BJP warns govt. over Kashmir

[Evil Flare]

What kashmiri people wants ??? Lets decide by referendum like it happens everywhere in the world .

 

[Gandhi G in da house]

if muslims are ready to commit mass genocide then army is also ready
and believe me, all of us would support army in that case also

Its because of people like you that inspite of hating Congress ,people don't vote for BJP and they end up losing in elections . Grow up .

 

[Abu Zolfiqar]

Referendum even today seems like a most fashionable and fair option. . .

indians often argue ''why would Kashmiris opt for Pakistan...''

so with that over-confidence, i dont see what clouds their thinking. Perhaps the ground-realities are known too much to them?




and im not even implying all Kashmiris are pro-Pakistan....some want total independence. But why not let a referendum determine the popular consensus and then implement it so we cuud move forward

 

[MrIndianSikh]

Please don't ask this question atleast from those who has lost their family members while fighting in Kashmir!!!!

thousands of soldiers on both sides have died for Kashmir... Kashmirs white snow covered valleys and mountains stained with blood of our brothers and sisters and for what? just recognize Loc as IB both sides keep Kashmir i can see why Pakistan wants Kashmir because of water but why does India need ?

 

[Mabs]

I fully support BJP
my next vote would be for BJP

Lol, yes my man that wasn't very difficult to figure out after looking at your avatar.

 

[Mabs]

Without attaching any nationalistic sentiments to it, I do not see how a referendum would favor Pakistan and go against India. Pakistan has an equal chance of losing its chunk of Kashmir if the people decide to merge it with India and vice-versa. Just let the people of the land decide what they want and all parties involved in the matter should respect their wishes. If Pakistanis are willing to take this chance for the sake of humanity, I don't see what could be the problem on the Indian side. We seriously have played enough with the lives of Kashmiris now, its time to give them some closure.

 

[Jade]

Referendum even today seems like a most fashionable and fair option. . .

indians often argue ''why would Kashmiris opt for Pakistan...''

so with that over-confidence, i dont see what clouds their thinking. Perhaps the ground-realities are known too much to them?




and im not even implying all Kashmiris are pro-Pakistan....some want total independence. But why not let a referendum determine the popular consensus and then implement it so we cuud move forward

Lot of blood has flown in last 60 years for referendum to be held, neither is Pakistan in strong position to demand referendum

 

[Abu Zolfiqar]

Lot of blood has flown in last 60 years for referendum to be held, neither is Pakistan in strong position to demand referendum

that's debatable....but in actuality, it is the Kashmiris in question. And they are more educated now, and thanks to social media and the internet they are more enabled to share their day to day experiences under occupation


(why do you think there are such draconian laws in place there?)

 

[Jade]

Without attaching any nationalistic sentiments to it, I do not see how a referendum would favor Pakistan and go against India. Pakistan has an equal chance of losing its chunk of Kashmir if the people decide to merge it with India and vice-versa. Just let the people of the land decide what they want and all parties involved in the matter should respect their wishes. If Pakistanis are willing to take this chance for the sake of humanity, I don't see what could be the problem on the Indian side. We seriously have played enough with the lives of Kashmiris now, its time to give them some closure.

No use talking about referendum. The solution could be

For India: LOC =IB
For Pakistanies: better water security
For Kashmiries: Greater autonomy

 

[Mabs]

Lot of blood has flown in last 60 years for referendum to be held, neither is Pakistan in strong position to demand referendum

Forget about Pakistan being in a strong position to demand it. Aren't Kashmiris as humans entitled to that basic right ? Let's for once stop looking at the Kashmir issue from an India-Pakistan standpoint and see it from a Kashmir standpoint.

 

[lem34]

What have india or pakistan gained out of this fruitless excersise over the last 63 years. we have wasted our resourses and more importatly precious lives on all side have been lost. Its all very well those of us who can afford computers and come on the internet to spout venom. guys dont eat for a day and then remember when you feel realy hungry that both in india and pakistan we have millions who go to sleep every day like that because we prefer bullets to bread. We have nukes but our populations starve, People in both countries are being killed for kashmir. tell a mother hindu muslim sikh or any other religion who lost a son in kargill etc that it was a cause worth losing their child. Guys are we so stupid after 63 year of stupid cynical basxxtd politicians using this issue on both sides to wind people up we still fall for it. Its time to sit and talk indians and pakistanis if not brothers we are at least cousins and we should resolve this matter peacefully.

 

[Jade]

that's debatable....but in actuality, it is the Kashmiris in question. And they are more educated now, and thanks to social media and the internet they are more enabled to share their day to day experiences under occupation


(why do you think there are such draconian laws in place there?)

No use discussing things that are untenable.

 

[Hindustani]

The only people who have a problem with being part of India in Kashmir as a whole, would be the people from the the Kashmir Valley. They have followed some strange ideology with "Muslim brothers uniting" even if it means killing the kaffirs (Kashmiri Pandits)

Look at any landlocked country particularly in Asia. They're either heavily dependent on neighboring countries as well as considered poor states for an example.. Nepal, Mongolia, Bhutan, Afghanistan, Azerbaijan, Uzbekistan etc.

 

[JayAtl]

interesting to read some comments here. The statement is made purely politically trickery, it had no actual factual reason behind it--- but it worked to even fool the so called educated Indian janta on this board. In the article itself they say " we hear sometimes that blah blah" -- so basically someone said and so we put out press release

Tomorrow, they will put out a statement " BJP says there will be not support destroying all its nuclear stockpiles by this govt because the tooth fairy said the congress will do so" ----and we will have folks here go _ damn! I'm voting for the BJP!

I'm no congress fan , for that matter I'm no fan of any political party or against the two parties. It's just funny to see how you guys get fooled...Hilarious! to be hoodwinked by any party so easily!

 

[misterme2]

Forget about Pakistan being in a strong position to demand it. Aren't Kashmiris as humans entitled to that basic right ? Let's for once stop looking at the Kashmir issue from an India-Pakistan standpoint and see it from a Kashmir standpoint.

They are humans but after all the blood shed, sorry such demands cannot be met ever, ever again. Pakistan has laready flooded the area with Non Kashmiris in their possession, so India would flood the area before any referendum took place. The only other option is to go to Pakistan and demand freedom for the chunk over there. Keep it simple.

If any referendum was to take price, certain steps have to be taken. The first and most important criteria would be for China to give the chunk that Pakistan gave away, which reminds me if Pakistan cared so much why would you give away their land and never request it back mmm?