Four illegal Bangladeshi immigrants caught in Modi's Gujarat

[Manmohan]

for the bold part you cant have uniformed civil code keeping in view religious diversity simple as that.

If Hindu and Christian laws have been reformed why not Muslim?
Even some scriptures in Hinduism and Christianity allow polygamy. Why can't we have multiple wives at the same time?

Why Indian Muslims are cherrypicking Sharia? Sharia also says hands of thieves must be chopped off. Why dont they ask for that? Since 90% of criminals in India are Muslim it would be good for India.

Why do they want selective sharia which benefits them?

 

[third eye]

How many BD nationals will be caught? Its better to give illegal immigrants Indian nationality. Bangladeshis are very hard working. They will contribute to India's economy.

@ title

What is Modi's Gujarat ?

Gujarat is a state in India which Modi was a CM of.

 

[Spring Onion]

If Hindu and Christian laws have been reformed why not Muslim?
Even some scriptures in Hinduism and Christianity allow polygamy. Why can't we have multiple wives at the same time?

Why Indian Muslims are cherrypicking Sharia? Sharia also says hands of thieves must be chopped off. Why dont they ask for that? Since 90% of criminals in India are Muslim it would be good for India.

Why do they want selective sharia which benefits them?

1. for the bold part that is NOT Muslim issue that is Hindus' issue so take it up with your people.

2. As far as cutting hands i think other than personal laws (marriage, inheritance, property) , Muslims in India do not apply sharia to criminal cases. So your argument is weakest here.


Uniform civil code is NOT possible in India simple as that and if you think its possible then of which faith you will adopt ?

 

[Manmohan]

As far as cutting hands i think other than personal laws (marriage, inheritance, property) , Muslims in India do not apply sharia to criminal cases. So your argument is weakest here.

Why don't they apply sharia to criminal cases? That's my question.

Why do they only restrict to civil cases? Because it benefits them. That's my point.

Just google "Imrana Rape case".

Cases like such are result of them having a different civil code. This is the only one out of many unreported ones, which our media suprisingly covered.

 

[Rahul9090]

quote="Manmohan, post: 5717743, member: 157317"]Why would they take Hindu Bengalis when they have kicked out their own Hindus in BD?

Let's be real. The way politics(Muslim appeasement) is being played in India we will end up in same place where we're few decades back. Then we had Gandhi and Nehru whose appeasement politics led to partition. In current times our politicians have become worse than Gandhi and Nehru. And they are in a majority. They say " History repeats itself" and in India's case it always has. Because we never learn from our mistakes[/quote]

think positive dude modi does what he says let's wait and see...i am sure we will be able to deport at least half of them if not all ...

 

[अखण्ड भारत!!!]

How many BD nationals will be caught? Its better to give illegal immigrants Indian nationality. Bangladeshis are very hard working. They will contribute to India's economy.

Only if you evacuate one third of your territory and give it to us

1. for the bold part that is NOT Muslim issue that is Hindus' issue so take it up with your people.

2. As far as cutting hands i think other than personal laws (marriage, inheritance, property) , Muslims in India do not apply sharia to criminal cases. So your argument is weakest here.


Uniform civil code is NOT possible in India simple as that and if you think its possible then of which faith you will adopt ?

Its possible when it is possible in so many muslim countries then it is possible here also

 

[Spring Onion]

Why don't they apply sharia to criminal cases? That's my question.

Why do they only restrict to civil cases? Because it benefits them. That's my point.

Just google "Imrana Rape case".

Cases like such are result of them having a different civil code. This is the only one out of many unreported ones, which our media suprisingly covered.

Because that will offend you Indians at large

If you allow them applying it to criminal cases they will gladly do that.

But personal laws are something which you cant touch

 

[अखण्ड भारत!!!]

India is already a very overpopulated country, so strong sentiments in masses against illegal immigrants is understandable, but the priority should be to resolve the issue through more peaceful ways.

Suggest some 'peaceful' ways?

 

[Spring Onion]

Its possible when it is possible in so many muslim countries then it is possible here also

lolzz how in Muslim countries ?

we dont ask you to follow Muslim personal laws. Even in Muslim countries you get your own personal laws.

 

[अखण्ड भारत!!!]

lolzz how in Muslim countries ?

we dont ask you to follow Muslim personal laws. Even in Muslim countries you get your own personal laws.

No variant of sharia in so many muslim countries
Green-Sharia plays no role in the judicial system
Yellow-Sharia applies in personal status issues only
Purple-Sharia applies in full, including criminal law
Orange-Regional variations in the application of sharia

 

[Spring Onion]

No variant of sharia in so many muslim countries
Green-Sharia plays no role in the judicial system
Yellow-Sharia applies in personal status issues only
Purple-Sharia applies in full, including criminal law
Orange-Regional variations in the application of sharia

uncle these apply to Muslims.

So how you plan to apply Hindu personal laws uniformly on all faiths in India?

 

[अखण्ड भारत!!!]

India has more kids per women compared to Bangladesh. so sterilize every one in India too? Plz be humane in discussion

Bangladesh's population density is twice that of India

 

[Manmohan]

Because that will offend you Indians at large
If you allow them applying it to criminal cases they will gladly do that.
But personal laws are something which you cant touch

So Indian Muslims will agree to flogging of alchohol consuming Muslims, cutting hands of Muslim thieves, stoning of married Muslim rapist, etc. I dont think so.

Now you are being biased.

So how you plan to apply Hindu personal laws uniformly on all faiths in India?

We plan to apply western personal laws on all faiths not the hindu one! And btw only Muslims are opposing it.

 

[अखण्ड भारत!!!]

uncle these apply to Muslims.

So how you plan to apply Hindu personal laws uniformly on all faiths in India?

What nonsense.
Who is talking about putting hindu laws on anyone.And what are hindu laws?We are talking about uniform civil code-one law applicable on everyone regardless of religion.

 

[Spring Onion]

So Indian Muslims will agree to flogging of alchohol consuming Muslims, cutting hands of Muslim thieves, stoning of married Muslim rapist, etc. I dont think so.

Now you are being biased.

first you announce that they will

We plan to apply western personal laws on all faiths not the hindu one! And btw only Muslims are opposing it.

why western personal law? lolzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz if you are opting to adopt an alien law then whats wrong with having that of Muslims, Sikhs, Christians, which they are already practicing individually at community level

What nonsense.
Who is talking about putting hindu laws on anyone.And what are hindu laws?We are talking about uniform civil code-one law applicable on everyone regardless of religion.

oh really and how will you do that ?

Till recently Sikhs were forced to register their marriage under Hindu law which was not acceptable to them so you had to atlast approve theirs.

Now how will you impose uniformed civil code viz a viz personal alws?