What's new

As Coronavirus Spreads, So Does Xenophobia and Anti-Asian Racism

艹艹艹

SENIOR MEMBER
Joined
Jul 7, 2016
Messages
5,198
Reaction score
0
Country
China
Location
China
As Coronavirus Spreads, So Does Xenophobia and Anti-Asian Racism

MARCH 6, 2020

A Singaporean student and a Vietnamese art curator are reported to be the latest targets of xenophobia and racism related to coronavirus in the U.K., as a growing number of incidents have been reported around the world since the outbreak started. On March 6, cases of coronavirus worldwide surpassed 100,000 as the U.S. announced its 14th death.

Jonathan Mok, a 23-year-old from Singapore, detailed on social media how he was allegedly attacked while walking down Oxford Street in central London on Feb. 24. He told the BBC that a group of four men told him “we don’t want your coronavirus in our country” as they punched and kicked him, and also said he may need an operation on a broken bone near his right eye as a consequence of the attack.

Mok posted photos of his sustained facial injuries on Facebook, which attracted attention from tens of thousands of accounts worldwide. “Racism is not stupidity — racism is hate. Racists constantly find excuses to expound their hatred — and in this current backdrop of the coronavirus, they’ve found yet another excuse,” he wrote.

On March 6, London’s Metropolitan Police announced that they had arrested a 16-year-old and a 15-year-old involved in the “racially aggravated assault” on Mok, and were appealing to the public for help identifying the other two men in connection with the incident.

“Whenever there’s some kind of major incident with global or regional implications, and as soon as you can identify it in relation to some racial ‘other,’ particularly in predominantly white, multi-ethnic societies like England or the U.S., I think it’s very easy for people to use a very small excuse to start scapegoating on the basis of their appearance,” Miri Song, professor of sociology at the University of Kent, tells TIME. Different groups of people are targeted or discriminated against based on different stereotypes, she says, pointing to the aftermath of 9/11, in which there was an increase in attacksagainst Middle Eastern, Arab, Muslim, and Sikh people based on their ethnicity and racial identity. Research has also indicated that racism, and race and religion-related hate crime significantly increased in the U.K. after the Brexit referendum in 2016.

Since the outbreak of coronavirus, which was first officially reported to the World Health Organization by Chinese authorities in Wuhan on Dec. 31, several accounts of racism and xenophobia have been reported and documented on social media. While some governments and politicians have denounced such incidents related to the outbreak, others think much more could be done to show support for Chinese communities worldwide. Last week, Michelle Bachelet, the U.N. human rights chief, called on member states to combat discrimination triggered by the virus.

Mok’s case is by no means an isolated incident. On March 6, rights groups condemned what appeared to be a racially motivated crime in New York City, as video footage emerged of a man on a subway train arguing with and spraying air freshener at a fellow passenger, who is Asian-American. Local media reported that the New York Police Department is now investigating the case as a possible hate crime.

On March 5, it was reported that a Vietnamese art curator was dropped by an exhibitor at a U.K. art fair who claimed her participation would be seen as “carrying the virus.” An Nguyen shared a screenshot on social media of an email she had received from Raquelle Azran, a New York-based art dealer specializing in Vietnamese art, which cancelled Nguyen’s assistance at London’s Affordable Art Fair spring event. “The corona virus is causing much anxiety everywhere, and fairly or not, Asians are being seen as carriers of the virus,” wrote Azran. “Your presence on the stand would unfortunately create hesitation on the part of the audience to enter the exhibition space.” After backlash on social media, Azran apologized “for any offence” caused by the email, reports The Independent. “If you are seeing that the issue is solely with the person in question alone, it is not.” Nguyen posted an Instagram story, adding that it was “normalizing non-aggressive discrimination” that needed to change.

As in several countries, Mok and Nguyen’s cases indicate that discrimination is not only targeting mainland Chinese people, but people of east and south east Asian descent more broadly, including those who are not first-generation immigrants. “I don’t think most of the people who tend to harbor these kinds of hatreds or prejudices are interested in the specifics of your ethnic or racial background,” says sociologist Song. “Because of your racial phenotype, you’re automatically deemed to be foreign.”
 
. . .
Anyone calling this the “Chinese virus” or “Wuhan virus” is a racist. You can see the racism by the WASPs.
Not necessarily... Those who used to call it nCov/COVID and now use Wuhan virus/Chinese Virus... yes, you are right.
But, most ppl refer it by "Origin" as a way to point to it... Everything isn't always racist...

I mean... When you call Ebola (African river/region)... African swine flu... MERS (middle eastern respiratory syndrome), Spanish flu (wasn't even originated from spain)...
Does that make you racist?
 
.
Not necessarily... Those who used to call it nCov/COVID and now use Wuhan virus/Chinese Virus... yes, you are right.
But, most ppl refer it by "Origin" as a way to point to it... Everything isn't always racist...

I mean... When you call Ebola (African river/region)... African swine flu... MERS (middle eastern respiratory syndrome), Spanish flu (wasn't even originated from spain)...
Does that make you racist?

