What's new

Can Temple Gold Help the Rupee?

IMG_0005.JPG



At a time when nothing seems to be able to stem the Indian rupee’s decline, a novel idea to boost the currency is doing the rounds: use the tons of gold stashed away in people’s homes and in temples.

The rupee sank to an all-time low of 65.56 for one U.S. dollar on Thursday (before recovering slightly Friday,) partly on fears that India will find it tough to finance its wide current-account deficit; the gap reflects the fact that India imports more than its exports.

To lower the deficit, the Indian government has announced several steps in recent weeks to reduce its imports, such as raising the import duties on gold.

But market experts aren’t so sure that high prices will deter India’s gold buyers, so some people have come up with an alternate solution: recycle the gold already in India.

India currently holds around 20,000 tons of gold, according to the World Gold Council. At current prices, that would be worth $950 billion.

A small piece of this gold – around 558 tons or 2.79% – is held by the Reserve Bank of India, making it the 11th largest official owner of gold in the world, according to data from the World Gold Council and International Monetary Fund.


The rest is held by households and individuals, in their homes or bank vaults, and by Indian temples, which have historically received gold bars, coins and even jewelry as donations from patrons.

There is no firm estimate of how much gold is held by Indian temples, but it is believed to be several thousand tons. In Sri Padmanabhaswamy temple in Kerala, where a large and intact hoard of temple treasure was discovered in 2011, there is estimated to be gold and jewelry valued at one trillion rupees (US$16billion.)

Jamal Mecklai, founder of Mumbai-based currency consulting firm Mecklai Financial, suggested that the Indian government should make use of some of this temple gold.

In a commentary published last week, Mr. Mecklai said the government should ask the Tirupati Trust Foundation, linked to the eponymous south Indian temple, to deposit its gold stock with India’s state-run banks.

Mr. Mecklai said the banks could pay the Tirupati Trust an interest for its gold, and then sell a large portion of the stock in the domestic market – thus ultimately, reducing the need to import. Mr. Mecklai estimated that the Tirupati Trust holds about 1,700 tons of gold, which would be worth around $81 billion.

On similar lines, an association of jewelers is suggesting that the government encourage individuals to deposit their gold jewelry with banks.

“If we will be able to bring out only 10% of the gold holdings, we don’t need to import any gold for the next two years,” Haresh Soni, chairman of the Mumbai-based All India Gems & Jewellery Trade Federation told India Real Time. Mr. Soni said he has submitted a plan to this effect to the government and some banks.

Indian banks already offer a so-called gold deposit scheme, in which they accept gold bars and jewelry from individuals and pay interest on it. But at the moment, banks require a minimum deposit of 500 grams of gold. Experts say this is too much to ask, since many individuals may want to deposit smaller quantities, say 100 to 200 grams.

Mr. Soni suggests that banks lower their minimum deposit required.

In another suggestion, London Bullion Market Association Chairman David Gornall told The Hindu Business Line newspaper that the Reserve Bank of India could swap the 200 tons of gold that it had bought from the International Monetary fund in 2009, for dollars. This will boost dollar inflows at a time, when foreign investors are taking out the greenback from the country.

Can Temple Gold Help the Rupee? - India Real Time - WSJ

Will India then sell 10,000 tons of its Gold that worth $475 Billions in to the international market???
 
.
.
.
our 3.5 trillion dollars foreign reserve will ensure the stablility of our currency and economy. india should honestly admit its own wrong policies and start to follow our model.
mate you might troll in other threads but for the first time in my entire stay in this forum i completely agree with you in this matter.if India start following the chinese model then it will not only be good for our own economy but also for the entire Asian economy as a whole as India is a major economic power in Asia!but i seriously doubt that our incompetent leaders have the balls to do so!this is the bitter truth about our country...
 
. . .
The Indian government seems to be forgetting (or more likely ignoring) a basic economic principle.

If people are losing trust in currency, they will go for Gold instead. This is a global phenomenon and happens in every country.

So there is an easy way for the Indian government to reduce Gold imports. Stop failing with their currency policy.

If they keep failing in their currency policy then they are basically forcing people to buy Gold instead. They are the ones responsible for the recent surge in Gold imports.
 
.
Not really.

RBI, after massive outrage has rejected.

The Hindu community across India has already raised their voice against such a move as it will hurt their sentiments, which is correct since this wealth is given from charitable/spiritual perspective.

Here's the update:

No plan to convert temple gold into bullion: RBI - The Times of India

is that gold is useful in anyway to the temple if not for the govt ? why don't the temple sell the gold, take the market value in cash so everybody will be benefited.
 
.
is that gold is useful in anyway to the temple if not for the govt ? why don't the temple sell the gold, take the market value in cash so everybody will be benefited.

Or they could just deposit the Gold in a bank, which would allow the banking system to give out more loans to small and medium businesses, and/or invest it in the stock market and provide additional capital to existing businesses.

There are probably a huge number of businesses that deserve a loan or an investment, but haven't been able to get one. These companies can provide a lot of extra productivity to the economy if they only had a bit of capital.
 
.
Or they could just deposit the Gold in a bank, which would allow the banking system to give out more loans to small and medium businesses, and/or invest it in the stock market and provide additional capital to existing businesses.

There are probably a huge number of businesses that deserve a loan or an investment, but haven't been able to get one. These companies can provide a lot of extra productivity to the economy if they only had a bit of capital.

sorry I don't understand that,

how is that system works ?
what is the benefit of bank in having the gold ?
how does it help the bank to fund business or invest in stock market ?
please explain in layman terms.
 
.
sorry I don't understand that,

how is that system works ?
what is the benefit of bank in having the gold ?
how does it help the bank to fund business or invest in stock market ?
please explain in layman terms.

Here you go:

Reserve requirement - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Banks can lend money and invest money based on how much they have in reserve and how much customers have deposited with them. It's like a safety net.

So if customers deposit more money with them, they can loan out more money, and they can invest more money.

China for example has a very high reserve ratio of 20% (the Government is playing it very safe in order to avoid a banking crisis). India has a reserve ratio of 4%, it's in the link I provided.

And here is a quote from the link, on how governments can change the reserve ratio to increase/decrease the amount of bank loans:

The reserve requirement can be used as an instrument of monetary policy, because the higher the reserve requirement is set, the less funds banks will have to loan out.
 
. .
is that gold is useful in anyway to the temple if not for the govt ? why don't the temple sell the gold, take the market value in cash so everybody will be benefited.

Whether it is or not, it is the assets of the temple which is voluntarily given. Similar to what donations we make to our monasteries. We won't want the corrupt regime to take it. Whatever it is, the gold is given by that community for a very strong sentiment and therefore the government, especially this government, has no right to take it.

How about forcing Sonia and her 5 puppets to get back all the black money billions they have stashed away in Switzerland? Why not press them and force them to get it through public outrage and other means?

As an Indian it is our right as people of all communities and all states have paid that tax money and therefore it has to be returned to the public in the form of services, benefits, job creations etc.

What right do these fcking politicians have on that money?
 
. .
I am sure people of India has....

Good isn't it? This is after all a personal donation. We'd go ballistic if our monasteries were asked to compensate for the inefficiencies and corrupt looting of the central government politicians, if we had such a concept of gold giving.
 
.
Back
Top Bottom