the mercy of climate change....

Anyways I would want to know whether joint action in subcontinent possible or not, or we will be witness to 200 million unnecessary deaths within in the span of a decade..and a complete collapse of the economy


The Indian subcontinent has some experience of this...The fact that British could stay in the subcontinent for around 150 years instead of say 50 years is because they completely broke the will of the people through repeated famines...Lack of food completely breaks the will of the people and kind of stays on as genetic memory even after food is later procured......Lack of action against climate change means a fate worse than 1980s sub Saharan Africa for a 1,000 years for the subcontinent
Anarchy, as I can sense. Wild animals are dangerous, wild humans, we will now.
 
. .
The tensions in the North-East is ethnic and not religious...North East people especially North East tribal people hate outsiders especially Bengalis...The recent Assam only NRC netted more Bengali HIndus as non-citizens..CAB bill is a way to fast track their citizenship in India and to resettle them elsewhere
NO the recent anti CAB protest is opposed by every one. Infact it is headed by mostly caste assamese people .Tribal areas and states are mostly protected by Inner line permit or other provisions(that is why only symbolic protest in AP-Nagaland-mizoram which are majority tribal land).

CAB Bill is a deft way of masking that Assamese Hindus hate Bengali Hindus..Period
Even the bengalis of Barak Valley are opposing CAB hand in hand with assamese people.Everyone (assamese+bengalis) opposes CAB.period
 
.

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom