China could prove ultimate winner in Afghanistan

[Luffy 500]

Please explain your fantasy.

Not fantasy but facts. India should be cut to size politically & strategically for stability of Asia which is very much possible. Poor Afghans don't know the true face of India.

 

[Kiss_of_the_Dragon]

We seem to have a Chinese Zaid Hamid in making

You seriously think China is remotely capable of affecting the events in Afghanistan?

In you deluded retarded analysis, you forget a basic premise for Chinese presence in Afghanistan. The approval of Afghans themselves.

Given Chinese pro-Pakistani stance, i wonder how many Afghan will appreciate that.

Also Chinese benefits in the long-run for Afghan reconstruction doesn't seem favorable.

Are The Chinese Reliable Partners For Afghan Reconstruction?

Seems like you are geographically challenged in this region too, not just limited rivers from Tibet.

It"ll be treat to see how China balances India there, let alone prevent extremist elements spillover into Xinjiang.

How we enjoy of dealing with Central Asia now, will be the same with Afghanistan..i guess it’s pretty obvious. We don’t need military to assert or to get Afghan approval, they know who to deal with for war torn reconstruction. Afghan people will judge by themselves who is reliable and practical to deal with.

 

[Echo_419]

How we enjoy of dealing with Central Asia now, will be the same with Afghanistan..i guess it’s pretty obvious. We don’t need military to assert or to get Afghan approval, they know who to deal with for war torn reconstruction. Afghan people will judge by themselves who is reliable and practical to deal with.

For the stability of Afghanistan it is the moral duty of 5 big players in the region to help afghan rebuilding
Pakistan,Iran,india,china,russia all have stakes in the region

Greater Sino-Indian relations will ensure peace & prosperity in the region

 

[INDIC]

Not fantasy but facts. India should be cut to size politically & strategically for stability of Asia which is very much possible. Poor Afghans don't know the true face of India.

Go enlighten both Afghans and Iranians about us evil Indians.

 

[Kiss_of_the_Dragon]

Indians have more influence in Afghanistan, they understand our language, they love our Films and music, they come to India in large numbers. But still I think India and China all have same interests in Afghanistan


By the way, China shares only 12km of border with Afghanistan. But we are extremely thankful to Iran for giving us a route to Afghanistan...

How practical influence to get resource from them when you don't have a practical geographic connection even let say Afghannistan favor you more than us? with 12 km boundary will be wide enough to have six lanes express way to carry resource back to China, if we include rail and pipe transportation for gaz.

Beside Afghanistan is look the best interest for themselve through competition bit on the resource, who is willing to pay the most has the last word...so your bollowood culture server no purpose.

 

[INDIC]

How we enjoy of dealing with Central Asia now, will be the same with Afghanistan..i guess it’s pretty obvious. We don’t need military to assert or to get Afghan approval, they know who to deal with for war torn reconstruction. Afghan people will judge by themselves who is reliable and practical to deal with.

I have noticed China is investing billions in Afghanistan but only few millions in Pakistan. Can you tell me why so.

 

[Srinivas]

Yes Indeed, you believe that you gonna get something after China-US exhaust battleling each other?? U.S is helplessly invited India because they can't withstand to counter China along in Afghanistan due to the fact that they're too far away from their own homeland, China just Afghanistan neighbor while India has no frontier with this country, dream to have bigger role doesn't help your cause...American strategy to use India to serve their interest is just epic fail.

Ultimately, US and China will have to sit and arrange some win-win deal, the worst nightmare for you is that China-US come with so secret agreement that exclude India such as we buy Afghanistan resource, US get a some reward $$$ for managing the security and India get nothing.

...and beside don't dream to carry any resource back to India even Afghanistan gorvernement is willing to sell...your old silk road to Afghanistan and central Asia is not longer exist thank to Pakistan...unless you beg them...oh sure Iran road I forgot



LOL, most likely we're there just for you.

Suddenly China bowed before the US for agreement and the real battle have not even started, Chinese have a policy of waiting for years, Why not wait and see for another 50 years before US become weak

Not fantasy but facts. India should be cut to size politically & strategically for stability of Asia which is very much possible. Poor Afghans don't know the true face of India.

Any ways BD will be under water in 2050 why should we care for your rants.

 

[Kiss_of_the_Dragon]

I have noticed China is investing billions in Afghanistan but only few millions in Pakistan. Can you tell me why so.

Hehe nice try, don't highjack the thread, this is about Afghanistan.

 

[INDIC]

How practical influence to get resource from them when you don't have a practical geographic connection even let say Afghannistan favor you more than us? with 12 km boundary will be wide enough to have six lanes express way to carry resource back to China, if we include rail and pipe transportation for gaz.

Beside Afghanistan is look the best interest for themselve through competition bit on the resource, who is willing to pay the most has the last word...so your bollowood culture server no purpose.

But China is preferring connectivity through Tajikistan, not through the mountainous border which is permanently sealed.

We Indians have no problem in business competition but you were asking about influence. In Afghanistan Indian movies and music are seen as a symbol for fight against extremism. Chinese influence is totally nil in this regard.

Hehe nice try, don't highjack the thread, this is about Afghanistan.

I asked a valid question, why suddenly Afghanistan become most important country for China in the region while neglecting other long term ally.

 

[Kiss_of_the_Dragon]

Suddenly China bowed before the US for agreement and the real battle have not even started, Chinese have a policy of waiting for years, Why not wait and see for another 50 years before US become weak

You should learn 14th chapter of Sun Tzu : it's not bow when win objectives without fire a single shot, we get what we want, American get what they want both are happy...simple as that.

 

[Srinivas]

You should learn 14th chapter of Sun Tzu : it's not bow when win objectives without fire a single shot, we get what we want, American get what they want both are happy...simple as that.

China missed that opportunity when US offered G2 block formation and China went too far when it started threatening US allies in East sea and SCS, It even gave warnings to Australia

CCP is more of a bully than a thinker and the chinese behavior in the last decade will cost them lot in the future. US in its history never accepts a growing economy as a friend so that it will become a superior power than USA, US has a habit of crushing any power which challenges its hegemony and history proved it.


Mate regarding Sun Tzu I have read his art of war, but I prefer Chanakya.

 

[Kiss_of_the_Dragon]

But China is preferring connectivity through Tajikistan, not through the mountainous border which is permanently sealed.

We Indians have no problem in business competition but you were asking about influence. In Afghanistan Indian movies and music are seen as a symbol for fight against extremism. Chinese influence is totally nil in this regard.

All come to either economic or political solution: economically yes it's short cut to get resource back to northern cities such Kashgar, but politically we're bit depend on Tajikistan good will...that doesn't prevent us from blowing up mountain to have direct connection to Afghnistan.

 

[Ayush]

China needs to collaborate with PAK IMO in order to kick out the chanakyan vulture from AF. China is way too pacifist when it comes to foreign policies in rest of Asia barring East asia. But then it has its own advantage & helps in enhancing china's soft power & good will. But China needs to be a little more assertive for the sake of stability of Asia & further development of china.

are u obsessed with the word chanakya?

 

[Kiss_of_the_Dragon]

China missed that opportunity when US offered G2 block formation and China went too far when it started threatening US allies in East sea and SCS, It even gave warnings to Australia

CCP is more of a bully than a thinker and the chinese behavior in the last decade will cost them lot in the future. US in its history never accepts a growing economy as a friend so that it will become a superior power than USA, US has a habit of crushing any power which challenges its hegemony and history proved it.


Mate regarding Sun Tzu I have read his art of war, but I prefer Chanakya.

G2 meant nothing to China that why we're not interested, and it's typical that you Indian like to divert the thread and talk about SCS and something else to patch your epic failed arguments and debat about Afghanistan. And you just assume that USA will believe and take your crap as for granted about China?

 

[Srinivas]

G2 meant nothing to China that why we're not interested, and it's typical that you Indian like to divert the thread and talk about SCS and something else to patch your epic failed arguments and debat about Afghanistan. And you just assume that USA will believe and take your crap as for granted about China?

I have mentioned SCS since you have mentioned Sun Tzu.

USA is a the one who is causing the trouble for China by dictating to your neighbors.