What's new

Can Pakistan Emulate Sri Lanka and Act Decisively to End Terror?

RiazHaq

SENIOR MEMBER
Joined
Oct 31, 2009
Messages
6,611
Reaction score
70
Country
Pakistan
Location
United States
Haq's Musings: Can Pakistan Learn From Sri Lanka's Rajapaksa to End Terror?

Sri Lankan military defeated the terrorists of the Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eelam (the LTTE or the Tamil Tigers) in 2009 after a war that lasted 26 years.

This period included a long series of talks and peace deals, all violated by the LTTE. After many years of on and off half-hearted attempts to quell LTTE insurgency, it took the determined leadership of President Mahinda Rajapaksa to declare an all-out war against LTTE with Pakistan's help to defeat the terrorist group in just three years. President Rajapksa made it his top priority. He built broad public support for his military campaign and followed through with ruthless execution of his plan.


Initially trained and supported by Raw, the Indian intelligence agency, in the 1980s, the Tamil Tigers met their bloody end at the hands of Lankan military using arms manufactured and supplied by Pakistan.

Alarmed by reports of Pakistani arms supplies to Sri Lanka in 2008, India said it wanted Sri Lanka to treat Tamils with dignity and also voiced concern that Colombo’s arms purchases may upset New Delhi’s “pre-eminent position” in South Asia. “We are facing a situation where the ceasefire (in Sri Lanka) could collapse. This could lead to a flashpoint,” National Security Adviser M.K. Narayanan said while delivering the 25th Air Chief Marshal P.C. Lal memorial lecture.

India refused to supply what it considered "offensive weapons" to Sri Lanka and opposed any military solution of the "ethnic conflict" while urging Colombo to devolve autonomy to the minorities.

According the News quoting reliable sources in Pakistan, military cooperation between Sri Lanka and Pakistan has grown significantly in recent years as Islamabad, unlike New Delhi, has had no problems supplying Sri Lanka's army state-of-the-art weaponry to accelerate its counter-insurgency operations against the LTTE which finally ended with the killing of the most wanted Tamil guerrilla fighter Vellupillai Prabhakaran. The sources said it was in the first week of May 2008 that Sri Lankan Army Chief General Fonseka came to Pakistan with his shopping list of high tech arms for the Lankan armed forces, who were engaged in an intense battle with the Tamil Tiger rebels at the time.

After Fonseca's visit, Pakistan sold 22 Al-Khalid tanks to Sri Lanka in a deal worth over US$100 million. Sri Lanka also purchased Multi-Barrel Rocket Launcher System (MBRLS), cluster bombs, deep penetration bombs and rockets and Unmanned Aerial Vehicles (UAV) from Pakistan, according to various reports. In fact, Sri Lanka, along with some Middle Eastern nations, has now become one of the largest buyers of Pakistani arms in the last few years.

On Jan 19, 2009, in a meeting between Pakistani Defense Secretary Lt-Gen (retd) Syed Athar Ali and his visiting Lankan counterpart Gotabhaya Rajapakse, the brother of Sri Lankan president, in Rawalpindi, an agreement was reached to enhance cooperation in military training, exercises and intelligence sharing regarding terrorism. The agreement came amid Sri Lankan media reports that the Pakistan Air Force (PAF) pilots had participated in several successful air strikes against LTTE military bases in August 2008. These reports further claimed that a highly trained group of the Pakistani armed forces officers is posted in Colombo to guide the Sri Lankan security forces in their counter-insurgency operations against the Tamil Tigers.

LTTE was initially funded, trained and equipped by RAW, the Indian intelligence agency. Tamil-speaking LTTE terrorists used the Indian state of Tamil Nadu as safe haven. Palk strait separating SriLanka from India is just 33 miles. It is easier to cross than the mountainous Afghanistan-Pakistan border.

LTTE's vicious campaign of terror claimed over 100,000 lives in a country with a population of just 20 million, about the same as Karachi's population. It included aerial attacks, and use of gun boats and suicide bombings.

LTTE started using suicide bombings as a terror tactic well before Al Qaeda did. LTTE victims included Prime Minister Rajiv Gandhi of India who was killed by a female LTTE suicide bomber. Another victim was former Sri Lankan President Chandrika Kumaratunga who lost an eye when her election rally was attacked by LTTE. The deaths include at least 27,639 LTTE fighters, 23,790 Sri Lankan soldiers and policemen, 1,155 Indian soldiers, and tens of thousands of civilians.

Some argue that the Pakistani Taliban are a much more difficult foe to defeat. Others argue that FATA can not be "conquered". They cite history of the Russians and the British to support their claim. I see these as seriously flawed analogies.

The reality is that nobody is talking about "conquering" FATA. To the contrary, the people of FATA need to be rescued from a band of thugs and criminals who are terrorizing the ordinary people of FATA and using North Waziristan as their base of operations. The Taliban recruit and train bombers and send them out into various town of cities of Pakistan to kill innocent people. Pakistani military is not a foreign military attempting to occupy FATA. In fact, there are significant numbers of people from federally administered tribal areas who are part of Pakistani security forces.

It's also a fact that the LTTE terrorists in Sri Lanka were just as just as vicious and determined as the TTP terrorists today. LTTE made and violated multiple peace deals over a long period. Sri Lankan leaders were as patient (clueless?) as Pakistani leaders are today. It all changed with the arrival of Rajapaksa who decided enough was enough. He disregarded the usual rights groups and other do-gooders to do what had to be done to rid his country of the scourge of terrorism by taking decisive action starting in 2006.

With daily carnage in the streets of Pakistan, the nation is suffering from extremely low economic growth rates of just 2-3% a year. Over 40,000 people have become victims of the Taliban terror. Foreign and domestic investments have dried up. There are widespread blackouts and energy shortages. Very jobs are being created. Foreign investors, tourists, sports teams and business executives are shying away from the country. Pakistan can not afford the continuation of the status quo. It must act quickly and decisively to end the ongoing reign of terror by the Pakistani Taliban and their various affiliates who share their hateful ideology and collaborate to achieve their aims.

Does Pakistan have a Mahinda Rajapaksa? Alternatively, can Pakistani leaders learn from Rajapaksa's experience?

Here's a recent video discussion of continuing terror attacks in Pakistan:


Haq's Musings: Can Pakistan Learn From Sri Lanka's Rajapaksa to End Terror?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
.
Very simple difference, when the Sri Lankan army launched its final decisive offensive to end the LTTE.. the pushed the LTTE to the shores of the sea where they had no escape.
By contrast, militants in Pakistan can escape to the following places to avoid death.

1) Cities in Pakistan
2) Afghanistan
3) Remote Areas in Pakistan

You can eliminate 1 & 3 perhaps by a massive quarantine of the area but cannot do the same for 2.
 
.
Very simple difference, when the Sri Lankan army launched its final decisive offensive to end the LTTE.. the pushed the LTTE to the shores of the sea where they had no escape.
By contrast, militants in Pakistan can escape to the following places to avoid death.

1) Cities in Pakistan
2) Afghanistan
3) Remote Areas in Pakistan

You can eliminate 1 & 3 perhaps by a massive quarantine of the area but cannot do the same for 2.

Tamil-speaking LTTE terrorists used the Indian state of Tamil Nadu as safe haven. Palk strait separating SriLanka from India is just 33 miles. It is easier to cross than the mountainous Afghanistan-Pakistan border.
 
.
Very simple difference, when the Sri Lankan army launched its final decisive offensive to end the LTTE.. the pushed the LTTE to the shores of the sea where they had no escape.
By contrast, militants in Pakistan can escape to the following places to avoid death.

1) Cities in Pakistan
2) Afghanistan
3) Remote Areas in Pakistan

You can eliminate 1 & 3 perhaps by a massive quarantine of the area but cannot do the same for 2.

Well, there are also solutions for no. 2 but the key here is to deny them any physical territory. Insurgencies need bases, if that be Afghanistan, we'd be in a much better condition than today, the reason is, the attacks from Militants from Afghanistan will have to cross a border, for example, TTP Swat chapter, they have been mounting attacks on border check-posts, but they were unable to make any move to their former base.

In the same way, when there will be loss of manpower and resources, which TTP has quite for now, in NWA, they can easily be dealt with, when they are operating from Afghanistan. Precision strikes into Afghanistan is one option, which I really support, though there are others too, which require the use of SFs, but Air Force can be useful here.

So the point is, once NWA is cleared, we wont have any major territory physically being controlled by the TTP, so, that gives us the chance to repeat what we did in Operation Raah-e-Nijat, but this time, taking the war to an end.
 
.
The biggest difference between LTTE and Pakistani Terrorists is that while the first was based on ethnicity the latter is based on religion. And given that the sole basis of Pakistan's existence is the same religion, it become extremely tough for Pakistan to act against that ideology. Specially since the concept of Muslim first, Pakistani later is extremely prevalent in Pakistan and the end to religious extremism (leading to terrorism) needs to be preceded by a humongous change in the mindsets around the same
 
.
Well, there are also solutions for no. 2 but the key here is to deny them any physical territory. Insurgencies need bases, if that be Afghanistan, we'd be in a much better condition than today, the reason is, the attacks from Militants from Afghanistan will have to cross a border, for example, TTP Swat chapter, they have been mounting attacks on border check-posts, but they were unable to make any move to their former base.

In the same way, when there will be loss of manpower and resources, which TTP has quite for now, in NWA, they can easily be dealt with, when they are operating from Afghanistan. Precision strikes into Afghanistan is one option, which I really support, though there are others too, which require the use of SFs, but Air Force can be useful here.

So the point is, once NWA is cleared, we wont have any major territory physically being controlled by the TTP, so, that gives us the chance to repeat what we did in Operation Raah-e-Nijat, but this time, taking the war to an end.

Ha! HA!:rofl: Wars in Afghanistan are unending. Even great powers come here just to go back sheepishly from the "Graveyard of Empires"

And a puny country like Pak imagines ending the war??

By the way, KPK and FATA are historically parts of Afghanistan....and its just a matter of time.

Read up whats being planned for your country by the great powers.
 
.
The biggest difference between LTTE and Pakistani Terrorists is that while the first was based on ethnicity the latter is based on religion. And given that the sole basis of Pakistan's existence is the same religion, it become extremely tough for Pakistan to act against that ideology. Specially since the concept of Muslim first, Pakistani later is extremely prevalent in Pakistan and the end to religious extremism (leading to terrorism) needs to be preceded by a humongous change in the mindsets around the same

Those terrorist are fighting for land in the name of religion not for religion.
Go and have a survey in SWAT how pious and religious those people were……:coffee:
They are just fooling this nation Shiriya is not a force its a way to live noone can force a muslim to live in another way he wants coz this is matter b/w him and Allah who are these farmi mullas to Force Islam through illegal Arms which are built by Yahoodis(jews) & those kaffirs(non holy book holder) whom which they are against off?? :lol:
 
.
Simple.. We kill these Indian terrorists like Sri Lanka killed their Indian terrorists... Now look at state of Indians in Sri Lanka. India cowers behind Sri Lanka and Sri Lanka can kill any Indian it likes

Ha! HA!:rofl: Wars in Afghanistan are unending. Even great powers come here just to go back sheepishly from the "Graveyard of Empires"

And a puny country like Pak imagines ending the war??

By the way, KPK and FATA are historically parts of Afghanistan....and its just a matter of time.

Read up whats being planned for your country by the great powers.

Since when Pashtuns in KPK want to be with Afghanistan... Heck afghans come HERE! LOL.

Btw don't wish death for others... We have already shown what we can do with Kashmir... If we rile up whole 180 mn Indian Muslim population, India is screwed...
We could make it look like the Hindu govt is killing Muslims.. Maybe even try a couple of riots simultaneously... That could set off the spark. :lol:
Partition 1947 repeating?
 
.
Tamil-speaking LTTE terrorists used the Indian state of Tamil Nadu as safe haven. Palk strait separating SriLanka from India is just 33 miles. It is easier to cross than the mountainous Afghanistan-Pakistan border.

Tamils initially supported the LTTE and affiliates due to ethnic politics, however towards the end they became supportive of a larger national cause than just ethnicity hence the LTTE had nowhere to go but the ocean. They were not welcome in Tamil Nadu anymore.

Question is, can Pakistani and Afghani Pashtuns put Pakistaniyat and Afghanism before Islam and Pashtunwali?
 
.
Simple.. We kill these Indian terrorists like Sri Lanka killed their Indian terrorists... Now look at state of Indians in Sri Lanka. India cowers behind Sri Lanka and Sri Lanka can kill any Indian it likes

Taliban-linked militant group TTP Jundullah claimed responsibility within hours of the suicide bombings.

When did Taliban became Indian terrorists??? If it makes it easy to kill these scum by calling them Indian terrorists then so be it. LOL
 
.
Those terrorist are fighting for land in the name of religion not for religion.
Go and have a survey in SWAT how pious and religious those people were……:coffee:
They are just fooling this nation Shiriya is not a force its a way to live noone can force a muslim to live in another way he wants coz this is matter b/w him and Allah who are these farmi mullas to Force Islam through illegal Arms which are built by Yahoodis(jews) & those kaffirs(non holy book holder) whom which they are against off?? :lol:

Dude, I do not disagree with that. Both in Srilanka and Pakistan, the ideology is a front for the real vested interests. However the religious ideology used as a front in Pakistan is much more difficult to smash thru than the ethnic ideology that was in use in Srilanka
 
.
Any terrorism can be controlled, quashed and eliminated....provided the armed forces are impartial....which is not the case with pakistan....simple...
 
.
To control any situation the first thing needed is the will to do it.

In case of Pakistan, there appears to be a chasm between what the Govt wants and what the PA wishes.

Here lies the diff between SL & Pak situations.
 
.
Dude, I do not disagree with that. Both in Srilanka and Pakistan, the ideology is a front for the real vested interests. However the religious ideology used as a front in Pakistan is much more difficult to smash thru than the ethnic ideology that was in use in Srilanka

Actually you can say that illiteracy is basic problem.
People here don't have common sence nor have basic religious knowledge.
Here people had given Islam in hand of such illiterate mullahs who can just read quran fastly i.e just can read Arabic and can't understand it.
You can then well imagine how can such common mullahs use religion for their personal benifits.
Here Islam is a ball being played by KSA,UAE,Iran and those mullahs who ain't intrested in religion.
They are just dividing people and ripping them to take some money and benifits.
 
.
Ha! HA!:rofl: Wars in Afghanistan are unending. Even great powers come here just to go back sheepishly from the "Graveyard of Empires"

And a puny country like Pak imagines ending the war??

By the way, KPK and FATA are historically parts of Afghanistan....and its just a matter of time.

Read up whats being planned for your country by the great powers.

Uh! Seriously? Please, go get some sleep, you're out of your senses.
 
.

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom