BREAKING!!! Half of US troops to leave Afghanistan by May 1: Taliban

[ziaulislam]

You ignorant runt, Pathans are Muslims in Pakistan and part of a Muslim majority.

Muslims in India are a minority in a Hindu majority country.

Now shoo.

You cannot tell the difference because you are dishonest.

Game is almost over..the future is afgan tajik, afgan uzbek and Afghan pushtoon States

They even have selected defacto leaders for these states

 

[MultaniGuy]

Game is almost over..the future is afgan tajik, afgan uzbek and Afghan pushtoon States

They even have selected defacto leaders for these states

Yes this pathetic excuse for a country called Afghanistan should be partitioned along ethnic lines.

 

[TheUndertaker]

Ultimately you will see Afghanistan splitting in multiple states already happening with help of USA ..
Each state will be a proxy of neighboring Pakistan iran and uzeb/Tajikistan and than ultimately swallowed by respective states if local population decides so ...

Only way this will be avoided if afghans own the afghan name to its current geography and refuse to indulge in ethnic politics


Those pushtoon that defeated empires now live in Pakistan while a small minority now remain in dusted areas of Afghanistan

Both by area and population Pakistani pushtoons now number 3x of what ever small legacy that's left

Good luck with that ..soon in months their will be
1. pushtoon Afghanistan led by taliban
2. tajik Afghanistan by burahnuddin(previous President )
3.and uzbek/hazara led by general dostum Afghanistan ...

I am talking in next few months not years thanks to india and Afghans in fighting

Loll sounds more like what it used to be under the Taliban rule.

 

[MultaniGuy]

Loll sounds more like what it used to be under the Taliban rule.

Seriously you are not Afghanistani. And Afghanistan is a destroyed country.

You are most probably an Indian. Why pretend to be an Afghanistani? Ashamed of your true identity.

 

[ziaulislam]

Loll sounds more like what it used to be under the Taliban rule.

Seriously you are not Afghanistani. And Afghanistan is a destroyed country.

You are most probably an Indian. Why pretend to be an Afghanistani? Ashamed of your true identity.

THE FUTURE and defacto status before Taliban almost united the country
1. Pushtoons led by talis
2. Dostum land(uzbeks)
3. Burhunddin land (tajiks)

 

[MultaniGuy]

THE FUTURE and defacto status before Taliban almost united the country

Your map of Pakistan is wrong. Pakistan has a huge chunk of Kashmir.

Why are these mapmakers so dishonest. These maps should be made illegal!

 

[Nilgiri]

drone strikes will do the work .

Blackwater too. There is whole different perspective that many here are too deluded to even contemplate....coz they need some "win" inside to vindicate whatever gaping chasm formed all these years.

Not to mention "fill em up" by @Tokhme khar 's lads...take out one fuel tank, another replaces it....and they are just waiting for opportunity to illustrate exactly what happened in Syria...on the other side of Persian cultural space. Most Afghans speak Persian for a reason you know.

@Cthulhu @SOHEIL @Ziggurat “TepeSialk“

 

[ziaulislam]

Your map of Pakistan is wrong. Pakistan has a huge chunk of Kashmir.

Why are these mapmakers so dishonest. These maps should be made illegal!

I guess its fixed now

Blackwater too. There is whole different perspective that many here are too deluded to even contemplate....coz they need some "win" inside to vindicate whatever gaping chasm formed all these years.

Not to mention "fill em up" by @Tokhme khar 's lads...take out one fuel tank, another replaces it....and they are just waiting for opportunity to illustrate exactly what happened in Syria...on the other side of Persian cultural space. Most Afghans speak Persian for a reason you know.

@Cthulhu @SOHEIL @Ziggurat “TepeSialk“

Will it has to be Indian blackwater and drones as USA is fedup..

 

[Nilgiri]

Will it has to be Indian blackwater and drones as USA is fedup..

Not really. If they are truly "fed up", they would have done complete withdrawal, not just half....and certainly not replace the half thats going with other (less command chain needed) ways to accomplish things on the ground where needed.

US 4 star General (theatre level i.e CENTCOM) I believe spoke on this just recently. He sees it completely different to most members here....I wonder who has better perspective on it?

@VCheng @Joe Shearer @padamchen @OsmanAli98

 

[ziaulislam]

Not really. If they are truly "fed up", they would have done complete withdrawal, not just half....and certainly not replace the half thats going with other (less command chain needed) ways to accomplish things on the ground where needed.

US 4 star General (theatre level i.e CENTCOM) I believe spoke on this just recently. He sees it completely different to most members here....I wonder who has better perspective on it?

@VCheng @Joe Shearer @padamchen @OsmanAli98

Oh its going to complete with draw ..this is now a bipartisan issue and nothing can stop it
7 trillion dollars is too much ..the anger is nlw at its boiling point

Centom thought the same in Vietnam war..once people loose the appetite for war the generals cant do anything

Issue of Afghanistan will be settled via a three way divide whether this will be permanent divide is actually the question

 

[Joe Shearer]

Not really. If they are truly "fed up", they would have done complete withdrawal, not just half....and certainly not replace the half thats going with other (less command chain needed) ways to accomplish things on the ground where needed.

US 4 star General (theatre level i.e CENTCOM) I believe spoke on this just recently. He sees it completely different to most members here....I wonder who has better perspective on it?

@VCheng @Joe Shearer @padamchen @OsmanAli98

Definitely the members here. They know much more than these silly generals. And there's a reason for that, and it stares us in the face. I'm not going to reproduce it; it's a 100% guarantee of getting permanently banned.

 

[GHALIB]

Oh its going to complete with draw ..this is now a bipartisan issue and nothing can stop it
7 trillion dollars is too much ..the anger is nlw at its boiling point

Centom thought the same in Vietnam war..once people loose the appetite for war the generals cant do anything

Issue of Afghanistan will be settled via a three way divide whether this will be permanent divide is actually the question

what three way divide ?
pastun, uzbek, tazik ?

Definitely the members here. They know much more than these silly generals. And there's a reason for that, and it stares us in the face. I'm not going to reproduce it; it's a 100% guarantee of getting permanently banned.

agree .

 

[Pan-Islamic-Pakistan]

THE FUTURE and defacto status before Taliban almost united the country
1. Pushtoons led by talis
2. Dostum land(uzbeks)
3. Burhunddin land (tajiks)

This should be prevented at all costs. I much rather prefer one dominant government under Pukhtoons to unite Afghans into one nation. This might be the only time to accomplish this as the wind is in the sails of the Taliban and their desire for one government.

They even have selected defacto leaders for these states

Who are the leaders of the Tajik and Uzbek regions? What about Hazarajat?

 

[ziaulislam]

This should be prevented at all costs. I much rather prefer one dominant government under Pukhtoons to unite Afghans into one nation. This might be the only time to accomplish this as the wind is in the sails of the Taliban and their desire for one government.



Who are the leaders of the Tajik and Uzbek regions? What about Hazarajat?

united Afghanistan will not happen as each ethnic group dont tolerate the other and is messing around the geography of Afghanistan..how do you think the tajik feels if Afghanistan talks about moving the boarder with pakistan..
hazaras might potentially form separate part..the reason why i mention it could be a four way divide
though historically tajiks dominated hazaras areas

uzbek--> general dostum
tajiks-->president bhurhunaddin

-----------------
people who have lived in around Afghanistan/KPK and have seen the people upclose, noticed their divide, talked and dinned with them know much more than foreign generals who come for 2 years and than are fired..what i mention here is what happened in 1990s and what is highly likley to be repeated again....people use to laugh about USA getting tired in Afghanistan..guess what its happening

 

[Joe Shearer]

@GHALIB

Look above.

QED.