What's new

After Mexico, India second largest source of migrants: report

Persecuted ethnic and religious minorities, who are victims of discrimination by the state and subjected to recurring communal and racial atrocities have been coming over to India in droves since the Partition of 1947. For a brief period of three-and-a-half years after liberation, Bangladesh was committed to secular governance when the Hindus and other minorities experienced some let up in the persecution by the majority Muslim community. Ever since 1975, the country has gone through a steady process of Islamisation, ranging from deletion of secularism from the constitution to legitimisation of banned communal and fundamentalist Islamist parties to declaration of Islam as the state religion of Bangladesh. The consequent heightening of insecurity among the
minorities intensified migration of the Hindus to the bordering states of India.

The second type of migrants consist of pauperised landless Muslims from rural Bangladesh in search of employment. The in-flow of economic migrants began during the 1974 famine in Bangladesh and has continued unabated ever since.

There has been no census of immigrants yet, but academics, government agencies, research organisations and demographers estimate 15-20 million migrants have found their way to different Indian states in the last three decades, the ratio of Hindu-Muslim immigrants being approximately 1:3.


While the migration pressure is understandably on the border states (Assam, West Bengal, Meghalaya and Tripura), significant numbers have traveled further afield and have been living in concentration in metropolitan cities like Delhi, Mumbai, Ahmedabad, Jaipur and a host of other urban conglomerates.

http://web.mit.edu/cis/www/migration/pubs/rrwp/chandan_nandy_immigrants.pdf
 
.
Dude you need to calm down first:cheesy:



http://arts.monash.edu.au/mai/asaa/rizwanashamshad.pdf

---------- Post added at 09:10 PM ---------- Previous post was at 09:09 PM ----------



Who was Felani?

Not unlikely. If even a fraction of 5.4 million are illegal and counting their descendent it can be 10 million. But still 10 million number is too high.

But the descendent those who born and brought up in India and living their for couple of decades can they be termed as illegal migrants?

N even after agreeing their is no way to trust any Indian leader or minister's word in face value as they are number one drama buz.

The way just few days earlier government officials has debunked the Arunachal pradesh's ministers claim that china is blocking water there is every reason to doubt their claim.

Basis of which survey or report he made the claim??? Or just a random claim!!!
 
.
Well its no secret that there is a massive slum of Dalit Hindus in Karachi who have come over illegaly to escape persecution in India.
 
.
BSF HAS NEVER KILLED ANY ILLEGAL MIGRANTS. THEY NEVER DO IT OR DID IT. PERIOD.

So BSF kills innocent cattle traders instead of illegal immigrants, great as they carry an billboard in their chest who states that my x. is 'innocent' cattle trader while my y.is an illegal immigrant. and BSF chose mr x. while pulling the trigger :tup: never knew it.
 
.
Not unlikely. If even a fraction of 5.4 million are illegal and counting their descendent it can be 10 million. But still 10 million number is too high.

But the descendent those who born and brought up in India and living their for couple of decades can they be termed as illegal migrants?

N even after agreeing their is no way to trust any Indian leader or minister's word in face value as they are number one drama buz.

The way just few days earlier government officials has debunked the Arunachal pradesh's ministers claim that china is blocking water there is every reason to doubt their claim.

Basis of which survey or report he made the claim??? Or just a random claim!!!

You just asked for an official claim, I gave you one and now you say Indian Government can't be trusted:woot:

Very hard to convince someone if the person has made up his mind already.
 
.
Dude you need to calm down first:cheesy:



http://arts.monash.edu.au/mai/asaa/rizwanashamshad.pdf

---------- Post added at 09:10 PM ---------- Previous post was at 09:09 PM ----------



Who was Felani?

Felani was born and brought up in India. So an Indian. But his father went to India along with his brother when they were 6 or 12 after their parents died when a farmer of neighboring village in India gave them work in the paddy field and they move to Delhi in 1991.