Sorry but that absolutely is racism. It’s disgusting and only used by racists. All the names for the diseases you have named are racist. Disease names should never have a country/region/ethnicity attached to it. Names for diseases should be named like COVID-19 and SARS that don’t stigmatise a country/region/ethnicity.

These are all racist terms created to attach a stigma to an entire group of people. Racism against black, brown, Asian people have been normalised throughout WASP countries.

In WASP countries, the racism against Asians, Indians, Muslims, Africans, Spanish-speaking people are rampant. Look at the racism against immigrants in the WASP countries.
 
.
As Coronavirus Spreads, So Does Xenophobia and Anti-Asian Racism

MARCH 6, 2020

A Singaporean student and a Vietnamese art curator are reported to be the latest targets of xenophobia and racism related to coronavirus in the U.K., as a growing number of incidents have been reported around the world since the outbreak started. On March 6, cases of coronavirus worldwide surpassed 100,000 as the U.S. announced its 14th death.

Jonathan Mok, a 23-year-old from Singapore, detailed on social media how he was allegedly attacked while walking down Oxford Street in central London on Feb. 24. He told the BBC that a group of four men told him “we don’t want your coronavirus in our country” as they punched and kicked him, and also said he may need an operation on a broken bone near his right eye as a consequence of the attack.

Mok posted photos of his sustained facial injuries on Facebook, which attracted attention from tens of thousands of accounts worldwide. “Racism is not stupidity — racism is hate. Racists constantly find excuses to expound their hatred — and in this current backdrop of the coronavirus, they’ve found yet another excuse,” he wrote.

On March 6, London’s Metropolitan Police announced that they had arrested a 16-year-old and a 15-year-old involved in the “racially aggravated assault” on Mok, and were appealing to the public for help identifying the other two men in connection with the incident.

“Whenever there’s some kind of major incident with global or regional implications, and as soon as you can identify it in relation to some racial ‘other,’ particularly in predominantly white, multi-ethnic societies like England or the U.S., I think it’s very easy for people to use a very small excuse to start scapegoating on the basis of their appearance,” Miri Song, professor of sociology at the University of Kent, tells TIME. Different groups of people are targeted or discriminated against based on different stereotypes, she says, pointing to the aftermath of 9/11, in which there was an increase in attacksagainst Middle Eastern, Arab, Muslim, and Sikh people based on their ethnicity and racial identity. Research has also indicated that racism, and race and religion-related hate crime significantly increased in the U.K. after the Brexit referendum in 2016.

Since the outbreak of coronavirus, which was first officially reported to the World Health Organization by Chinese authorities in Wuhan on Dec. 31, several accounts of racism and xenophobia have been reported and documented on social media. While some governments and politicians have denounced such incidents related to the outbreak, others think much more could be done to show support for Chinese communities worldwide. Last week, Michelle Bachelet, the U.N. human rights chief, called on member states to combat discrimination triggered by the virus.

Mok’s case is by no means an isolated incident. On March 6, rights groups condemned what appeared to be a racially motivated crime in New York City, as video footage emerged of a man on a subway train arguing with and spraying air freshener at a fellow passenger, who is Asian-American. Local media reported that the New York Police Department is now investigating the case as a possible hate crime.

On March 5, it was reported that a Vietnamese art curator was dropped by an exhibitor at a U.K. art fair who claimed her participation would be seen as “carrying the virus.” An Nguyen shared a screenshot on social media of an email she had received from Raquelle Azran, a New York-based art dealer specializing in Vietnamese art, which cancelled Nguyen’s assistance at London’s Affordable Art Fair spring event. “The corona virus is causing much anxiety everywhere, and fairly or not, Asians are being seen as carriers of the virus,” wrote Azran. “Your presence on the stand would unfortunately create hesitation on the part of the audience to enter the exhibition space.” After backlash on social media, Azran apologized “for any offence” caused by the email, reports The Independent. “If you are seeing that the issue is solely with the person in question alone, it is not.” Nguyen posted an Instagram story, adding that it was “normalizing non-aggressive discrimination” that needed to change.

As in several countries, Mok and Nguyen’s cases indicate that discrimination is not only targeting mainland Chinese people, but people of east and south east Asian descent more broadly, including those who are not first-generation immigrants. “I don’t think most of the people who tend to harbor these kinds of hatreds or prejudices are interested in the specifics of your ethnic or racial background,” says sociologist Song. “Because of your racial phenotype, you’re automatically deemed to be foreign.”


 
.
Not necessarily... Those who used to call it nCov/COVID and now use Wuhan virus/Chinese Virus... yes, you are right.
But, most ppl refer it by "Origin" as a way to point to it... Everything isn't always racist...

I mean... When you call Ebola (African river/region)... African swine flu... MERS (middle eastern respiratory syndrome), Spanish flu (wasn't even originated from spain)...
Does that make you racist?
I'd say there is a lot of borderline racism in the way some of these pathologies, pathogens and clinical features are named by western science.

Only until quite recently, Downs sufferers were routinely referred to as having "mongoloid features".

I do get your point though that geographical origin of a virus or disease for example is usually just a statement of fact and not intended as racism.

Each particular nomenclature needs to be considered on its merits. It is very much possible that disease naming can be used as a crude form of propaganda and so such theories cannot be dismissed as paranoia.

Take the history of syphilis' naming for example:

"Until that time, as Fracastoro notes, syphilis had been called the "French disease" (Italian: mal francese) in Italy, Malta,[27] Poland andGermany, and the "Italian disease" in France. In addition, the Dutchcalled it the "Spanish disease", the Russians called it the "Polish disease", and the Turks called it the "Christian disease" or "Frank (Western European) disease" (frengi). These "national" names were generally reflective of contemporary political spite between nations and frequently served as a sort of propaganda; the Protestant Dutch, for example, fought and eventually won a war of independence against their Spanish Habsburg rulers who were Catholic, so referring to Syphilis as the "Spanish" disease reinforced a politically useful perception that the Spanish were immoral or unworthy."
 
.
I'd say there is a lot of borderline racism in the way some of these pathologies, pathogens and clinical features are named by western science.

Only until quite recently, Downs sufferers were routinely referred to as having "mongoloid features".

I do get your point though that geographical origin of a virus or disease for example is usually just a statement of fact and not intended as racism.

Each particular nomenclature needs to be considered on its merits. It is very much possible that disease naming can be used as a crude form of propaganda and so such theories cannot be dismissed as paranoia.

Take the history of syphilis' naming for example:

"Until that time, as Fracastoro notes, syphilis had been called the "French disease" (Italian: mal francese) in Italy, Malta,[27] Poland andGermany, and the "Italian disease" in France. In addition, the Dutchcalled it the "Spanish disease", the Russians called it the "Polish disease", and the Turks called it the "Christian disease" or "Frank (Western European) disease" (frengi). These "national" names were generally reflective of contemporary political spite between nations and frequently served as a sort of propaganda; the Protestant Dutch, for example, fought and eventually won a war of independence against their Spanish Habsburg rulers who were Catholic, so referring to Syphilis as the "Spanish" disease reinforced a politically useful perception that the Spanish were immoral or unworthy."

It's all good until the Coronavirus came out....now it's "racist"

Believe me, if this virus had come from Africa....no one, including our Chinese friends with their egos, would have a problem scrutinizing Africans, their way of living and more...

This is the world we live in....racism...or should I say "bias" and "bigotry" is inherent to us since the division of the human race since the times of Nuh A.S.
 
.
I'd say there is a lot of borderline racism in the way some of these pathologies, pathogens and clinical features are named by western science.

Only until quite recently, Downs sufferers were routinely referred to as having "mongoloid features".

I do get your point though that geographical origin of a virus or disease for example is usually just a statement of fact and not intended as racism.

Each particular nomenclature needs to be considered on its merits. It is very much possible that disease naming can be used as a crude form of propaganda and so such theories cannot be dismissed as paranoia.

Take the history of syphilis' naming for example:

"Until that time, as Fracastoro notes, syphilis had been called the "French disease" (Italian: mal francese) in Italy, Malta,[27] Poland andGermany, and the "Italian disease" in France. In addition, the Dutchcalled it the "Spanish disease", the Russians called it the "Polish disease", and the Turks called it the "Christian disease" or "Frank (Western European) disease" (frengi). These "national" names were generally reflective of contemporary political spite between nations and frequently served as a sort of propaganda; the Protestant Dutch, for example, fought and eventually won a war of independence against their Spanish Habsburg rulers who were Catholic, so referring to Syphilis as the "Spanish" disease reinforced a politically useful perception that the Spanish were immoral or unworthy."
I agree with such statement, And I also understand that the overall majority of ppl aren't using such "behavior" to stigmatise a certain population.
Like per exemple with Israel... In the West, the critics of Israel is de facto associated to Antisemitism... Even though most of Israel's critics are against the Gov behavior... And it's also true that a minority use such "critics" to target Jews...
But that's the case for everything....

Now, for some ppl... using names like African swine flu, MERS, Ebola, Spanish flu isn't Racist while pointing out that calling it Wuhan virus/Chinese Virus is Racist... is quite frankly Hypocritical...
Therefore, as long as Other "names" aren't considered wrong... then this one shouldn't either... But IF all are considered wrong, then all shall be... It's either all together or none.

I, do wish/hope that each one of them, do not hold any geographical/ethical connotation... But unfortunately many, aren't and will live with it...

In the End, This virus should be called COVID-19/nCov/Coronavirus... and that's it.

PS: the Western naming isn't only a Western thing... Back in the days, Naming had to be "specific"/"related to what we understand", nowadays, it's still present when the targeted pop keep their mouth shut... It's a good thing China made such move... many couldn't do it...
 
.
Back
Top Bottom