What's new

Don't compare India with Pakistan: US

Contrarian

ELITE MEMBER
Joined
Oct 23, 2006
Messages
11,571
Reaction score
4
Don't compare India with Pakistan: US


WASHINGTON: The United States has rejected the notion that the civilian nuclear deal with India is going to spur a nuclear arms race in South Asia while stressing that Washington has different but singularly important relationships with both New Delhi and Islamabad.

"No, we don't expect that to be the case and we hope that's not going to be the case," US Under Secretary of State for Political Affairs Nicholas Burns told reporters in response to a query.

He said the United States has singularly important relationships with both countries, but they are very different. "The relationship with India is based on this extraordinary growth of trade and investment between our private sectors. The fact that India has the greatest number of students here, 75-80,000, and the fact that we are going to do things with India - civil nuclear trade, democracy promotion worldwide, HIV/AIDS cooperation --that are going to be unique," he added.

Pakistan, he said, was the most indispensable country in Washington's goal of fighting Al-Qaida. "I testified on Pakistan the other day and said Pakistan was the most indispensable country in the entire world to the United States in our number one global priority, fighting Al-Qaida, fighting the Taliban, fighting radical extremist terrorists groups."And so that relationship rests on that kind of cooperation which is very important to the internal stability of Pakistan and of Afghanistan," the senior State Department official maintained.

The senior State Department official said the US is going to proceed with very strong relationships with both countries and both countries are going to look to the United States in different ways. "And I think it's important to mention that as a way to answer your question, because obviously Pakistan has a past, in terms of nuclear proliferation which, with the AQ Khan network, was very troubling.

India has a very different past, and therefore we construct a different future on that basis, on that particular activity, civil nuclear cooperation," Burns added.

http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/...dia_with_Pakistan_US_/articleshow/2240305.cms
 
.
Pakistan isnt important to usa. We are just being used like always. The report clearly states cooperation in the required field means pakistan cooperation against terrorism getting soilders killed and india getting nuclear deal. Wow. God give our leaders some sense. Anyhow This deal will help india alot. Good going india
 
.
What an irony, President Nixon had totally opposite view of Indians.

BTW, does any one knows, what India is giving to US in return as part of the said deals?
 
.
Pakistan isnt important to usa. We are just being used like always. The report clearly states cooperation in the required field means pakistan cooperation against terrorism getting soilders killed and india getting nuclear deal. Wow. God give our leaders some sense. Anyhow This deal will help india alot. Good going india

Nothing to feel despondent about actually.

The US loves the smell of money over everything else.

India has a huge market and it means BIG money.

There is no other reason as I see.

Haven't you noticed that China is no longer taken to be a horror of a country with rampant atrocities behind 'The Bamboo Curtain"? Does Reader Digest carry those horror stories any more? No. Why? Because China means BIGGER money!
 
.
Nothing to feel despondent about actually.

The US loves the smell of money over everything else.

India has a huge market and it means BIG money.

There is no other reason as I see.

Haven't you noticed that China is no longer taken to be a horror of a country with rampant atrocities behind 'The Bamboo Curtain"? Does Reader Digest carry those horror stories any more? No. Why? Because China means BIGGER money!
Salim, I appreciate your optimism.
India indeed is a big buyer of weapons and who some how suddenly become unconviced with Russian arms and ditched them, was that only American arms? no it was all to strip Pakistan from a strong ally.
Pakistan is also equally interested in American arms but some how Americans are not willing to sell, irrespective of our historic relations.
This is because America has been hijacked by misinformation and who has just made another decision, again based on misinformation and I'm affraid it might have more nagative implications on US and our region.
I say US has been hijacked by the influential world of media and it seems India is runnig the world of media like a bollywood movie place some mullahs like characters, film them and release it through news channels.
 
.
Russia yesterday started building 3 Indian Major surface combat ships? So when did India ditch Russia. India has till now only bought a second hand LPD from US, at 48 million dollars. Russia and Indian friendship is far more deeper than you think
 
.
Russia yesterday started building 3 Indian Major surface combat ships? So when did India ditch Russia. India has till now only bought a second hand LPD from US, at 48 million dollars. Russia and Indian friendship is far more deeper than you think

when was that deal signed.
 
.
cheetah This nuke deal is in as much Russias Prerogative as much Us's, It has nothing to do with defence cooperation with the US.

