What's new

Afghan Govt claims Pak Army Captain, suicide bombers arrested in Afghanistan

Sorry, anonymous sources cannot be considered credible.

Even if there are RAW personnel in Afghanistan, it is a matter between India and Afghanistan, because Afghanistan is a sovereign independent country. Furthermore, even if Indians are talking with Sindhis or Punjabis or Balochis or Pakhtuns, there is nothing wrong with it. If Pakistanis allege there was any contravention of international law, they should provide evidence.

Dude, the evidence has been provided to Afghan and US governments. They continue to let indians export terrorism because of their interests and thus we have to use other ways to contain or stop indian terrorism.

The amount of indian intelligence present in Afghanistan should itself be a red flag anyhow.
 
CBS is reporting it, and what would providing evidence do anyway. They can deal with the situation and are safeguarding Pakistan. That is their primary duty.

Since you regard that article as credible, pay attention to what the Afghan people themselves have to say about what India is doing there:

Pakistan wants "a puppet state in Kabul, a subservient state," said Muradian, the foreign ministry adviser. "India wants a stable, pluralistic Afghanistan."

.....


Take the three Indian doctors working in the dusty northern town of Mazar-i-Sharif, dispensing prescriptions and performing surgeries in a faded colonial-era hospital that somehow survived the years of fighting.

Every morning, clusters of women in blue burqas gather in the narrow hallway outside the clinic, while men wait in the parking lot. They are the poorest people in one of the world's poorest countries: widows, the unemployed, the elderly. They measure the distance to the clinic by the cost of getting there — and a 10-cent bus ride is a painful investment.

About 150 arrive every day for free care and medicine.

An old man named Myagul — he has only one name, and didn't know his age — had been coughing badly, he said, and growing dizzy when he stood up. The doctors prescribed blood pressure medicine and cough syrup. He'd already been to a handful of doctors, but they had all asked for fees he couldn't afford.

But on a warm Afghan morning, the old man with the greasy beard and the torn blazer left the clinic clutching a handful of medicines, weary but pleased.

"Finally it was these Indians who helped."
 
Intelligence agencies work in a state's interests. None of them are innocent, least of them RAW or CIA. It's high time for some to stop claiming to have a moral high ground as if their own intelligence agencies don't kill people via terrorists.

So the thread is about suicide bombers and a Pakistani captain. Do you think this is acceptable as this is what intelligence agencies do ? hand in glow with terrorists to get even with one another ?

I am still not able to believe what is written by a senior member !
:cheers:
 
Since you regard that article as credible, pay attention to what the Afghan people themselves have to say about what India is doing there:

That's a misrepresentation, na? Pakistan wants a subservient and stable Afghanistan but so does India.
 
So the thread is about suicide bombers and a Pakistani captain. Do you think this is acceptable as this is what intelligence agencies do ? hand in glow with terrorists to get even with one another ?

I am still not able to believe what is written by a senior member !
:cheers:

It's acceptable? Maybe not to a typical citizen, but that's how it works in the real world.

:cheers:
 
Indians are just contribute to improve afganistan if afgan government have no problem with india so why your government make issue for that .... just because pakistan nahi chahta ki afganistan selfdependent ho gaye... tabhi to pakistan afgan - iran road nahi banne dena chahta
 
Indians are just contribute to improve afganistan if afgan government have no problem with india so why your government make issue for that .... just because pakistan nahi chahta ki afganistan selfdependent ho gaye... tabhi to pakistan afgan - iran road nahi banne dena chahta

You seriously think that's india's primary aim there? Do you think it has billions to waste just to help the Afghans (that too for a poor country) or there are bigger interests at stake there?
 
Since you regard that article as credible, pay attention to what the Afghan people themselves have to say about what India is doing there:

Thats the whole point, this article is not biased and presents the true picture. India can help the Afghanis but it SHOULD NOT use it to destabilize Pakistan.

This will guarantee response from Pakistan, our countries can work together to help them. Pakistan has been helping Afghanistan for a long time, billion of Dollars in remittances, trade and what not. Even the article mentions that India, a poor country is spending 1.2 billion on afghans when it can use it itself. Also Pakistan aid is also talked about, which the western media rarely highlights.
 
It's acceptable? Maybe not to a typical citizen, but that's how it works in the real world.

:cheers:

And what makes you think that the policy of aiding and abetting will not backfire?

It is without a doubt the work of creating Frankensteins as a suicide bomber is on nobody's side. Not even on his own side. No wonder, the terror engulfing Pakistan does not seem to subside. No one can distinguish terrorists as good and bad useful / problematic. This is the mistake ISI is making in my humble opinion. Lets not bring RAW, ... etc. Nobody is affected by terror more than Pakistan. If ISI continues to "Use" terror networks, Pakistan will be in real danger of imploding due to a cancer that can't be cured.

My 2 cents. Afterall, no one other than the citizens of Pakistan can influence the work ethics of ISI.
:cheers:
 
That's a misrepresentation, na? Pakistan wants a subservient and stable Afghanistan but so does India.

No, India does not want or need a subservient Afghanistan, and that is what scares Pakistan even more. India wants an independent, democratic and prosperous Afghanistan.

That is exactly what the Afghans themselves want.

The fight is not really between India and Pakistan.

In this conflict, there is freedom and independence on one side, against fanaticism and colonial aggression on the other side.

India and Afghanistan are together on one side, and unfortunately Pakistan chooses to be on the opposing side.
 
You seriously think that's india's primary aim there? Do you think it has billions to waste just to help the Afghans (that too for a poor country) or there are bigger interests at stake there?



so no one do that free of cost they want to do it because...
1: afganistan is one of the biggest home of terrorist (in past " taliban")
so then can harm india.
2: afganisan will become gud market for indian products . but

pakistan dont want to see that
they dont want afganistan to impove
 
You seriously think that's india's primary aim there? Do you think it has billions to waste just to help the Afghans (that too for a poor country) or there are bigger interests at stake there?

Of course not. India wants to exercise its influence on the Afghan govt. and the people through humanitarian means. Its just that you guys dont want to see that happening and are hell bent on using your terrorists to remove Indian presence.

If you would have used all this energy and resources to rebuild and help Afghanistan instead of controlling it through Taliban, you wouldn't have seen any Indians there. You guys gave us the opportunity to enter Afghanistan.
 
That's a misrepresentation, na? Pakistan wants a subservient and stable Afghanistan but so does India.

No, India does not want or need a subservient Afghanistan, and that is what scares Pakistan even more. India wants an independent, democratic and prosperous Afghanistan.

That is exactly what the Afghans themselves want.

The fight is not really between India and Pakistan.

In this conflict, there is freedom and independence on one side, against fanaticism and colonial aggression on the other side.

India and Afghanistan are on one side, and unfortunately Pakistan chooses to be on the opposing side.
 
And what makes you think that the policy of aiding and abetting will not backfire?

It is without a doubt the work of creating Frankensteins as a suicide bomber is on nobody's side. Not even on his own side. No wonder, the terror engulfing Pakistan does not seem to subside. No one can distinguish terrorists as good and bad useful / problematic. This is the mistake ISI is making in my humble opinion. Lets not bring RAW, ... etc. Nobody is affected by terror more than Pakistan. If ISI continues to "Use" terror networks, Pakistan will be in real danger of imploding due to a cancer that can't be cured.

My 2 cents. Afterall, no one other than the citizens of Pakistan can influence the work ethics of ISI.
:cheers:

Well you seem to be picking on ISI solely. ISI is like any other intelligence. You can point out the problem with supporting terrorists but all intelligence agencies do it, not just ISI.
 

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom