Dear Pakistan, I still love you to the moon and back

[nahtanbob]

You cite Wikipedia a lot. But that doesn't seem to be good for you when things are not in your favor.

Well written Wikipedia articles reference credible relevant original sources

There are zero references here

Illegal Immigrants on the Subcontinent - Migration News | Migration Dialogue

migration.ucdavis.edu

if the census report of Pakistan cannot be used as a reference for counting these Bengalis I do not know what can be used

 

[ThunderCat]

Well written Wikipedia articles reference credible relevant original sources

There are zero references here

Illegal Immigrants on the Subcontinent - Migration News | Migration Dialogue

migration.ucdavis.edu

if the census report of Pakistan cannot be used as a reference for counting these Bengalis I do not know what can be used

I see, so if the Pakistani census misses undocumented Binglos living illegally in Pakistan, it automatically means they don't exist.

Nice denial, but it doesn't hide the ground realities. Your country is s shithole and no Pakistani would ever want to live there, meanwhile your people are coming to Pakistan by the millions and your government refuses to take them back.

You're just butt-hurt about that. Did the Pakistani census also miss out on these Bangladeshi students at Pakistani universities https://bsapk.tripod.com/

An authoritative figure on Pakistan's affairs, an old member, @Indus Pakistan would tell you, partition immigrants from Indian Punjab are not Mohajir.

They are indeed. As are Biharis, UP people, Gujaratis amongst others.

 

[ThunderCat]

If you are keen on patterns, most of them are born in Lahore much like the aforementioned Niazi.

And most of them have a love for Bharat after they lost out to the armed forces. Muhajir neo-liberalism comes from the frustration that Pakistani failed to prioritize them/

You can see Tarek Fatah's daughter's reaction. After he passed away he spoke of a "united Hindustan." Did he even know where the real Hindustan lies? Hint:

 

[nahtanbob]

I see, so if the Pakistani census misses undocumented Binglos living illegally in Pakistan, it automatically means they don't exist.

Nice denial, but it doesn't hide the ground realities. Your country is s shithole and no Pakistani would ever want to live there, meanwhile your people are coming to Pakistan by the millions and your government refuses to take them back.

There are numerous official links for Afghan refugees

Welcome to Commissionerate for Afghan Refugees | Commissionerate for Afghan Refugees

car.punjab.gov.pk

Afghanistan | UNHCR

Overview

www.unhcr.org

If Bengali refugees exist
Count them, intern them and/or deport them. Otherwise they do not exist

 

[ThunderCat]

If Bengali refugees exist
Count them, intern them and/or deport them. Otherwise they do not exist

I see so no official links exist; therefore there's no Binglos in Pakistan. Playing by this "logic" all those undocumented Pakistani refugees in Europe are non-existent.

Nice false premise argument. If you read Wiki which you keep citing, it states the Bangla government refused to take them back after Benazir deported them.

Just an attempt to dump all your problems on us.

 

[nahtanbob]

I see so no official links exist; therefore there's no Binglos in Pakistan. Playing by this "logic" all those undocumented Pakistani refugees in Europe are non-existent.

Nice false premise argument. If you read Wiki which you keep citing, it states the Bangla government refused to take them back after Benazir deported them.

Just an attempt to dump all your problems on us.

There are plenty of European government websites with listing of illegal migrant in detentions

What's fueling the Pakistani migrant exodus that ended in tragedy near Greece

Desperation is driving people to take risky voyages.

abcnews.go.com

 

[ThunderCat]

There are plenty of European government websites with listing of illegal migrant in detentions

That's a news article. And not all those migrants are documented and hiding in refugee camps and other hideouts. According to you, they "don't exist."

Basically doing anything to hide the existence of Bangladeshi migrants in Pakistan. In the meantime no Pakistani would dream of going to the shithole that is Bangladesh.

So much for your economic pride.

 

[nahtanbob]

That's a news article. And not all those migrants are documented and hiding in refugee camps and other hideouts. According to you, they "don't exist."

Basically doing anything to hide the existence of Bangladeshi migrants in Pakistan. In the meantime no Pakistani would dream of going to the shithole that is Bangladesh.

So much for your economic pride.

the number of detained and deported Pakistanis migrants are published. you can infer there are some that are not detained.

There is no count of any illegal Bengali immigrants who have migrated post 1971.

Stateless and helpless: The plight of ethnic Bengalis in Pakistan

Even though they are born in Pakistan, ethnic Bengalis deprived of official recognition and citizenship.

www.aljazeera.com

The article clearly states they were living prior to 1971.

people migrate to Europe for a better life. No one save hapless Afghan refugees migrate to Pakistan

Bangladesh is doing pretty well compared to Pakistan in the sense they are not going around begging.

 

[ThunderCat]

the number of detained and deported Pakistanis migrants are published. you can infer there are some that are not detained.

There is no count of any illegal Bengali immigrants who have migrated post 1971.

Stateless and helpless: The plight of ethnic Bengalis in Pakistan

Even though they are born in Pakistan, ethnic Bengalis deprived of official recognition and citizenship.

www.aljazeera.com

The article clearly states they were living prior to 1971.

people migrate to Europe for a better life. No one save hapless Afghan refugees migrate to Pakistan

Bangladesh is doing pretty well compared to Pakistan in the sense they are not going around begging.

Is this a joke???? Scores of Bangladeshis migrated AFTER 1971. The majority of migrants came after 1971. Why do you lie?

They came in the 70s, 80s and 90s. In post 2000s there's millions of them, happy to work for rupees. They work as house maids, paan sellers and common criminals.

If Bangladesh is "doing better" why the f**ck are you people coming to our country? Your country is a dirty dung hole with no clean water for the masses while you Binglo elites come online and troll about your greatness.

Who are you lying to? Trying to cope with your shame in being the world's most overcrowded country? A country f rickshaws and underwear for Walmart.

All that Japanese charity money didn't do sh***t for your filthy impoverished country.

 

[ThunderCat]

No one save hapless Afghan refugees migrate to Pakistan

1 + plus million Binglos in Karachi alone is not 'no one.' They are just a fraction of millions of more Binglos living illigally in Pakistan.

Meanwhile nobody in Pakistan or anywhere would go to an impoverished shithole like Bangladesh. You have the highest levels of population density, pollution, zero hygiene.

All that Japanese charity didn't seem to do sh*t for you.

 

[pallab hazarika]

Shut up you Indiot, India spends billions on military or space projects, while hundreds of millions live in poverty. You shouldn't even be posting crap on this Green Pakistani forum.

Yes, very foolish country, India should try to emulate Pakistan, I like they way they are climbing up the economic ladder and becoming one of the strongest economy along with huge contribution to the world of science and technology, i really envy Pakistan

 

[Olympus81]

You Indians should visit Kemari, Karachi.

There are more Bengalis there than Pakistanis.

 

[ThunderCat]

You Indians should visit Kemari, Karachi.

There are more Bengalis there than Pakistanis.

Didn't know about that but probably true.

 

[nahtanbob]

You Indians should visit Kemari, Karachi.

There are more Bengalis there than Pakistanis.

Are they counted in the census ?

 

[karmaa]

Are they counted in the census ?

They are still in line for citizenship , racism cost them bangladesh .