We are building 2 Russian VVEr's with Guaranteed russian fuel supply of 1000Mw *2, we want more but they cannot sell as we cannot get fuel from abroad, it cannot happen unless we get NSG consensus which cannot happen until deal is signed.
 
.
Pakistan isnt important to usa. We are just being used like always. The report clearly states cooperation in the required field means pakistan cooperation against terrorism getting soilders killed and india getting nuclear deal. Wow. God give our leaders some sense. Anyhow This deal will help india alot. Good going india

Respect is not given its earned.

when we will get politicians that actually care and are proud to be pakistanies world will listen and care.
 
.
cheetah This nuke deal is in as much Russias Prerogative as much Us's, It has nothing to do with defence cooperation with the US.

We are building 2 Russian VVEr's with Guaranteed russian fuel supply of 1000Mw *2, we want more but they cannot sell as we cannot get fuel from abroad, it cannot happen unless we get NSG consensus which cannot happen until deal is signed.

joey you are talking about different things.
 
.
Russia yesterday started building 3 Indian Major surface combat ships? So when did India ditch Russia. India has till now only bought a second hand LPD from US, at 48 million dollars. Russia and Indian friendship is far more deeper than you think
It is only because India need to buy spare parts of its Russian military hardware. India switching to the cold war enemy of Russia can been only seen as by Moscow as ditching.
Russia may see it hostile from the poit of view that India may pass on all the intelligence of Russian arms technology simply because India has nothing to offer in return other than intelligence about Russia.
 
.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Adux View Post
Russia yesterday started building 3 Indian Major surface combat ships? So when did India ditch Russia. India has till now only bought a second hand LPD from US, at 48 million dollars. Russia and Indian friendship is far more deeper than you think

It is only because India need to buy spare parts of its Russian military hardware. India switching to the cold war enemy of Russia can been only seen as by Moscow as ditching.
Russia may see it hostile from the poit of view that India may pass on all the intelligence of Russian arms technology simply because India has nothing to offer in return other than intelligence about Russia.

If one sees the first post and then the answer, the answer does not have any connection to the issue.

If Russia is building ships for India how on earth does it mean that that Russia is hostile to India.

I fail to see the logic.

It appears that Batman is only posting with an eye on the counter since I find his contention really odd that a country hostile to another country is building war materiel for the country that she is hostile to! :hitwall:

It really marvels me!

Wonders will never cease!
 
.
"Don't compare India with Pakistan: US"

Interesting that even Mr Burns is using terms like this when there's no comparison at all. India with a trillion dollar economy is much more attractive and luctrative market than Pakistan ever will be, its all about money.

Why else would uncle want to bend local laws to grant India fuel supply even if she decides to hold future nuclear tests. Any other country would be sanctioned to starvation!

Talk about double standards, US style. :disagree:
 
.
No offence to anyone from a Pakistani POV, If i saw this report I would be LITERALLY PISSED.

I dont get it, you guys have been their ally for over 50 years, and all they have done is flown the spy drons from pakistan to USSR? What have they done as HRD developement in Pakistan? I really want to know. Because Pakistan as a state is not that huge that it would need the level of effort India needs to become a developed state.

The soviets in first send us big big ships of free books, I still have in my collection, they are magnificient publications and scientific approach, from Mir Publishers, Moscow.
 
.
If one sees the first post and then the answer, the answer does not have any connection to the issue.

If Russia is building ships for India how on earth does it mean that that Russia is hostile to India.

I fail to see the logic.

It appears that Batman is only posting with an eye on the counter since I find his contention really odd that a country hostile to another country is building war materiel for the country that she is hostile to! :hitwall:

It really marvels me!

Wonders will never cease!

I said:
Russia may see it hostile
Do you know what 'MAY' implies!
And again IF Russia finds Indian military relations with US hostile that does not means they will stop selling weopans to India or either India stop buying from Russia.
It's just the begining, India will continue to buy Russian arms till India see an alternate source for military hardware other than atom bombs and than if the day come soon than still India will be in need of spareparts.
Russian co-operation was in the hope that India will buy mig from them.
We will see how it proceeds from there on.

I hope I never have been personally offensive to any member, incl. you.
I also have the right to post every where I wish. After all every day I read loving statements about Pakistan and Islam from Indian rulers.
 
.

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom