What's new

French emergency terror powers enshrined in law

Vergennes

ELITE MEMBER
Joined
Feb 25, 2014
Messages
8,576
Reaction score
61
Country
France
Location
France
MPs give police more ability to act in terror cases

http%3A%2F%2Fcom.ft.imagepublish.prod.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fc62ff51e-a85a-11e7-ab66-21cc87a2edde

Nearly three-quarters of MPs backed a bill that will allow police officers to continue to use some counter-terrorism powers once the state of emergency expires © AFP

France’s parliament has voted overwhelmingly to convert a number of emergency police powers into permanent laws as the country grapples with a homegrown terrorist threat.

A bill backed by nearly three-quarters of MPs on Tuesday will allow police officers to continue to use some powers once the state of emergency expires in November. It was implemented by former president François Hollande after 130 people were killed in terror attacks in Paris in November 2015.

Some judges, lawyers and human rights organisations have criticised the move, saying it enshrines infringements of civil liberties, targets Muslims and will lead to more police mistakes.

Gérard Collomb, interior minister, said on Tuesday that France was “still in a situation of war”.

“I have heard sometimes that some of those controls are against liberties. No, they are useful,” he said.

The bill gives police the right to restrict the whereabouts of terror suspects without judicial approval and shut down places of worship if they are deemed by intelligence services to be encouraging terrorism.

Police will also be able to raid homes and other places on terrorism grounds after getting a judge’s approval. Officers will be able to do so based on intelligence reports that would not necessarily be enough evidence to open a judicial probe.

Such powers largely mirror those granted under the state of emergency, which has been extended six times since being enacted nearly two years ago.

The law’s approval comes during a heightened terror alert after a series of unprecedented attacks by Islamist extremists that has claimed 239 lives in France since 2015. At the weekend two women were fatally stabbed by a Tunisian national in Marseille and explosive devices were found in a building in Paris.

The legislation marks a change of tack by president Emmanuel Macron, who had backed a parliamentary report published in December concluding that the state of emergency had produced only modest results.

During his presidential campaign Mr Macron said recent laws beefing up powers for anti-terror judges and the intelligence services were enough to tackle terrorism.

More than 4,300 raids, 439 house arrests and 16 closures of mosques have been carried out under the state of emergency, producing 20 prosecutions.


https://www.ft.com/content/6b68aa54-a850-11e7-93c5-648314d2c72c

@Nilgiri
 
Would you say its largely bipartisan (left + right political unity) or split/fractured along party lines in support for it?

At least France is pushing ahead with responding to the threat. Now will passing of these laws allow state of emergency to lapse in november...or will state of emergency also be renewed for some more period of time (say another year)? I guess we will see.

The latest attack in Marseilles was vile and despicable...France must never let this settle as the new normal status quo...and I have full faith in France regarding that.
 
Good, about time something (good) is done.

Although I have read some critisism, namely that the term 'terrorism' is vaguely mentioned, this might leave the danger of designating something 'terrorist' which it actually wouldn't be, endangering the freedom.

Is this adressed by lawmakers?

I do trust France won't ever abuse this law, then again, I trusted Spain too... :sarcastic:
 
Would you say its largely bipartisan (left + right political unity) or split/fractured along party lines in support for it?

The bill was largely approved by MPs from LREM,MoDem,The Constructives (Macron compatibles MPs from the center-right spectrum) and the Socialist Party.

However the Republicans,the National Front and the Unbowed France voted against it. The two first because they deemed it 'insufficient' and the latter because it is 'ineffective' and 'liberticide'.

At least France is pushing ahead with responding to the threat. Now will passing of these laws allow state of emergency to lapse in november...or will state of emergency also be renewed for some more period of time (say another year)? I guess we will see.

This bill is due to take over the state of emergency that if I remember is going to end on the 1st of November. After being approved during the first reading,a parliamentary commission will now seek compromises on amendments put forward by the Senate and the Assemblée before a definitive vote in mid-october.

Good, about time something (good) is done.

Although I have read some critisism, namely that the term 'terrorism' is vaguely mentioned, this might leave the danger of designating something 'terrorist' which it actually wouldn't be, endangering the freedom.

Is this adressed by lawmakers?

That will remain to be seen however I have read that the Senate put an amendment to evaluate, each years, the usefulness of these new measures and to control them so to prevent any abuse.

Interestingly despite being labelled as endangering freedom,the bill has met little to no resistance at all from the public. It seemed as if no one gave two cents about it. Well it may be understood after the people are still on edge after the terror attacks that hit our country.


I do trust France won't ever abuse this law, then again, I trusted Spain too... :sarcastic:

:nana:
 
Last edited:
That will remain to be seen however I have read that the Senate put an amendment to evaluate, each years, the usefulness of these new measures and to control them so to prevent any abuse.

Interestingly despite being labelled as endangering freedom,the bill has met little to no resistance at all from the public. It seemed as if no one gave two cents about it. Well it may be understood after the people are still on edge after the terror attacks that hit our country.
Allright, thanks for the inforlation.

Interestingly despite being labelled as endangering freedom,the bill has met little to no resistance at all from the public. It seemed as if no one gave two cents about it. Well it may be understood after the people are still on edge after the terror attacks that hit our country.
Well, I suppose if you aren't a terrorist, you don't have to worry about anything. :woot:
 
France’s parliament has voted overwhelmingly to convert a number of emergency police powers into permanent laws as the country grapples with a homegrown terrorist threat.

When it comes to the national fabric and security, no one gives a rat's rear about 'liberalism' and 'intellectualism'. That's the truth that we Indians don't seem to digest.
 
Back
Top Bottom