Anyway felani was not coming from Bangladesh. But her death is a big violation of human right.

According to the data 1.7 million muslim migrated to India. Some of them may be illegal. But no way it makes up 20 million figure.
 
. .
You just asked for an official claim, I gave you one and now you say Indian Government can't be trusted:woot:

Very hard to convince someone if the person has made up his mind already.

I am asking for any census or government data not random claim by minister. As most of the BJP leader claim 20 million are illegal migrants. But that can not be a legitimate claim to be trusted other then any official document.

What was the source of that minister's claim??
 
.
Felani was born and brought up in India. So an Indian. But his father went to India along with his father when they were 6 or 12 when a farmer of neighboring village in India gave them work in the paddy field and they move to Delhi in 1991.

Anyway felani was not coming from Bangladesh. But her death is a big violation of human right.

According to the data 1.7 million muslim migrated to India. Some of them may be illegal. But no way it makes up 20 million figure.

I don't undertsand you just said you can't tryst the words and figures of Indian Ministers and Government. Why are taking this figure from PEW Research as the ultimate truth, when infact PEW Research got their data from 2001 Indian Government Census:woot:

wYdiS.png


Make up your mind will ya!:rolleyes:
 
.
I am asking for any census or government data not random claim by minister. As most of the BJP leader claim 20 million are illegal migrants. But that can not be a legitimate claim to be trusted other then any official document.

What was the source of that minister's claim??

Dude it was a good joke to expect illegal immigrant to register themselves in front of census survey :rofl:

Tell it it was a joke or you expect illegal immigrant to register in front of census survey and register themselves as illegal immigrants :lol: :lol:
 
.

Chandan Nandy is an Indian. N what are the agency specially government agency that mentioned 15-20 million illegal migrant went to India. I am asking not any random claim but any government report or census. Do not post any random claim. No interest on that.

This Chandan nandy even suppressed that minister by almost 100% !! What a joke. But still that include all illegal migrants not from bangladesh alone.
 
.
I am asking for any census or government data not random claim by minister. As most of the BJP leader claim 20 million are illegal migrants. But that can not be a legitimate claim to be trusted other then any official document.

What was the source of that minister's claim??

He was the Home Minister, he must have access to official estimates. No country includes illegal migrants in Census. Not even the US. Even their claims of illegal Mexicans are estimates!

The Pitfalls of Counting Illegal Immigrants - The Numbers Guy - WSJ

But as my print column notes this week, these estimates are limited by several factors that make it difficult for researchers to count this population. No major government survey, including the decennial census now under way, asks Americans about their citizenship status. Thus estimates of the number of illegal immigrants in the country are indirect and possibly far off from the correct count.
 
.
Dude it was a good joke to expect illegal immigrant to register themselves in front of census survey :rofl:

Tell it it was a joke or you expect illegal immigrant to register in front of census survey and register themselves as illegal immigrants :lol: :lol:

If they dont register then how come you are getting the figure of 20 million? Do not make other people to laugh at you.
 
.
He was the Home Minister, he must have access to official estimates. No country includes illegal migrants in Census. Not even the US. Even their claims of illegal Mexicans are estimates!

The Pitfalls of Counting Illegal Immigrants - The Numbers Guy - WSJ

Then when BJP will come to power and any minister just make a claim their are 30 million illegal migrants are there then you are asking me to believe that.

I just asked what are the source or government documents. If your government really has any documents why they are not publishing it.

By the way that 10 million including all not just Bangladeshi migrant alone. So still it makes 20 million illegal migrant story invalid.

N that 10 million number also includes the descendent of he migrants. N why you are just bypassing the question how come those who born and brought up in India and living there for decades is illegal migrants still??
 
.
If they dont register then how come you are getting the figure of 20 million? Do not make other people to laugh at you.
'lol
Do you have any idea how statistics are prepared ? And still you except a census????... :lol:

And what do you think how come this author made this article,did he visit ever illegal immigrant camps in India?
 
.

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom