What's new

10 captives, Over 20 soldiers, including Commanding Officer killed at Galwan border clash with China

I think that we went over a tipping point yesterday. The situation is now quite unpredictable. While I still hold to my evaluation of earlier, the following things have changed - for the worse.
  1. There has been major violence.
  2. This cannot have been unplanned; these are not one or two accidental deaths.
  3. Either Beijing intended this to happen right through, OR
  4. Local commanders took matters into their own hands.
  5. The Indian political leadership has washed its hands of the situation and left it to the military leadership to sort out the problems that they created in the first place.
Now I don't want to predict anything; things have taken an ugly turn.

I don't know how the IA will react.

Even One of my friend is working in DRDO....

I spoke with him, as per his sources the situation is not good at all...but still some hopes there.

But it is confirmed that Military got go ahead approval if any such incident happen again at borders.

Previously, indian governments were not ready to engage with PLA at borders and avoiding such situations but now it about development of roads nearby borders area's with china.

China has done to stop these development and this one is their condition also but Indian government is not ready. now, it caused a major chock point between the both countries..
 
35 PLA soldiers were slaughtered .
Nobody cares what a dictatorship says .
The silence in chinese mainstream media about this incident says it all . The cbinese were slaughtered .





Actually, 350 PLA troops lost their lives and 5000 American Marines of the 101st Airborne division were slaughtered by the indian army yesterday. My indian sources informed me this morning.
 
An interesting point, and one that I have thought about, but would not have raised on my own.

Unfortunately, it seems that there is a great deal of image management going on. Deaths in the dozens do not lend themselves to being brushed under the carpet. It seems that there has been a calculated decision taken to project killling as not really amounting to killing as long as gunpowder is not in use, and that, in my reasoning, is specious. Stating that the letter has not been violated, and killing over twenty - or more - soldiers is a warlike act, whatever the methods used to kill.

Based on your posts, I assume you are at least old enough for kids, possibly grandkids? I don't know about you, but experience has tought me anything and everything can be brushed under the carpet.

If war is on the cards, a random assassination from Serbia started WW1. However, if no one wants war? America literally bombed Chinese Embassy in Belgrade, same country and nothing other than an apology happened.

If war is on the cards, no need for 20 casualties, a sneeze in the wrong direction would be enough.
 
Are you delusional? Worse thing than a clear defeat is trying to declare victory
That’s their coping mechanism like when Pakistan whopped their *** last year they came up with F16 shoot down story which the world is laughing at... they will keep repeating it like a broken record.
 
Regarding China's casualties, personally I highly doubt China suffered any major casualties.

hypothetically let's assume the information that we got from the Indian side is true, why did the GT editor declare that the Chinese will not reveal their casualties? Indians claim the Chinese are not declaring the casualties to save face so that Xi is not embarrassed in front of his people, that is false, if the Chinese would want to save face then what they should do is "lie" (again I'm assuming the Indian sources are true) and say "we have 4 dead & 17 injured", instead of saying "we have casualties but we won't declare them" which is what the GT said.

But any way, that is just my opinion, could be right & could be wrong, I would rather just wait for more news, hopefully the Chinese side will change their mind on not disclosing any numbers & decide to give us some numbers.
Def a number of wounded for sure but dead maybe not. Either way the casualties should be lighter than the Indian side by a fair margin ... Chinese troops are better equipped and are better trained in hand to hand fighting. They probably have significantly better logistics than the Indian side too ... some of the Indians died due to exposure, which should have been treated.
 
35 PLA soldiers were slaughtered .
Nobody cares what a dictatorship says .
The silence in chinese mainstream media about this incident says it all . The cbinese were slaughtered .

Nobody gets slaughtered in a hand to hand combat. Energetic Chinese troops simply wont allow you to touch them twice. indian soldiers died of fear of death alone while escaping, and of below zero temperature and of falling off the cliff. In case you didnt realize it, your claim of india and China not having a single bullet since 1962 still holds.

But the Rock of Peace has become meaningless since hand to hand fight warrants the use of rocks as projectiles.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom