What's new

A caste-ridden society is worse than a society of slavery-Arundhati Roy

INDIAPOSITIVE

ELITE MEMBER
Joined
Sep 20, 2014
Messages
9,318
Reaction score
-28
Country
India
Location
India
New DElhi. A caste-ridden society is worse than a society of slavery, and even apartheid, said Arundhati Roy, during a function held at the Constitution Club, New Delhi, on April 29 to mark the6th anniversary of India’s first fully Hindi-English, bilingual magazine, FORWARD Press.

The theme of function, graced by eminent personalities like Anupriya Patel, Ramdas Athawale, Ali Anwar, Ramnika Gupta, Braj Ranjan Mani, Sheoraj Singh Bechain, Jaiprakash Kardam and Arvind Jain, was the “The Future of Bahujan Politics and Literature”. “We are on to an important idea,” said Roy, after releasing FORWARD Press’ fourth Bahujan Literature Annual. She was referring to the idea of Bahujan literature, the idea of fighting casteism with anger at the injustice “while holding in our hearts theidea of justice, love, beauty, music, literature”, without being reduced to a “bitter, small people”.

Ali Anwar, who heads the All India Pasmanda Muslim Mahaz, said Pasmandas are Bahujan first and then Muslims. “We don’t want to be called minorities. We are Bahujans”, he said. He was surprised by Ramdas Athawale’s proposal of reservations for the economically backward among the upper castes. He said we are not “mentally prepared” for such a move. The only criteria, he added, should be social and educational backwardness.

Braj Ranjan Mani, the author of Debrahmanising History, mooted the idea of a “social democracy” and the stressed the need for an “emancipatory unity” among Bahujans. Sujata Parmita said the Dalit-Bahujans have been the creators of culture throughout history but religion has been used to enslave them and seize their culture from them. Anupriya Patel shared the view that once the oppressed masses are educated, their leaders will stop making compromises.

Sheoraj Singh Bechain recalled a conversation with Kanshiram shortly before his BSP formed its first government in Uttar Pradesh in alliance with the BJP. Instead of eyeing power, he should have started a magazine, Bechain had advised Kanshiram – for it is “social power, cultural power, intellectual power” that brings real empowerment to the Bahujans.

On the occasion, the second Mahatma Jotiba and Krantijyoit Savitribai Phule Balijan Ratna awards were presented to Braj Ranjan Mani, A.R. Akela (poet, folk singer, author and publisher) and Dr Hiralal Alawa (senior resident doctor at AIIMS and founder of Jai Adivasi Yuva Shakti)

A caste-ridden society is worse than a society of slavery-Arundhati Roy
 
.
It seems Arundhati madam is not aware of how the slaves were treated.
 
. . .
i think arundhati roy should experience being a slave for a year and then comment
stupid women, many of our generation had left the caste barrier and stopped naming ourselves with our caste suffixes
 
. .
She is a naxal sympathizer. Never ever she condemned brutal killings by Naxalites.
 
.
She is just another attention seeker. She has nothing credible under her belt except making utopian comments .....

Arundhati Roy is as sane as Subramanian Swamy.
Naah .... She can't match the credibility of swami... At least in unearthing the corruption cases.....
 
.
Ramachandra Guha had this to say about Ms. Roy

To suppress my reservations was not easy, for I had been intensely irritated by Ms. Roy's previous venture into public interest journalism: her polemic against the nuclear tests on 1998. There too, I was on her side, "objectively" speaking. Yet her vanity was unreal. Ms. Roy quoted, without irony, the judgment of her friend that after having written one successful novel she had seen it all, that a barren stretch of life lay before her until the final meeting with her Maker. She spoke of how she had disregarded the advice of those who insisted that the tax man would come chasing her were she to write against the bomb. A month before Ms. Roy sat down to write her piece, 4,00,000 adults had marched through the streets of Calcutta in protest against the Pokharan blasts. Were their homes all raided by the Income Tax Department?

The anti-dam essay had its signs of self-absorption too. Its opening scene, of Ms. Roy laughing on the top of a hill, seemed a straight lift from the first lines of that monument to egotism, Ayn Rand's The Fountainhead. The essay was marked throughout by a conspicuous lack of proportion. To compare dams to nuclear weapons was absurd. To demonise technology was irresponsible. ...
 
. . .
Caste system is worst than slavery!! Looks like this idiot has lost her mind.

In Caste system, while your social status is low, and their are marriage and dining restrictions; a low cast person is essentially a free man. He could own property of his own, is free to accumulate wealth and become rich, is secure in knowledge that his nine year old daughter would not be raped by his owner, and has free agency ,while in slavery, a slave, his children, his possessions are property of his master. Only a diabolical and shameless propagandist would consider caste system as worst than slavery.

This is not an apology of caste system ,but the truth is that caste system before last two century, was most benign of any hierarchical system in existence.

Muslims and Christians (including Arundhati, though I think she has forsaken her Church) should shut up about evil of Caste system . Their theology justifies taking slaves straight up. They have no authority to lecture anyone.
 
Last edited:
.
Naah .... She can't match the credibility of swami... At least in unearthing the corruption cases.....
you are comparing arundati roy with subramanian swamy ??:o::o:
Well you do know how our neighbors perceive Subramanian Swamy. :-)

Caste is an issue....a big at one that. Nobody is denying it.
 
. .
but denied by people like "annonying mouse" just above your post. :)
I dont see denial, he has compared caste system and slavery.
anonymus said:
a low cast person is essentially a free man. He could own property of his own, is free to accumulate wealth and become rich, is secure in knowledge that his nine year old daughter would not be raped by his owner, and has free agency
This is true.
Narendra Modi himself is not from one of the privileged castes, but he's the PM of our country today, which proves the above point right.
 
Last edited:
.

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom