90 Afghan nationals nabbed by Police

[RescueRanger]

We should filter Afghans and keep the educated ones with degrees that can positively contribute to the country. For example Hazara refugees who have medical degrees they should be kept as they can contribute to the country.
We should follow the policy of the west. Deport the ones that are burdens on us. Keep the ones which can help us.
Ofc even if educated we need data mining ways to determine their whole history and see if they are hostile to us or not. If they have no history of being hostile and are educated then keep them.
Also we should have some laws to keep wealthy afghan businessman who aren’t hostile to us. For example make them invest $100 000 USD in our stock market (not properly) or invest in any productive sector like setting up factories and we can keep them and give them PR.
We should have policies to attract wealth and attract educated people.
Right now is best time for such policies because we can attract rich afghans to invest in productive sectors and educated ones to help our economy while sending the burdens back.

No thanks, they have their own country called Afghanistan. They should go and develop their own country.

Pakistan has enough mouths to feed already. We have supported Afghan nationals as UNHCR host and processing country since 1980’s.

Afghans only see Pakistan as a “stop over” until they can get a laal or neela passport and then they just go on to spout venom about Pakistan.

There is no middle ground. We don’t want Afghans here. It is fundementally a security risk.

They can visit as friendly tourists through the proper channels, they can attend universities as foreign students, no problem.

But no, we don’t want third national citizens in Pakistan claiming Pakistani citizenship.

They hate Pakistan. We don’t need Afghans in Pakistan.

They will hate us even we give them whole pakistan

This!!!

 

[Sayfullah]

Bahi.

Haan ya baan. There is no middle ground.

Bhai, think about it. If you keep an educated Hazara Afghan Refugee he can contribute to economy and help the country. He will never ally with TTP cuz ideology differences.
We can keep even uneducated Hazara Afghans and create a force out of them to fight Taliban during skirmishes. They hate Taliban. Taliban use TTP, we use Hazaras. Seems fair to me.

 

[Imran Khan]

Afghan bowler rashid khan is good example

 

[Sayfullah]

No thanks, they have their own country called Afghanistan. They should go and develop their own country.

Pakistan has enough mouths to feed already. We have supported Afghan nationals as UNHCR host and processing country since 1980’s.

Afghans only see Pakistan as a “stop over” until they can get a laal or neela passport and then they just go on to spout venom about Pakistan.

There is no middle ground. We don’t want Afghans here. It is fundementally a security risk.

They can visit as friendly tourists through the proper channels, they can attend universities as foreign students, no problem.

But no, we don’t want third national citizens in Pakistan claiming Pakistani citizenship.

They hate Pakistan. We don’t need Afghans in Pakistan.


This!!!

You might be correct. I’m just stating my opinion as an overseas Pakistani but in my experience I have seen some Afghans who have contributed to Pakistan. But locals would know more.

 

[RescueRanger]

Afghan bowler rashid khan is good example

Exactly. No yar. I have worked with Afghans and unlike most on PDF I have worked IN Afghanistan. They HATE us.

So if they hate us so much that they would gladly pray for us to wiped out in an Earthquake, then we don’t want them in our country.

 

[Imran Khan]

Exactly. No yar. I have worked with Afghans and unlike most on PDF I have worked IN Afghanistan. They HATE us.

So if they hate us so much that they would gladly pray for us to wiped out in an Earthquake, then we don’t want them in our country.

We need a special force like saudi have jawwazat to control illegal migrants 90 is a joke we need to deport some 100000 per month .just check the statics of jawwazat they deport million in year . We have bhan matti ka kunba afghani irani indian bengali burmees everyone is liveing here free

 

[RescueRanger]

You might be correct. I’m just stating my opinion as an overseas Pakistani but in my experience I have seen some Afghans who have contributed to Pakistan. But locals would know more.

Name one Afghan who has contributed to Pakistan.

We need a special force like saudi have jawwazat to control illegal migrants 90 is a joke we need to deport some 100000 per month .just check the statics of jawwazat they deport million in year . We have bhan matti ka kunba afghani irani indian bengali burmees everyone is liveing here free

agreed.

