Balakot air strike: Why IAF used 907-kg ‘penetrator’ bombs to target Jaish terror camp

[Qutb-ud-din Aybak]

https://www.google.com/amp/s/thepri...bombs-to-target-jaish-terror-camp/205227/amp/



Look at the maths man.
Read carefully then raise your points

Those roofs are so easy to blow away that Pakistan easily removed them from all houses in one operation so that no terrorist could hide inside those buildings.

Secondly, new day new theory, new maths. Even Israel could not kill people in such small non concrete buildings without damaging the building.

 

[xyxmt]

because they wanted to destroy exactly 8 pine trees, no less

 

[SrNair]

@SrNair

"The British news agency Reuters says high-resolution satellite images show buildings which India claimed its warplanes had hit in Balakot killing a large number of militants still standing at the site.

The images produced by Planet Labs, a San Francisco-based private satellite operator has shown at least six buildings on the site six days after the airstrike.

The image is virtually unchanged from an April 2018 satellite photo of the facility.

There are no discernible holes in the roofs of buildings, no signs of blown-out walls, displaced trees around the site or other signs of an aerial attack."

OR are you suggesting that all the international media and independent groups performing satellite imagery analysis are faking this?

Well ,after that what happened?
Reuters complained few times that they dont have access.

Then all of those assumption on the basis of that it was a Mk84 but it was not .
This a different kind pentrator either full package from Israel or just only kit but rest of the penetrator designed in India.

He even mentioned the soil type of Balakot .
Then eyewitness said that entire earth was shaking.
Had it been a MK84 the building will oblierate and shock was less .
This just pentrated deep inside to thecm earth and explode causing more shock to
Earth but less harm to building

 

[AgNoStiC MuSliM]

Look at the maths man.
Read carefully then raise your points

You do realize that after all the calculations he provided, he ended the piece with outright assumptions (that the force of the explosion would be less than required to collapse the building) and has no answers to the independent (non Indian) satellite image analysis that shows NO holes in the roof and NO other destroyed structures, as he claims.

The fact that the author is making at least 2 claims that have already been debunked by international media and satellite image analysts really puts the credibility of the author in doubt.

Well ,after that what happened?
Reuters complained few times that they dont have access.

Then all of those assumption on the basis of that it was a Mk84 but it was not .
This a different kind pentrator either full package from Israel or just only kit but rest of the penetrator designed in India.

He even mentioned the soil type of Balakot .
Then eyewitness said that entire earth was shaking.
Had it been a MK84 the building will oblierate and shock was less .
This just pentrated deep inside to thecm earth and explode causing more shock to
Earth but less harm to building

Doesn't matter if they got access or not. Interviews with the local residents indicated no damage to the madrassa and satellite imagery analysis show no holes.

 

[SrNair]

I'm pointing out that unless these bombs also have the ability to patch the holes in the ceiling/roof behind them as they enter, and douse the flames etc caused by the explosion instantly, as to not leave any remnants of any kind of an explosion behind, they did not hit the intended target, or the intended target was in fact the trees, with Modi's plan being to hide the fact that nothing was actually hit behind his massive Indian media manipulation.

Holes on the big roof is actually a mystery as per this author.
He is saying perhaps that one is sharpnels .

He is also raising several points that medias pointed out.

Regarding proof ,They wont release it
India wont release ops details .

 

[Vapnope]

Indians claim to have one of the best satellite image resolution however there are still no pictures of funeral of 300 dead terrorists. I wonder what happened to the space power prowess?

 

[AgNoStiC MuSliM]

Holes on the big roof is actually a mystery as per this author.
He is saying perhaps that one is sharpnels .

He is also raising several points that medias pointed out.

Regarding proof ,They wont release it
India wont release ops details .

This author can say whatever he wants, but multiple international analyses of satellite imagery show NO holes and NO destroyed structures, tertiary or primary. So without any evidence of holes, all his calculations mean nothing.

Indians claim to have one of the best satellite image resolution however there are still no pictures of funeral of 300 dead terrorists. I wonder what happened to the space power prowess?

Cloud cover, or maybe Modi farted at just the right time and ended up blinding their satellites.

 

[undercover JIX]

Wait for the final version, which will be released by bollywood.

daily new drama. if it was 2012 the super power India would have used invisible Fighters, bombs etc and deadboys would have vanished without leaving any traces, and not even a scratch to the building, structure and in the area. ohhh and everything silent, no sound so dont ask for any witnesses.

 

[newb3e]

pissfull indians,caring indians used that bomb so poor Pakistan doesnt suffer any infrastructure damage and dont waste any resources rebuilding.The bomb was dipped in ganga water and only killed jesh terrorist inside all 350 of them but dint even damage a brick.

 

[SrNair]

This author can say whatever he wants, but multiple international analyses of satellite imagery show NO holes and NO destroyed structures, tertiary or primary. So without any evidence of holes, all his calculations mean nothing.


Cloud cover, or maybe Modi farted at just the right time and ended up blinding their satellites.

Those multiple authors didnt try to dissect the points raised by Indian side.
All of those are some paid medias and non existent thinkers

 

[AgNoStiC MuSliM]

Those multiple authors didnt try to dissect the points raised by Indian side.
All of those are some paid medias and non existent thinkers

There are no points that need 'dissecting'

Multiple international media organizations and journalists reported directly from the site of the attacks.
- They viewed the craters and saw fragments of Indian bombs in the craters. The journalists saw the craters which means the bombs landed in that location and not on the Madrassa (really simplifying it for you)
- They interviewed multiple local residents as to the events that occurred. All the residents offered largely the same narrative of events in terms of what had occurred and the number of explosions they heard and that no one was injured besides one individual hurt from glass from his shattered window and cracks in the walls of some homes.
- Multiple media & other organizations have done satellite imagery analysis that show no damage and no holes in the buildings in the Madrassa compound.

What is there to dissect? If there are no holes and no damage to the structures in the Madrassa compound per independent satellite imagery analysis, there is obviously no damage to the compound, and it's backed up by the other things I mentioned above.

 

[Jinn Baba]

I'm at work, but fully intend to rip this piece of garbage in a few hours when I get a chance. That's if someone else hasn't beat me to it.

 

[Windjammer]

Some basic hard facts that debunk Indian lies.
India crossed the LOC, violated Pakistan air space by a few KMs.... launched weapons and hit some Forrest area.....no loss of lives.
Pakistan replied by going about 10 KMs across the LOC.....launched weapons at six different selected targets.....but deliberately aimed at the empty grounds adjacent to the targets.
Conclusion: Had the Indian attack caused any loss of Pakistani lives, then Pakistan could have easily paid back in the same coin. India now just trying to cover up the humiliation by either waving a piece of a missile or coming out with different and ridiculous versions of it's failed exercise.

 

[SrNair]

There are no points that need 'dissecting'

Multiple international media organizations and journalists reported directly from the site of the attacks.
- They viewed the craters and saw fragments of Indian bombs in the craters. The journalists saw the craters which means the bombs landed in that location and not on the Madrassa (really simplifying it for you)
- They interviewed multiple local residents as to the events that occurred. All the residents offered largely the same narrative of events in terms of what had occurred and the number of explosions they heard and that no one was injured besides one individual hurt from glass from his shattered window and cracks in the walls of some homes.
- Multiple media & other organizations have done satellite imagery analysis that show no damage and no holes in the buildings in the Madrassa compound.

What is there to dissect? If there are no holes and no damage to the structures in the Madrassa compound per independent satellite imagery analysis, there is obviously no damage to the compound, and it's backed up by the other things I mentioned above.

Sirji ,
Just be calm and read it .He addressed all of your queries

 

[scionofPakwattan]

So you are saying that all those calculation is wrong?
That guy is a professional

The journalists that visited the site and the Pakistani officials that actually visited the site post-botched bombing raid are also professionals and they are reporting the damage as they've witnessed, not speculating from thousands of miles away, imagery as we all know can be very misguiding.