What's new

Arkansas passes law allowing rapists to prevent victims who want an abortion

Pindi Boy

FULL MEMBER
Joined
Jun 2, 2015
Messages
1,685
Reaction score
0
Country
Pakistan
Location
Pakistan
A pregnant woman's husband will have the power to stop her from having an abortion, even in cases of spousal rape, under a new law introduced in the US state of Arkansas.

Most second trimester abortions will also be banned by Act 45 - the Unborn Child Protection From Dismemberment Abortion Act - which will make it possible for husbands to sue doctors who carry out abortions for civil damages, or get an injunction to block the termination.

The pro-life law, which was pushed through in just two months by the state's Republican government, prohibits all dilation and evacuation (D&E) procedures, in which the physician removes the foetus from the womb with surgical tools.

Barack Obama moved to protect funding for abortion clinics before passing the presidency to Trump
How Donald Trump's 'global gag rule' puts Indian women's lives at risk



https://www.independent.co.uk/news/...ctims-husbands-second-trimester-a7561066.html

D&E procedures are the safest way for women to end their pregnancies after 14 weeks of gestation, according to the American Medical Association.


But the medical procedure will now become a felony in the southern state, punishable by a $10,000 fine or six years in prison.

This is despite 683 of Arkansas's 3,771 abortions being D&E in 2015, according to the state's health department.

A clause in the legislation also states the husband of a woman seeking an abortion, if he is presumed to be the baby's father, can file a civil lawsuit against the physician for monetary damages or "injunctive relief" ― a court order that would prevent the doctor from going ahead with the procedure.

The woman’s parents or legal guardians can also sue to stop the abortion, if she is a minor.

Although a husband cannot win money in cases of “criminal conduct” against his wife ― namely, spousal rape ― he could still sue to block her from having the abortion.

State Representative Andy Mayberry, who co-sponsored the bill, called D&E a “gruesome, barbaric procedure”, adding that the routine procedure “is one that no civilised society should embrace”.

Mr Mayberry is also the president of Arkansas Right to Life, a subsidiary of America's largest pro-life organisation, the National Right to Life Committee.

Karen Musick, co-founder of Arkansas Abortion Support Network, told The Daily Beast she could not fathom how the bill had become law.

Supreme Court strikes down abortion restrictions
“There is zero part of me that understands why a rapist or someone who got someone pregnant against their will, maybe incest, would have any right in that decision,” she said. “I cannot wrap my brain around the fact that there would be anyone who thinks otherwise.”

Holly Dickson, legal director for the American Civil Liberties Union of Arkansas, told the Huffington Post the bill might not be constitutional.

“They created a whole new right ― the right of a husband or family member to sue a doctor on behalf of an adult patient,” she said. “I cannot begin to tell you what the intent was, but we have raised concerns about that provision and the entire rest of the bill, which is unconstitutional.”

The ACLU of Arkansas has said it plans to challenge the abortion law in court before it goes into effect later this year.

Six other states have passed nearly identical laws, and in all four states where the law was challenged ― Louisiana, Alabama, Mississippi and West Virginia ― it was struck down by the courts.

The Supreme Court’s 1973 decision in Roe versus Wade protects a woman’s right to have an abortion up until the foetus would be viable outside the womb, around 22 weeks of pregnancy.
 
.
Average American is pro life. Good to see laws mirroring the will of the people.

But america should really look into why rape is an uncontroable epidemic in its society
 
.
Now that's some real Good old Americanism for you.
USA!! USA!!

Now keep this in mind that they teach the whole world about human rights.
 
.
Just check the low level of reporting and strong bias of the media... They have turned the husband into a rapist. These feminazis are really scumbags.
 
Last edited:
.
Just check the low level of reporting and strong bias of the media... They have turned the husband into a rapists. These feminazis are really scumbags.

I'm sure it wouldn't go over well in most countries if the wife announces to the husband "I aborted your son because I wanted a girl instead" with the husband having no legal say.
 
.
I'm sure it wouldn't go over well in most countries if the wife announces to the husband "I aborted your son because I wanted a girl instead" with the husband having no legal say.
Are you talking about India? because that's only country with a demographic imbalance in favour of male gender. No other country that I know has more males than females.
But in this case (Arkansas), the husband is in full control right?
 
