What's new

Fishy,sending $4 billion per year to India from Pakistan

WTF is gangaland?


Which is even more shameful. Thanks for pointing that out though.
A country of 200 mn sending 5 bn for a country of 1.6bn where as a country 1.6 cant even reciprocate the same amount let alone exceeding it, Indeed it is shameful
Why it is shameful, it makes intuitive sense since Muslim in India mostly fall in lower income class than their Pakistani relatives. You don't expect much from the poor and you shouldn't be expecting 80% non-muslim population to be sending anything because of their lack of link with Pakistan.
 
.
For an emotional piece of writing, i give you full marks. But Pakistan and India are not at war just like Pakistan and UK are not at war despite UK conveniently housing the newly labeled traitor AH. I am often amazed at how quickly the brood of Zaid Hamid has spread all over the internet. If I have an apartment in dubai, doesn't make it my country, my country is where I live, breath and earn my livelihood and call my home. Living in UK while claiming Pakistan to be home is disrespect to your home country.
And yet somehow those of us who are living in Karachi are traitors. Oh the irony doesn't end
 
.
Living in UK while claiming Pakistan to be home is disrespect to your home country.
Are you seriously equating UK/Pakistan dynamic with Pak/India dynamic - seriously? Are you telling me Pak has spent billions on nuclear deterant, maintains a huge military it can ill afford and that the primary driver behind this is UK. seriously?

Every Pakistani knows the main driver of the expenditure on defence is India. Entire Pak military is confiigured against India. Entire Pak policy is premised on India be the adversery? And you have the galls to equate India with UK.

Are you Indian? Are you in love with India or something? If you think India is so great go move back there or go suck a Indian teat. This is my last response to you as it's just going to go in circles.
 
.
WTF is gangaland?


Which is even more shameful. Thanks for pointing that out though.
A country of 200 mn sending 5 bn for a country of 1.6bn where as a country 1.6 cant even reciprocate the same amount let alone exceeding it, Indeed it is shameful
Actually an average Pakistani person is getting $10 of remittances from India whereas an average Indian person is getting less than $4 from Pakistan.
Also as a % of GDP Pakistan is getting 0.75% from India remittances whereas India is getting only 0.25%
 
.
You don't expect much from the poor and you shouldn't be expecting
Sadly, it is true.

Actually an average Pakistani person is getting $10 of remittances from India whereas an average Indian person is getting less than $4 from Pakistan.
Also as a % of GDP Pakistan is getting 0.75% from India remittances whereas India is getting only 0.25%


Actually an average Pakistani person is getting $10 of remittances from India whereas an average Indian person is getting less than $4 from Pakistan.
Also as a % of GDP Pakistan is getting 0.75% from India remittances whereas India is getting only 0.25%
If calculating over per capita makes you feel happy. please feel free to then. But knowing that this assistance is direly required by the poor muslims their just pains and hurts me.
 
.
And yet somehow those of us who are living in Karachi are traitors. Oh the irony doesn't end
Most of the Pakistanis suffer from acute shortage of patriotism and identity crisis. Most of the people with different flags fit in this class who are aliens in their new home and keep looking back the place they initially left willingly. These people are more interested in declaring the treachery and patriotism because doing so they believe that it bridges their own identity crisis.
 
.
Most of the Pakistanis suffer from acute shortage of patriotism and identity crisis. Most of the people with different flags fit in this class who are aliens in their new home and keep looking back the place they initially left willingly. These people are more interested in declaring the treachery and patriotism because doing so they believe that it bridges their own identity crisis.

And most of these passionate patriots living in the west- Indian or Pakstani - advocate real hardline positions for their respective nations, and simply froth over with love for their country.

Until you ask them to actually go back and live permanently in India or Pakistan. You know, actually show proof of concept, so to speak.

Then their love for the 'homeland' curdles a little bit.
 
