What's new

China, Russia Have Different Takes on Beijing’s Position

manojb

FULL MEMBER
Joined
Jun 18, 2009
Messages
1,943
Reaction score
6
Country
India
Location
United States
If you ask Russia’s foreign ministry, China agrees with the Kremlin about Russian military action in Ukraine. China’s foreign ministry, however, is singing a slightly different song.

In describing a phone call between the foreign ministers of Russia and China, the Russian ministry said Monday that “there was a broad convergence of views between Russia and China in connection to the situation in Ukraine and around it.”

The statement was widely broadcast by Russian media outlets as proof Russia doesn’t stand alone on Ukraine.

But China’s foreign ministry spokesman, Qin Gang, gave a somewhat different take on China’s position.

“It is China’s long-standing position not to interfere in others’ internal affairs. We respect the independence, sovereignty and territorial integrity of Ukraine,” he said, according to a statement posted on the Chinese ministry’s website on Sunday.


Although his statement didn’t criticize Russia outright for sending troops into Ukrainian territory and threatening further use of force, China called for dialogue to resolve the fractious situation in Ukraine.

“China is deeply concerned about the current situation in Ukraine. We condemn the recent extreme and violent acts there and have been urging the relevant parties in Ukraine to resolve their internal disputes peacefully,” he said.

Russia and China have often stood together in the United Nations to block calls by the West for military intervention in crisis-torn countries – most notably in Syria. Chinese leaders have looked to Russia as a bulwark against U.S. and European Union influence around the world.

But in recent years, Beijing has forged stronger commercial relations with Ukraine, purchasing large amounts of corn and some military supplies.

China, Russia Have Different Takes on Beijing’s Position - Wall Street Journal - WSJ.com
 
Well it is not like they can do anything about it. So yeah.
 
Where is Yushchenko?Ukraine must always be a state of Russian independence.
Timoshenko is a Russian and in favor of Russia's interest more than yanukovych as I know.

We respect the independence, sovereignty and territorial integrity of Ukraine,RUSSIA”
 
First and foremost, in order to understand our position, you must understand who we aim to speak of. Do we prefer the Pro-West or Pro-Russia? We did most of our business and had relation with the Pro-Russia Ukraine. We never dealt with the Pro-West Ukraine, so it's hard to imagine us being very enthusiasm supporting the Pro-West but we will stick to our longstanding position of "no interference" because it is the best strategy in foreign affair that is not a major concern to our core interest.
 
Terrible WSJ propaganda article hoping to play 'divide and rule' against Asian countries.

Instead, let's refer to all statements actually made by the Chinese government:
China urges political solution to Ukraine situation - Xinhua | English.news.cn
China FM clarifies stance on Ukraine situation - Xinhua | English.news.cn

  • "China is deeply concerned with the current Ukraine situation"
  • Qin said China has been urging all parties in Ukraine to address their domestic disputes peacefully in accordance with the country's law, safeguard the legitimate rights of the Ukrainian people of all ethnics, and restore social order as soon as possible.
  • Qin said China always sticks to the principle of non-interference in any country's internal affairs and respects the independence, sovereignty and territorial integrity of Ukraine.
  • "There have been reasons for today's situation in Ukraine,"
  • China's stance on the current situation in Ukraine is objective, just, fair and peaceful, Foreign Ministry spokesman Qin Gang said on Monday.
  • "China upholds its own diplomatic principles and the basic codes for international relations, which have also been implied on the Ukraine issue,"
  • "Meanwhile, we have also taken the historical and contemporary factors of the Ukraine issue into consideration."
The two most important parts are: China's respects Ukraine's independence, sovereignty, and territorial integrity, and that China recognizes the historical and contemporary factors about Ukraine that form the reasons for today's situation in Ukraine. So ultimately, it's a mildly pro-Russian position, because China recognizes historical/contemporary factors that compel Russia to intervene. This is also the position reached by the anti-China Japanese government propaganda organ, the Diplomat:

thediplomat.com/2014/03/china-backs-russia-on-ukraine/comment-page-1/
 
Russia backed the friendly goverment and protects Russian assets and Russian national securitiry
USA and EU are trying to establish an illegitimate pro NATO regime and tries to contain Russia.
A NATO puppet regime will enforce anti Chinese sentiment even against Ukraines best interests.
Chinas best interest is Ukraines independence, stability and friendly relationship with Ukraine.
 
Oh please. This is called silent support. Ukraine is not China's fight, as a result, even though we support the Russians, we are not about to jump out and start screaming. If you want to REALLY look at China's stance, just check China's economic and military cooperation with Russia. Did any economic deal gets canceled/delayed? Did any military exercises get canceled/delayed? No? That's more than enough evidence for the support.
 
So China don't support Russia on this issue ?

We don't need explicitely to upset U.S with a declaration when we still able to milk them with trade surplus, a back door or informal support will be sufficient, Russia is capable to handle U.S. Chinese government didn't say anything but it allows our media to carry out their message subtilely.

Only paranoid western media is trying to write their own "Chinese thinking" article such as wall street journal (#1 post ) for self comforting :lol:. And what is India's position?,I didn't see any pro-Russian or anti-Russia articles from your media. Must be too scare of losing spare parts from both side US and Russia I guess :rofl:
 
Last edited:
what is India's position?,I didn't see any pro-Russian or anti-Russia articles from your media. Must be too scare of losing spare parts from both side US and Russia I guess :rofl:[/quote]

Read this ;)

India bats for Russia interests
 
That statement has no indication India will support Russia.

India has sold out to the highest bidder and that is America.
India supporting either side isn't going to change anything. India is an insignificant country on the global scale. No one cares what side india stands on.
 
Back
Top Bottom