2 die as protests flare across India over anti-Muslim comments

[jamahir]

Why would u have sympathy for poor working class muslims? U r just a hypocrite. I thought communism ensures equal rights for all working class.

You said the right thing - these are poor working class people. So why did they never join progressive movements ( the Communists ) who think, speak and agitate for the rights of the working class and seek to eliminate socio-economic classes ( very rich, rich, middle, poor ) once and for all ? Why didn't the protestors join the 2020-21 protests by farmers all over the country ? Are the farmers not working class ? Did these people speak a word of sadness when 700 farmers died during the Delhi farmers protests ? These protestors don't care for human lives lost but get highly emotional over something where they don't know the abc of including how to reply to the other party ?

 

[SuperStar20]

You said the right thing - these are poor working class people. So why did they never join progressive movements ( the Communists ) who think, speak and agitate for the rights of the working class and seek to eliminate socio-economic classes ( very rich, rich, middle, poor ) once and for all ? Why didn't the protestors join the 2020-21 protests by farmers all over the country ? Are the farmers not working class ? Did these people speak a word of sadness when 700 farmers died during the Delhi farmers protests ? These protestors don't care for human lives lost but get highly emotional over something where they don't know the abc of including how to reply to the other party ?

If the muslims in India wants to arrest and jail Nupur sharma, then the could have done sit on protest in front of district administration all over India or at least in Delhi. In 1-2 days, they could have got much support from all over India and world. Govt would have acted for sure.

Their motive looks different, what are they going to get throwing stones at police and destroying public property? These violence are also not spontaneous. They are pre planned. They are also using kids. They lost all the sympathy and credibility from normal people in India.

 

[jamahir]

If the muslims in India wants to arrest and jail Nupur sharma, then the could have done sit on protest in front of district administration all over India or at least in Delhi. In 1-2 days, they could have got much support from all over India and world. Govt would have acted for sure.

Their motive looks different, what are they going to get throwing stones at police and destroying public property? These violence are also not spontaneous. They are pre planned. They are also using kids. They lost all the sympathy and credibility from normal people in India.

Yes, they could have gone to Delhi and sat in front of Modi's residence because after all his slogan is "Sabka saath, sabka vishwaas, sabka vikaas". And they should have groomed themselves to look good by shaving off those Tableeghi beards and should have worn normal clothes instead of the Modern Indian Muslim Male ones ( white kurta pyjama and topi ). And they should have raised voice against the other atrocities in India as well. Then as you said, they would have got support from others in India and the world.

Secondly, even though I am not sympathetic with these protestors these protests were spontaneous and not planned. These things are always spontaneous with just some call-for-protest transmissions to mosques across regions. And anyone over 13 years of age is not a kid but an adult because Nature decides this, not the non-democratic Anglo political system which has arbitrarily decided that the age of 18 is the magical age when one becomes adult and sensible, as if all the 80-years-olds in Britain and India have made their societies harmonious and evolved.

 

[TNT]

You said the right thing - these are poor working class people. So why did they never join progressive movements ( the Communists ) who think, speak and agitate for the rights of the working class and seek to eliminate socio-economic classes ( very rich, rich, middle, poor ) once and for all ? Why didn't the protestors join the 2020-21 protests by farmers all over the country ? Are the farmers not working class ? Did these people speak a word of sadness when 700 farmers died during the Delhi farmers protests ? These protestors don't care for human lives lost but get highly emotional over something where they don't know the abc of including how to reply to the other party ?

The farmers werent communists either, they were protesting for their rights. You dont have to be a communist to raise voice for ur rights but being a communist, i thought ud understand their plight, instead ur asking them questions of why not this and that, shows u r a moron and a hypocrite.

 

[jamahir]

The farmers werent communists either, they were protesting for their rights. You dont have to be a communist to raise voice for ur rights but being a communist, i thought ud understand their plight, instead ur asking them questions of why not this and that, shows u r a moron and a hypocrite.

I agree that many of the protesting farmers were not Communist nor does one have to be a Communist to speak up for their rights. I agree totally. I just mentioned "Communist" because they are at the forefront of thinking, speaking and agitating for human rights. Now why I don't support these violent "Muslims" in Ranchi and other Indian cities is because of reasons I have said before. It may be that they are misinformed and misguided by listening to wrong leaders. Maybe this is a phase of indian Muslims being the green version of the Hindutvadis and so they may go back to Communist and Socialist activism like was just three decades ago. They need an example who can guide and I hope to become that guide in five years if all goes well.

Lastly, these are the farmer components of the Communist movement, joining the farmers protests of 2020-21 :