Do you think QUAD set Modi up?

[vi-va]

What has China done for India ? USA & West pump in $200 billion in business. At the end of the day Indian leaders do what is good for India.

No amount of chest thumping is going to change that

You mean your worthless green paper? Come on, the money flow in will flow out some day, somehow with margin and interest.

It's private capital seeking return, Chinese money flow in as well. A large portion of the capital come from Singapore and Hong Kong.

It's not US is helping India, US private companies is doing what's the best interest of US private companies.

No matter what, those capital will go to places which provides return, such as China and Russia.

And by the way, China has worse and worse relationship with US, but those capital flow into China market more and more. China got much more FDI than India. So US is helping China as well?

Your lack of finance 101 and ignorance always make me laugh. I don't blame you, maybe drop out too early.

 

[nahtanbob]

It's not US is helping India, US private companies is doing what's the best interest of US private companies.

Tell us what Indian products & services China purchases and how many Indian nationals Chinese companies employ

Compare & contrast it to what USA and West provides

 

[vi-va]

Basically, what India got from the romantic relationship with US is opening her legs, wide open.

US look at India as a prey, just like what US did to the Philippines, Mexico, Argentina, Venezuela, Iraq, KSA, East European countries, Latin Americas.

India market especially digital market conquered completely by US monopoly, such as twitter, facebook, google and many others.

India, with such a large population and millions of IT worker, don't have any meaningful social media company, no Search Engine, no streaming company like youtube.

I would say there is no other country as silly as India.

On the other hand, China has Tencent, Alibaba, JD, Meituan, ByteDance, and many others, trillions of revenue.

List of largest Internet companies - Wikipedia

en.wikipedia.org

 

[vi-va]

US provide nothing.

The only 3 things US and West provide to India is

1. Illusional security
   • Illusional security, India is buying weapons from US, France. But US is dragging India into a potential conflict with both Pakistan and China, which are 2 major nuclear power.
   • During Doklam standoff 2017 and Skirmish 2020, US did nothing, just push India to buy more weapons.
2. White worship
   • India blindly adopted US economy model and political system
   • India opened his society to US dominance
3. Brian Drain
   • The most successful Indians are in US, not in India
   • India intellectual basically are echo chamber of US propaganda machine

 

[Path-Finder]

QUAD ask India to beat China and Russia vaccine diplomacy. Then Modi handed out tens of millions of vaccines, sent all over the world, while other members of QUAD, such as US never provide a single shot, not even US allies.

Modi tried to save the world at the expense of Indians lives. Brilliant. Best PM ever.

I guess if Trump/Biden did that in US, the president had been hanged in the oral office of White House.

Do you think QUAD set Modi up, or Modi truly ignorant?

NO, shri moohdhi ji is too smart for the west.

 

[nahtanbob]

US provide nothing.

American companies provides $200 billion in IT services & employment. What does China provide ?
Nothing.

 

[vi-va]

American companies provides $200 billion in IT services & employment. What does China provide ?
Nothing.

Provide?

Come on. By your standard, US provides 2000 billion to China?

It's money seeking return, and profit of China market isn't bad, hmm? So many US companies come to China for revenue and margin.

Every Fortune 500 have lots of business in China, so they love China? Damn not, they LOVE CHINESE MONEY.

Go back to school for finance 101.

 

[nahtanbob]

Provide?

Come on. By your standard, US provides 2000 billion to China?

It's money seeking return, and profit of China market isn't bad, hmm? So many US companies come to China for revenue and margin.

Every Fortune 500 have lots of business in China, so they love China? Damn not, they LOVE CHINESE MONEY.

Go back to school for finance 101.

Simple question - you keep dodging
What do Chinese companies do for India unlike American companies ?

 

[mike2000 is back]

Basically, what India got from the romantic relationship with US is opening her legs, wide open.

US look at India as a prey, just like what US did to the Philippines, Mexico, Argentina, Venezuela, Iraq, KSA, East European countries, Latin Americas.

India market especially digital market conquered completely by US monopoly, such as twitter, facebook, google and many others.

India, with such a large population and millions of IT worker, don't have any meaningful social media company, no Search Engine, no streaming company like youtube.

I would say there is no other country as silly as India.

On the other hand, China has Tencent, Alibaba, JD, Meituan, ByteDance, and many others, trillions of revenue.
View attachment 753224

List of largest Internet companies - Wikipedia

en.wikipedia.org

You are sounding quite overbearing and obviously biased in your views here. India's decisions during the pandemic had nothing whatsoever to do with the US or Quad. Its even foolish and outright stupid to even think that there was any link between the two. The Indian companies involved like SII(a private company by the way) did that for profits and market contracts/ market share they enjoyed.
So I don't see the point you are trying to make here. It was the Indian government that failed to realise the threat of covid and became quite complacent as infection rates had dropped so low that they thought they were out of the woods and so they eased all measures and even became careless thinking the fight against the pandemic was won. So they failed to formulate a long term viable policy and prepare fir any second or third waves, which they should have been prepared for looking ar other countries experiences. So it was the short-sightedness and incompetence of the government that is to blame.

So I don't see how this has anything to do with QUAD it being a pawn . India will and should do what is in her best interests, if that means allying with the US against a common threat then that's actually what they should rationally do. Just like China eventually did back I the 70s to early 90s by allying with the US against the Soviets Union which China viewed as its biggest threat back then. Its normal in geo politics , only interests matters . Everything else is secondary. . Many also called China's move back then as treason and even called china a pawn/puppet the US is using against the Soviets(a view many Vietnamese held. Lol ) but did it change anything ? As far as it served China's interests, that's all that mattered , and history shows it was the right move to make at the time for the Chinese at the time, and it help open up China and its economy and prosperityfrom then on, the rest is history. Only fools will rely on their feelings and emotions to forge their foreign policy.

 

[White and Green with M/S]

Simple question - you keep dodging
What do Chinese companies do for India unlike American companies ?

lots infrastructure development projects by Chinese companies in India, google is your friend, and India is just cannon fodder of USA against China

 

[nahtanbob]

lots infrastructure development projects by Chinese companies in India, google is your friend, and India is just cannon fodder of USA against China

Infrastructure projects are paid by Indian taxpayers. The money goes back to China

 

[White and Green with M/S]

Infrastructure projects are paid by Indian taxpayers. The money goes back to China

LOL don't troll, China is invested lots in India for example on Mumbai road infrastructure and local train infrastructure etc etc, and give us the proofs that these projects are being completed by Indian taxpayers money???, you should google instead a doing useless blabbering

 

[Pakistan Space Agency]

USA is using you from afghan jehad days , ...

They can't use us.

We just bought time to first get nukes and second build jet fighters to make up for the lost decade.

These are the two things they tried so hard to deny us by imposing sanctions but due to their own greed, they were forced to look the other way while we acquired them (and beat up India with them).

 

[vi-va]

You are sounding quite overbearing and obviously biased in your views here. India's decisions during the pandemic had nothing whatsoever to do with the US or Quad. Its even foolish and outright stupid to even think that there was any link between the two. The Indian companies involved like SII(a private company by the way) did that for profits and market contracts/ market share they enjoyed.
So I don't see the point you are trying to make here. It was the Indian government that failed to realise the threat of covid and became quite complacent as infection rates had dropped so low that they thought they were out of the woods and so they eased all measures and even became careless thinking the fight against the pandemic was won. So they failed to formulate a long term viable policy and prepare fir any second or third waves, which they should have been prepared for looking ar other countries experiences. So it was the short-sightedness and incompetence of the government that is to blame.

So I don't see how this has anything to do with QUAD it being a pawn . India will and should do what is in her best interests, if that means allying with the US against a common threat then that's actually what they should rationally do. Just like China eventually did back I the 70s to early 90s by allying with the US against the Soviets Union which China viewed as its biggest threat back then. Its normal in geo politics , only interests matters . Everything else is secondary. . Many also called China's move back then as treason and even called china a pawn/puppet the US is using against the Soviets(a view many Vietnamese held. Lol ) but did it change anything ? As far as it served China's interests, that's all that mattered , and history shows it was the right move to make at the time for the Chinese at the time, and it help open up China and its economy and prosperityfrom then on, the rest is history. Only fools will rely on their feelings and emotions to forge their foreign policy.

Not that complicated.

Modi lack of experience. Modi has not received systematic education, what he achieved in Gujarat has little to do with him, but Gujarat itself.

Modi is too ambitious, but lack of the understanding of ground reality. He has no experience to run such a large population, no experience to rule radical ideology of RSS/BJP.

Modi is very anxious, the slogan and promise he made and the delivery gap is so large that he lost direction.

When US ask India to compete with China on Vaccine diplomacy, Modi seized the opportunity, but he is overconfident, and completely screw things up again.

Take 2016 Indian banknote demonetisation as example. That's Modi.

• reckless
• foolhardy

Take 2019 India–Pakistan border skirmishes as example. That's Modi

• reckless
• foolhardy

Take 2020–2021 China–India skirmishes as example. That's Modi

• reckless
• foolhardy

That's Modi, the best PM ever of India.

 

[nahtanbob]

LOL don't troll, China is invested lots in India for example on Mumbai road infrastructure and local train infrastructure etc etc, and give us the proofs that these projects are being completed by Indian taxpayers money???, you should google instead a doing useless blabbering

Quit trolling ... show me the link where China invests in Mumbai road infrastructure
Winning Indian government contracts is not investment