What's new

Court upholds Centre's decision to dismiss BSF soldier

CaPtAiN_pLaNeT

SENIOR MEMBER
Joined
May 10, 2010
Messages
7,685
Reaction score
0
Court upholds Centre's decision to dismiss BSF soldier

Court upholds Centre's decision to dismiss BSF soldier

New Delhi, Sep 16 (PTI)

The Delhi High Court has upheld the Centre's decision to dismiss a BSF soldier from service for entering a Bangladesh village and firing at residents with his official rifle killing three persons, including a child, three years ago.

A bench of justices Pradeep Nandrajog and Sunil Gaur dismissed a plea of constable Rana Pratap Singh, who was posted along the Indo-Bangladesh border at BOPs Soldighi and Nayabari at the time of incident, challenging the department's decision to sack him for the murder.

"Finding no merit in the writ petition we dismiss the same, but without any order as to costs," the bench said while rejecting the constable's argument that the villagers had abused as well as beaten him up.

"We may only highlight that the manner in which the petitioner (Singh) claims to be hit on his head and thereby losing consciousness and he not knowing how his rifle was used, is not believable for the reason he never cross-examined the eye witnesses by putting his version as aforesaid," the bench said.

According to the charge sheet against Singh, on November 16, 2008 DIG R Chandra had received a telephone call from the Sector Commander, Bangladesh Rifles(BDR) that a BSF personnel had entered into Moyanagri village in Bangladesh and fired indiscriminately at villagers, leaving three persons dead including Mohammed Mustafa, a woman identified as Majeedia Begum and her eight-month-old son Mamoon. Begum's husband was seriously injured in the firing.

The BDR sector commander had also informed that villagers had overpowered and beaten Singh, who was rescued by jawans of BDR and admitted at a local hospital in Bangladesh.
On October 28, 2009, the General Security Court had found Singh guilty and sentenced him to life besides dismissing him from service.

---------- Post added at 12:24 AM ---------- Previous post was at 12:22 AM ----------

Bangladesh youth, chased by BSF, drowns in Thakurgaon border river

UNBconnect... - Bangladesh youth, chased by BSF, drowns in Thakurgaon border river

E-mail PrintDecrease Font SizeIncrease Font Size
Reported by: UNBconnect
Reported on: September 15, 2011 19:03 PM
Reported in: National
Thakurgaon, Sept 15 (UNB) - A Bangladeshi youth, chased by BSF, drowned, as he dived into Nagor River to save himself from BSF torture near his house at Thukrabari village in Baliadangi upazila on Thursday.

The deceased was identified as Anwarul Haque, 26, son of Abu Taher of the village.

Police and family sources said members of India`s Border Security Force (BSF) challenged Anwarul on his way back home from his father-in-law`s house in the afternoon.

Panicked, Anwarul jumped in the river to save his life from attack by India`s Border Security Force (BSF) which swooped on him near the 380 No pillar at around 2 pm.


Members of BGB recovered his body from the river at Beurbari.

The body was handed over to police.

Thakurgaon 20 BGB Battalion Commander Lt Col Abdur Rahman confirmed the incident.

A UD case was lodged with Baliadangi police station.

---------- Post added at 12:26 AM ---------- Previous post was at 12:24 AM ----------

another example of naked violation of human right by this coward and bloody BSF... all these BSF`s should also be persecuted... for their barbaric act.
 
.
And your point is?

Cowards are they or have they turned your pants a colour of yellow.

Don't mess with them is possibly what is the message.

But if they taken law into their own hands, no matter what is the provocation, the Indian Law's heavy hand with visit them.

QED!
 
.
its ok for a Bangladeshi to illegally cross over to India . but not for a BSF jawan to do his duty ,which is to protect the border?

talk of double standards.
 
.
its ok for a Bangladeshi to illegally cross over to India . but not for a BSF jawan to do his duty ,which is to protect the border?

talk of double standards.

Can you explain to me what part of the bsf duty is requires them TO ENTER BANGLADESH and kill innocents??
 
.
A drunk foreign troop entered BD, killed 3 villagers including an infant while they were sleeping, handed over to that very hostile foreign country to face justice.

The justice is "Loose his job" yet by the high court.

He should not had handed over rather placed before the court in BD and sentence should had been capital punishment.
 
.
Can you explain to me what part of the bsf duty is requires them TO ENTER BANGLADESH and kill innocents??

He is talking about the second article, where BSF chased that Bangladeshi who illegally entered India, and drowned in the process.
 
.
A drunk foreign troop entered BD, killed 3 villagers including an infant while they were sleeping, handed over to that very hostile foreign country to face justice.

The justice is "Loose his job" yet by the high court.

He should not had handed over rather placed before the court in BD and sentence should had been capital punishment.
 
. .
He is talking about the second article, where BSF chased that Bangladeshi who illegally entered India, and drowned in the process.

Read these quotes from the second article, i dont think that guy entered india

A Bangladeshi youth, chased by BSF, drowned, as he dived into Nagor River to save himself from BSF torture near his house at Thukrabari village in Baliadangi upazila on Thursday

Police and family sources said members of India`s Border Security Force (BSF) challenged Anwarul on his way back home from his father-in-law`s house in the afternoon.
 
.
No, of course, he did not enter India.

Must have entered outer space!
 
.
Back
Top Bottom