.
Are you talking about India? because that's only country with a demographic imbalance in favour of male gender.

I'm just giving an example scenario in any country. I haven't read the details of the law but it seems strange if the husband had no legal say in whether his wife can have an abortion.

No other country that I know has more males than females.

Seems to be a problem in China and India. I bet some in Africa too.

https://www.scmp.com/magazines/post...-many-men-china-and-india-battle-consequences

Too many men: China and India battle with the consequences of gender imbalance

In the world’s most populous nations, men outnumber women by 70 million. Both countries are trying to come to grips with the policies that created this generation of gender imbalance
 
Last edited:
.
well , if the law only ban D&C , then don't worry I can gave consultation to Arkansas Medics how to bypass the law .
 
.
I'm just giving an example scenario in any country. I haven't read the details of the law but it seems strange if the husband had no legal say in whether his wife can have an abortion.



Seems to be a problem in China and India. I bet some in Africa too.

https://www.scmp.com/magazines/post...-many-men-china-and-india-battle-consequences

Too many men: China and India battle with the consequences of gender imbalance

In the world’s most populous nations, men outnumber women by 70 million. Both countries are trying to come to grips with the policies that created this generation of gender imbalance
China's problem is due to one child policy so I think it will be fixed as now the govt has allowed two children per family. China needs a lot of young people to replace its ageing population but India's issue is deep rooted. It begets from the culture + religious reason as man is considered superior to woman for plethora of reasons so parents abort female foetuses. So until this mindset changes, it will stay like that and with rising hindutva...I don't see it changing any time soon.
 
. .
As compare to India. Where just an ordinary vanilla rape are no big deals. Only gang rape and the murder of the woman catch their attention.
You seem to bring India and Indians in all sorts of discussions. What happened? Was it one person or was it a gang? And was it with you or your family member?
 
.
That is a law which should find its way into Pakistani society as well. My friends ex-wife had an abortion without his knowledge and later took divorce citing miscarriage as a consequence to the lack of care from his side. Creating balance for all the aggrieved is a stringent rule, that need not to be superceeded to the duress by political movements such as feminisim.
 
.
Are you talking about India? because that's only country with a demographic imbalance in favour of male gender. No other country that I know has more males than females.
Nope, China is another one too.
 
.
Seems to be a problem in China and India. I bet some in Africa too.

https://www.scmp.com/magazines/post...-many-men-china-and-india-battle-consequences

Too many men: China and India battle with the consequences of gender imbalance

In the world’s most populous nations, men outnumber women by 70 million. Both countries are trying to come to grips with the policies that created this generation of gender imbalance

China's problem is due to one child policy so I think it will be fixed as now the govt has allowed two children per family. China needs a lot of young people to replace its ageing population but India's issue is deep rooted. It begets from the culture + religious reason as man is considered superior to woman for plethora of reasons so parents abort female foetuses. So until this mindset changes, it will stay like that and with rising hindutva...I don't see it changing any time soon.
Reports are saying 30million more men than women in China but this is not the case in reality. The gap is not that big, likely in the range of 5 million (men also have higher mortality rate). In reality those girls were just not officially registered at birth. It is a well known phenomenon in China where people that had extra children just hid them, especially the girls because they wanted the boys educated through official channels. These people live in the country side so the girls can just be married off and educated in privately run rural schools. I've talked to people with 5 children in China, for city people this might seem abnormal but for many rural folk this is normal.

https://news.ku.edu/2016/11/22/study-finds-chinas-missing-girls-theory-likely-far-overblown

https://qz.com/941240/china-keeps-finding-millions-of-people-who-never-officially-existed/

The issue with some rural men getting married is that there are less women in rural areas due to the fact that proportionally more young women move to the cities for work, thus these rural men will usually have to pay a very large sum to get a wife in the countryside.
 
Last edited:
.
You seem to bring India and Indians in all sorts of discussions. What happened? Was it one person or was it a gang? And was it with you or your family member?

We are talking about rape in India and you turned it into personal attacks. Reported.
 
.

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom