The Accountant
PDF THINK TANK: ANALYST
- Joined
- Aug 13, 2016
- Messages
- 8,504
- Reaction score
- 20
- Country
- Location
As i said, you are comparing apples and oranges. I sound like a broken record. I explained the Sunnah method of establishing Ramzan, which you conveniently disregarded.
You are abolishing the Sunnah of moon sighting in favour of lunar calculations. Seems like stopping to me.
Witness testimony is established and verified through proper methods. Otherwise every year there are scores of people purporting to be witnesses of the moon. I agree with your statement on not agreeing to someone saying they sighted the moon when it is scientifically impossible. Using the science as an aid is perfectly permissible.
Allah has given us a brain, not for refining our religion but to follow the religion through thick and thin.To use that brain to accommodate Sunnah in these modern times. Comparing following and refusal to leave Sunnah to being brain dead, is what is actually brain dead. I am a blind follower of Allah and His Prophet (PBUH) alone. I don’t follow any Mullah. I read the Hadeeth and came to my conclusions.
No brother i am not amending ... the sinnah as to have eid on appearance of moon ... moon sighting is sunnah as at that time prediction of moon sighting was not possible but now it is so why not to use it ?
I am asking one simple question that if scientifically you know the witness is saying wrong then still will you accept ? For example in a rape case sunnah was to accept the testimony but now DNA gives more accurate proof so if someone is testifying as pr rules of Quran but DNA is provding evidence against the testimony then what will be your conclusion ? Will you say no i will not accept DNA as Quran says 4 witness are required ...
We have to understand the objective of sunnah and have to get out of this old mindset ...
Stupid people like you opposed loud speakers opposed any technological advancement and are the core reasons we r left behind ...