 

[Goritoes]

90,000 nikalo tu baat hai, if it wasn't for a certain Ethnic group Pakistani's overall are fed up with Afghans, but I know that Pakistani's love to live in delusion, they will blame everyone for their own doings except themselves.

 

[RealNapster]

90,000 nikalo tu baat hai, if it wasn't for a certain Ethnic group Pakistani's overall are fed up with Afghans, but I know that Pakistani's love to live in delusion, they will blame everyone for their own doings except themselves.

That certain ethnic group is screaming to Pak federal government to deport every last of the Afghan because it's due to these Afghans that this "certain ethnic group" is checked on checklists, have to go through extra security checks, are blamed to be Afghanis while in reality they are not.

Every individual of this ethnic group is considered Afghani till proved otherwise. Crime rates sky rocketed in province of this "certain ethnic group" due to influx of afghanis in 70s because a Pakistani mard-e-mujaahid from Jalandhar India was fighting yahood o nasara in Afghanistan . Kalashnikov culture, drugs, gangs, kidnapping groups, prostitution, selling daughters all came and damaged society of this "certain ethnic group".


For God sake, hear the loud screams of this certain ethnic group and deport these namak harams and never ever blame that certain ethnic group for your inability to do anything against these Afghans.

 

[HAIDER]

They will hate us even we give them whole pakistan

Sir ji ...Pakistan army need to revisit Gen Naseer ullah Baber strategy ...no carrot only a stick. They are wild animals ....you CAN T TAME them.

 

[TNT]

Well then i hope they folllw peoper course and not take money from them. Mostly it seems a topi drama. A friend sent me this poc of afghans in karachi jail. This is so shameful, then morons here wonder why afghans hate us.

 

[Tornado23]

https://twitter.com/x/status/1608890124955447298

@RescueRanger

 

[TheSolution]

You might be correct. I’m just stating my opinion as an overseas Pakistani but in my experience I have seen some Afghans who have contributed to Pakistan. But locals would know more.

Playing this game of filtering through this one and that one never works.

It becomes long, tedious and generally ineffective. Clear black and white strategy is the only solution for matters pertaining to national security.

Only have a few tiny negligible amount of them in Pakistan who's presence is significant due to business, etc. But common folk is better deported.

Well then i hope they folllw peoper course and not take money from them. Mostly it seems a topi drama. A friend sent me this poc of afghans in karachi jail. This is so shameful, then morons here wonder why afghans hate us.
View attachment 908494

The only reason they hate us is due to our very existence - has nothing to do with these on and off things here and there.

You can give them the world but your existence will still be hated.

 

[Mirzali Khan]

Playing this game of filtering through this one and that one never works.

It becomes long, tedious and generally ineffective. Clear black and white strategy is the only solution for matters pertaining to national security.

Only have a few tiny negligible amount of them in Pakistan who's presence is significant due to business, etc. But common folk is better deported.


The only reason they hate us is due to our very existence - has nothing to do with these on and off things here and there.

You can give them the world but your existence will still be hated.

Loads of Afghan diaspora buy houses in Islamabad, they obviously do it while holding a western passport but they still buy properties. Which then raises prices and local people have to start competing with people who earn in dollars, euros, and pounds.

So in that case how do you stop that?

Well then i hope they folllw peoper course and not take money from them. Mostly it seems a topi drama. A friend sent me this poc of afghans in karachi jail. This is so shameful, then morons here wonder why afghans hate us.
View attachment 908494

https://twitter.com/x/status/1608321466067734528

https://twitter.com/x/status/1601178940147499008

https://twitter.com/x/status/1608076585030254592

Name one Afghan who has contributed to Pakistan.

Afghans are improving the landscape of Balochistan:

HOW AFGHANS ARE TURNING BALOCHISTAN GREEN

Locals believe the Afghans are good at farming because of their experience in the Helmand basin area, which they helped develop.

www.dawn.com