Deconstructing Modi Agenda for Afghanistan

[Kandahari]

Khpal plar ta de zoya ma waya, ta de moor da aqal na de kho wale.

You don't represent the whole of Afghanistan. And as for your assertion that people don't Pakistan coz of support for Taliban then you should realise that the Taliban are not resident on Mars, they are present and fighting from among the local population, as an insurgency, now try reading about any insurgency and soon you will realise that an insurgency can never be successful without local support.

So doesn't matter if Pakistan support or not the Taliban the local Afghans do.

You don't live in Afghanistan as you put it yourself probably that's the reason you don't understand the local dyanmics and got yourself pumped up watching Bollywood and Fox News, and thus you statred you keyboard war. Just a suggestion though, do some research before you start posting.

The locals have no choice to give passage, their property, weapons and food. Do you know what the results are if they don't?! I have family in govt and am fully aware of what's going on.

A small percentage of locals do support Taliban probably because of bad experiences with the Afghan govt/US military/stupidity.

The insurgency in Afghanistan is not only run by Taliban (afghans) but various groups from foreign countries.

 

[nangyale]

The locals have no choice to give passage, their property, weapons and food. Do you know what the results are if they don't?! I have family in govt and am fully aware of what's going on.

A small percentage of locals do support Taliban probably because of bad experiences with the Afghan govt/US military/stupidity.

The insurgency in Afghanistan is not only run by Taliban (afghans) but various groups from foreign countries.

Ooh right. So from no support it becomes "A small percentage".

Look dear. The US and ANA have superior numbers, firepower, technological advantage and an unlimited budget. And what has the opposition got...................... not much.
You don't need to be a scientist to know that if it wasn't for the local suppor there will be no insurgency.

You can call them whatever you want, Taliban, Haqqani or anything else. But the only reason there is an insurgency is because there is support for one.

 

[Kandahari]

The locals have no choice to give passage, their property, weapons and food. Do you know what the results are if they don't?! I have family in govt and am fully aware of what's going on.

A small percentage of locals do support Taliban probably because of bad experiences with the Afghan govt/US military/stupidity.

The insurgency in Afghanistan is not only run by Taliban (afghans) but various groups from foreign countries.

Ooh right. So from no support it becomes "A small percentage".

Look dear. The US and ANA have superior numbers, firepower, technological advantage and an unlimited budget. And what has the opposition got...................... not much.
You don't need to be a scientist to know that if it wasn't for the local suppor there will be no insurgency.

You can call them whatever you want, Taliban, Haqqani or anything else. But the only reason there is an insurgency is because there is support for one.

You have piss poor reading comprehension lol where did I say Taliban have zero support?

Majority of the insurgency support is by coercion.

 

[TMA]

Khpal plar ta de zoya ma waya, ta de moor da aqal na de kho wale.

You don't represent the whole of Afghanistan. And as for your assertion that people don't Pakistan coz of support for Taliban then you should realise that the Taliban are not resident on Mars, they are present and fighting from among the local population, as an insurgency, now try reading about any insurgency and soon you will realise that an insurgency can never be successful without local support.

So doesn't matter if Pakistan support or not the Taliban the local Afghans do.

You don't live in Afghanistan as you put it yourself probably that's the reason you don't understand the local dyanmics and got yourself pumped up watching Bollywood and Fox News, and thus you statred you keyboard war. Just a suggestion though, do some research before you start posting.

It is best not to engage with such people. What Pakistan needs to do is protect herself and improve herself - this will be the best answer to such people. Unfortunately I feel it will cause them to only increase in jealous arrogance towards Pakistan.

 

[nangyale]

It is best not to engage with such people. What Pakistan needs to do is protect herself and improve herself - this will be the best answer to such people. Unfortunately I feel it will cause them to only increase in jealous arrogance towards Pakistan.

Although I agree with your idea of not engaging idiotic trolls, sometime it's hard to leave complete rubbish propaganda unchallenged.
In the modern world, a lot of battles are decided not just on the battlefield but also by the perception of the wider public. True that the best answer is making our country better and prosperous, but at the same time any lies about homeland shouldn't be tolerated. They should be challenged and debunked every step of the way.

 

[TMA]

Although I agree with your idea of not engaging idiotic trolls, sometime it's hard to leave complete rubbish propaganda unchallenged.
In the modern world, a lot of battles are decided not just on the battlefield but also by the perception of the wider public. True that the best answer is making our country better and prosperous, but at the same time any lies about homeland shouldn't be tolerated. They should be challenged and debunked every step of the way.

Fair enough.

 

[nangyale]

You have piss poor reading comprehension lol where did I say Taliban have zero support?

Majority of the insurgency support is by coercion.

I understand you are here to only troll and your blind hatred towards Pakistan has left you unable to understand ground realities.

Still can you explain to me how is it. That a an insurgency who gets it's support through coercion is able to gain more and more ground from the US and ANA? What is the secret to their success? Is it better training, superior firepower, better logistics, better battlefield medi support, or superior air cover?
Where does the superiority of the insurgency lies?
Please enlighten us.

 

[Kandahari]

I understand you are here to only troll and your blind hatred towards Pakistan has left you unable to understand ground realities.

Still can you explain to me how is it. That a an insurgency who gets it's support through coercion is able to gain more and more ground from the US and ANA? What is the secret to their success? Is it better training, superior firepower, better logistics, better battlefield medi support, or superior air cover?
Where does the superiority of the insurgency lies?
Please enlighten us.

Da Panjabi ghulam, bey namoos, I will not answer you until you give an answer to my question above... I don't respect those that twist the words of others.

I will clarify myself by saying,

Majority of insurgency support by LOCALS is through coercion.

 

[Khanate]

The locals have no choice to give passage, their property, weapons and food. Do you know what the results are if they don't?! I have family in govt and am fully aware of what's going on.

A small percentage of locals do support Taliban probably because of bad experiences with the Afghan govt/US military/stupidity.

The insurgency in Afghanistan is not only run by Taliban (afghans) but various groups from foreign countries.

The locals have choice and they choose Taliban because the government in Kabul is so corrupt.

Over $100 billion has been spent on Afghanistan. Where did it all go? Dubai?

Stop fooling to yourself.

 

[nangyale]

Da Panjabi ghulam, bey namoos,

Wow, thats amazing coming from someone who's country is run by outsiders, with whom you share no border, no culture and no religion. Your country got invaded in 2001 by a power seeking revenge, and Afghanistan is still paying the price.
So sort your own house first before you start pointin fingers at others.
Anyways what makes you think I am anybody's slave(ghulam)? Is it because I burst your bubble and showed the mirror?

I will not answer you until you give an answer to my question above...

I know you are not going to answer me anytime soon. After all you are the one coloured Pink.