What's new

Granting citizenship to Afghan refugees is Pakistan’s internal matter – UNHCR

Kailash Kumar

SENIOR MEMBER
Joined
Oct 8, 2018
Messages
4,643
Reaction score
-1
Country
Suriname
Location
Netherlands
Granting citizenship to Afghan refugees is Pakistan’s internal matter – UNHCR

SIB KAIFEE

February 17, 2020

ISLAMABAD: The United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR) made it clear on Monday that granting citizenship to Afghan refugees is in the Pakistani government’s discretion, as Islamabad has already done much in the past four decades for the world’s second-largest displaced community.

“That is a matter for the Pakistani government to discuss,” UN High Commissioner for Refugees Filippo Grandi told Arab News on the sidelines of an ongoing international summit – 40 Years of Hosting Afghan Refugees in Pakistan – held in Islamabad.

“In general, the measures that have been taken without reaching that level (offering Pakistani citizenship to refugees) have been very positive,” Grandi added, referring to Pakistan’s efforts to provide shelter, protection, and other facilities to persons displaced by conflict in Afghanistan.

Pakistan hosts over 1.4 million Afghan refugees registered with UNHCR, but many others are not registered. It is estimated that some 2 million Afghans have been living in Pakistan.

A citizenship pledge to refugees was made by Prime Minister Imran Khan in 2018, shortly after assuming office. “Afghans whose children have been raised and born in Pakistan will be granted citizenship, inshallah (God willing) because this is the established practice in countries around the world,” he said at the time.

“They are humans. How come we have deprived them and have not arranged for offering them a national identification card and passport for 30 years, 40 years?”

Refugees still hope the premier will deliver on his promise.

Pakistan’s former ambassador to Afghanistan, Rustum Shah, told Arab News that Pakistan should grant the refugees nationality after four decades of hosting them.

“Afghan refugees would continue to stay here. As long as there is no reconciliation there is no peace,” Shah said adding that forced repatriation would be wrong.

“The government of Pakistan must consider giving them nationality now because they have been here for 40 years,” the retired diplomat said.

There was also a video (54 seconds) where the UNHCR talks a bit more about the situation than what is written in the article above.

The video however could not be embedded here.

See the link below for the video.


https://www.arabnews.pk/node/1629221/pakistan
 
.
Not at all . They are in millions not in thousands . They are already involved in getting Fake CNICs ( Which are then restored by courts ) . We have already no jobs in Pakistan . with Movements like PTM coming in KP , Pakistan Afghanistan border fenced not completed >>> granting citizenship at this stage will be a suicide . This Rustam Shah was against Pakistan Afghanistan border fencing as well ( on Aljazeera video 2017 i think )
 
.
Not at all . They are in millions not in thousands . They are already involved in getting Fake CNICs ( Which are then restored by courts ) . We have already no jobs in Pakistan . with Movements like PTM coming in KP , Pakistan Afghanistan border fenced not completed >>> granting citizenship at this stage will be a suicide . This Rustam Shah was against Pakistan Afghanistan border fencing as well ( on Aljazeera video 2017 i think )

Many are born and raised in Pakistan, they wouldnt survive in Afghanistan as they have no knowledge about the place.

If random people on Twitter can find the identities of refugees that are attending anti-state rallies, then it should be easy work for a Federal agency. Maybe a citizenship questionaire and verified references from legal citizens could be enough to weed out all the degenerates.

Then they should offer to resettle them out of Peshawar and Karachi, and into Gwadar, or other SEZ's
 
. . .
Great idea !

But then what those Biharis stranded in Bangladesh would think? They are facing worst persecution, more severe than the kabuli Muhajirs for fighting alongside our boys

Many are born and raised in Pakistan, they wouldnt survive in Afghanistan as they have no knowledge about the place.
Bro are you nuts?
 
. .
.
No under any circumstances

Don't care if they go and starve in Afghanistan but they can't be citizens here, these people have ZERO loyalty to Pakistan
 
.




I don't care what your race, ethnicity or religion is. In order to be given Pakistani citizenship, you have to be fanatically loyal and pro-Pakistani to the core. Alot of afghans living in Pakistan are NOT, however those who are can become Pakistanis.......We will embrace them if they show their loyalty and love for Pakistan.
 
Last edited:
.
But then what those Biharis stranded in Bangladesh would think?
Most of the Afghan refugees are in K-Pk and can easily assimilate into that province. Furthermore they are in Pakistan and not on the other side of the world. There is no war in Bangla and Bihari's are very close to Bengalis. I would even raise a 'Afghanka legion' from the refugees similiar to French Foreign Legion. All recruits get Pak citizenship after service includingtheir families.

Anbd I still hope towards end of his term PMIK gives all Afghans citizenship. Then sails into oblivion ...
 
.
As per natural law that ties man to the place of his birth, they should be given citizenship of Pakistan.

The government is urged to produce robust lawmaking in this regard as to not fall prey to exploitation but natural law must be respected in its entirety if we wish to progress as a Nation.
 
.
I don't care what your race, ethnicity or religion is. In order to be given Pakistani citizenship, you have to be fanatically loyal and pro-Pakistani to the core. afghans living in Pakistan are NOT!!!!!!.

How do you know that? If their only connection to Afghanistan is their parents fleeing from there, how does that make them anti-Pakistani?

No foreigners should not be allowed to serve in Pakistani forces not even in police. And These people would be sent back to their country. For 1 soldiers job dozens or hundreds apply Pakistani government would not hire them.

I agree its too risky, there will always be a risk of them getting trained and joining terrorist groups; but selection should be open to them if they can prove they are just as good as domestic applicants. That's how they do it in the UK.
 
.
The blood that flowss in these men is same that defeated the Soviet Red Army, fought NATO, U Army to standstill and brough many a sultanate over South Asia including Sher Shah Suri. Never forget that. A Afghanka Legion would make a perfect blade in Pakistan Army.

In history it put terror in hearts of many a Hindu ruler ...
 
.
Yet some of their ancestors helped to free large parts of Kashmir in 1947 when your breed was munching birian while riding donkeys to Pakistan.

I generally agree that service = citizenship, but I dont think a dedicated paramilitary organisation is a good idea. Its expensive and risky, foreign agencies would be drooling at the opportunity to inflitrate its ranks and incite unrest.

I would say that they should be employed as govt cleaners or labourers instead, but I think Pakistan already has too many unemployed citizens already.
 
.
Back
Top Bottom