.
Actually an average Pakistani person is getting $10 of remittances from India whereas an average Indian person is getting less than $4 from Pakistan.
Also as a % of GDP Pakistan is getting 0.75% from India remittances whereas India is getting only 0.25%
Actually an average Pakistani person is getting $10 of remittances from India whereas an average Indian person is getting less than $4 from Pakistan.
Also as a % of GDP Pakistan is getting 0.75% from India remittances whereas India is getting only 0.25%
Most of the Pakistanis suffer from acute shortage of patriotism and identity crisis. Most of the people with different flags fit in this class who are aliens in their new home and keep looking back the place they initially left willingly. These people are more interested in declaring the treachery and patriotism because doing so they believe that it bridges their own identity crisis.
Do believe people from Pakistan are sending money to help the people in India. 99.99% of the money is for business.
 
.
@salarsikander @Talwar e Pakistan @xyxmt @haviZsultan @X-2.

Pakistan received $2+ billion remittances from India whereas India received $5 billion which means given that India's population is 1.3 billion and Pakistan 200 million, Pakistan per capita remittances from India is far higher than India's from Pakistan.



http://blogs.wsj.com/indiarealtime/...pakistanis-sent-5-billion-to-india-last-year/
It's not abt who get the remittance.... problem is how any why ..on both sides it's illegally transfer and doesn't good for both countries GDP
Understand :P
 
.
Are you seriously equating UK/Pakistan dynamic with Pak/India dynamic - seriously? Are you telling me Pak has spent billions on nuclear deterant, maintains a huge military it can ill afford and that the primary driver behind this is UK. seriously?
The point being? Whose the aim of UK's nuclear deterrent then? Israel? I mean I am even more surprised at the core of the argument. Every country maintains a military heck even the New Zealand whose at the tip of the world mainatains a military but against who? India is just an excuse for the military machine of Pakistan which now reaches gigantic in size characterized by all sorts of ventures.

Every Pakistani knows the main driver of the expenditure on defence is India. Entire Pak military is confiigured against India. Entire Pak policy is premised on India be the adversery? And you have the galls to equate India with UK.
Military's goal is to defend the national territory from All of the agressors but yes apparently military is so occupied with India that their duty to protect doesn't apply on others.

Are you Indian? Are you in love with India or something? If you think India is so great go move back there or go suck a Indian teat. This is my last response to you as it's just going to go in circles.
Again that emotional speech. Pakistan's
My both flags should be enough to tell that I am in no doubt about where my loyalties are and where I belong.

And most of these passionate patriots living in the west- Indian or Pakstani - advocate real hardline positions for their respective nations, and simply froth over with love for their country.

Until you ask them to actually go back and live permanently in India or Pakistan. You know, actually show proof of concept, so to speak.

Then their love for the 'homeland' curdles a little bit.
Exactly because they know that if a Nuke is fired, it wont hit them. So they can safely cheerlead the war hysteria
 
.
Higher quality material are made locally so quite strange for the 4 Billion trade

Strange part is our budget is 4-8 Billion , so just really surprised I would have imagined may be a small amount like 100 million
 
.
Indian rice exporter buy all Pakistani rice, repack with Indian logo and sell in international market. Dubai is quota hub.
 
.
But the money does through offical channel and has contributed to indian GDP. ther no denying in that :disagree:


Oh dont worry at all we are very generous people:
http://tribune.com.pk/story/1040155/10-most-generous-nations-in-the-world/

We will continue to help those who are in dire need, even though our situation is not really good. But hey that's what being generous is all about
no, they tracked transactions that went via several countries...in multiple hops.. not between pak and india specifically... used some logic known to them, that they think is right and arrived at the conclusion.
http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/...ttances-over-3-years/articleshow/51178634.cms

"Reached for an explanation, Dilip Ratha, Manager, Migration and Remittances at the World Bank, said, "The reported remittances from Pakistan to India are not an actual, official data. It is an analytical estimate derived from a global estimation of bilateral remittance flows worldwide. This estimate is just that, an estimate based on logical assumptions.""
 
.
Indian rice exporter buy all Pakistani rice, repack with Indian logo and sell in international market. Dubai is quota hub.
It is ...but how remittance going just like that to India . legalisation is necessary for our economy
 
.
It is ...but how remittance going just like that to India . legalisation is necessary for our economy
Unfortunately , PMLn is run by King , who doesn't bother to inform the citizen about economic policy or changing policy without letting masses know. Some policies are secretly adopted and only few people take absolute advantage.
 
.
Back
Top Bottom