Afghan Refugees - Should Pakistan expell them to India?

[karan.1970]

So we have a disagreement on Cats?-

Nope

 

[JonAsad]

Nope

Do you have something relavent to say?-

 

[RAMPAGE]

@Horus

We must expel them and bring back our stranded Bihari Pakistanis from Bangladesh.

 

[livingdead]

how do you expel people into India?
senior cafe is supposed to be for serious discussion, this seems to be worse than member's club.

 

[karan.1970]

Do you have something relavent to say?-

 

[farhan_9909]

We should give those citizenship living in Pakistan since 80's.

Pakistanis can talk all they want but in the end they will have to provide citizenship to all those afghan refugees and we will make sure that they form a strong political party

Majority of them already have(atleast those in my hometown as now consider themselves as Pakistanis) and most of them have voted for Diesel

 

[halupridol]

We should give those citizenship living in Pakistan since 80's.



Majority of them already have(atleast those in my hometown as now consider themselves as Pakistanis) and most of them have voted for Diesel

ofcourse giving them citizenship is the only solution.
identifying afghans from ur own pashtuns wud be way too messy n then to deport them with a porous border...

Pakistan is in a real tricky situation

 

[farhan_9909]

ofcourse giving them citizenship is the only solution.
identifying afghans from ur own pashtuns wud be way too messy n then to deport them with a porous border...

Pakistan is in a real tricky situation

Those with Pakistani citizenship will not be deported.It was easy to get citizenship till 2005-06( In Bannu,dera ismail khan,Lakki marwat etc) and even now in Balochistan but ever since than it is difficult even in the mentioned cities.Those living in peshawar are wealthy and having citizenship arleady.those living in Bannu now identify themselves as banusi/wazir/local.

In Balochistan,in the past decade so much Afghan refugees are registered as Pakistani that today pashtuns have become majority in Balochistan despite pashtun being only 30% of Balochistan population in 1998

I believe we still have 1.5Million registered Refugee.Anyone once registered as refugee cannot become citizen

 

[Armstrong]

We should give those citizenship living in Pakistan since 80's.

Majority of them already have(atleast those in my hometown as now consider themselves as Pakistanis) and most of them have voted for Diesel

Suchhh ? Pakistan keh khilaaaf tou nahin bolteiii ? Are they loyal to Pakistan ?

 

[farhan_9909]

Suchhh ? Pakistan keh khilaaaf tou nahin bolteiii ? Are they loyal to Pakistan ?

one of them has even forced his family members to not watch geo after the hamid mir issue (itne Pakistani hain wo Hafeez saeed or zaid hamid type blind lover hai saare )

 

[Armstrong]

one of them has even forced his family members to not watch geo after the hamid mir issue (itne Pakistani hain wo Hafeez saeed or zaid hamid type blind lover hai saare )

Then they are one of us - No question asked !

Unfortunately wrrora I've never met a Pro-Pakistan Afghan....Ever....most start frothing from the mouth whenever Pakistan is talked about !

 

[farhan_9909]

Then they are one of us - No question asked !

Unfortunately wrrora I've never met a Pro-Pakistan Afghan....Ever....most start frothing from the mouth whenever Pakistan is talked about !

Believe me,i have yet to meet a anti Pakistan Afghan and we have more like 10%-20% of city population as afghan

 

[halupridol]

Those with Pakistani citizenship will not be deported.It was easy to get citizenship till 2005-06( In Bannu,dera ismail khan,Lakki marwat etc) and even now in Balochistan but ever since than it is difficult even in the mentioned cities.Those living in peshawar are wealthy and having citizenship arleady.those living in Bannu now identify themselves as banusi/wazir/local.

In Balochistan,in the past decade so much Afghan refugees are registered as Pakistani that today pashtuns have become majority in Balochistan despite pashtun being only 30% of Balochistan population in 1998

I believe we still have 1.5Million registered Refugee.Anyone once registered as refugee cannot become citizen

bottomline being ,,,deporting refugees(registered n unreg.) is very difficult,may even have serious backlash,,,,n whats the point when there is no proper border to stop thm from coming back..
with US draw down,,,,chances are,more refugees will pour into Pakistan....
i predict a significant change in demographics n politics of Pakistan

 

[Armstrong]

Believe me,i have yet to meet a anti Pakistan Afghan and we have more like 10%-20% of city population as afghan

So are you saying that I keep meeting Northern Alliance types !

 

[farhan_9909]

So are you saying that I keep meeting Northern Alliance types !

Indeed,they are mostly from peshawar and abbottabad and pretend to be pashtun despite they being Tajik/farsiband etc.

bottomline being ,,,deporting refugees(registered n unreg.) is very difficult,may even have serious backlash,,,,n whats the point when there is no proper border to stop thm from coming back..
with US draw down,,,,chances are,more refugees will pour into Pakistan....
i predict a significant change in demographics n politics of Pakistan

Deporting Unregistered won't be a problem.

The border is no more as porous as you think today or when it was in the 90's.my cousin had medicine business in khost and as per him,it used to take not more than 2-3hours to reach khost from mir ali.Today it takes him more than 12hours as the border along ghulam khan is sealed