Discussion: Quranism, Quranists. Share your views

[LeGenD]

What is Quranism?

Holy Quran = divine revelation and the primary source of guidance for Muslims or Believers. This distinction is important for being a Muslim.

Hadith is a collection of sayings attributed to the Holy Prophet (PBUH) by Sahabah. Hadith provide additional guidance to Muslims or Believers but there was a controversy about so many sayings attributed to the Holy Prophet (PBUH) that Islamic scholars had to scrutinize this practice and distinguish a collection of hadith as Sahih from others, but some still claim that some of the Sahih hadith are not Sahih. Human subjectivity / error / mischief is to blame for this problem.

Hadith are best considered as the secondary source of guidance for Muslims or Believers. This distinction is important to separate truly divine revelations from the others.

Problems arise when hadith are given priority over the Holy Quran to shape belief and for politics. Non-state actors are known to do this.

 

[Areesh]

Quranists are a deviant group. Simple

There is nothing more to say about these people

 

[StormBreaker]

What is Quranism?

Holy Quran = divine revelation and the primary source of guidance for Muslims or Believers. This distinction is important for being a Muslim.

Hadith is a collection of sayings attributed to the Holy Prophet (PBUH) by Sahabah. Hadith provide additional guidance to Muslims or Believers but there was a controversy about so many sayings attributed to the Holy Prophet (PBUH) that Islamic scholars had to scrutinize this practice and distinguish a collection of hadith as Sahih from others, but some still claim that some of the Sahih hadith are not Sahih. Human subjectivity / error / mischief is to blame for this problem.

Hadith are best considered as the secondary source of guidance for Muslims or Believers. This distinction is important to separate truly divine revelations from the others.

Problems arise when hadith are given priority over the Holy Quran to shape belief and for politics. Non-state actors are known to do this.

That’s the issue !

Most of the sects give ahadith more priority over Quran.

Inki misal aisi hai ke Nauzu Billah, Allah Quran kaamil utarna bhool gaye the isliye 200 saal baad Imam Bukhari aur baqi deegar Imamon ke zariye nai kitabein banwain.

Like this doesn’t even make any sense.

Ahadith should never be rejected, But they shouldn’t be given an importance to such degree that Quranic translations and interpretations become dependent on these so called attributed sayings.

Quranists are a deviant group. Simple

There is nothing more to say about these people

Mazay ki baat, Quranists aren’t a group, There’s no uniformity among them.

Why ? Because no one bothers to focus on Quran oriented Islam coz mullahs have invented their own fiqh using the cursed science of derivations