Search results

So who is providing an alternate theory? I am just wondering what the thinking and rationale is at this moment in time. The brotherhood and friendship stance has been tried right, it's not as if the approach has been devoid of compassion. Btw, I do think many, the vast majority in Pakistan...

Why do so many pro Afghan Taliban arguments logically lead to pain for Pakistan, either via terrorism, crime or just plain ethno centric behaviour. Nurturing the Afghans has yielded what so far? Any notional future benefit are high risk and low probability, who disagrees?

Can we just stop fantasising about other countries doing anything, it's like the dreams of a childish mind, so many pages and comments on empty hopes and endless self pitying laments Maybe people want to hope someone else will just solve this all for them, rather than come to the realisation...

Here is a crazy idea... Muslims should hold "je suis Palestinian" and "je suis Charlie" in an ironic sort of way

In fairness it's not the worst idea, it should not be dismissed and maybe we can revisit this in the future but it's one for a few generations further down. In order for this not to make an internal mess you have to have 2 economically viable states, internally at peace with improved...

Why should afghan refugees make demands on the resources of the country over and above the citizens?I don't understand. Also, if this population requires intelligence monitoring then that is already a drain on the security services, if they are not there the burden is not there.... The other...

Thank you, a detailed response. Can you imagine the pushtun in reality wanting to share, or is it that the Punjabis have never given a chance? The problem I see is that many pashtuns actually have a deep racial hatred to Punjabis, it's not a political or economic gripe, Punjabi's do not have...

Any takers to help explain this?

I am not very familiar with this situation but is this a strategic blunder or the best of a bad set of options? I have seen anecdotally that the average pushtun has a very open and deep desire to conquer Pakistani territory as a part of a broader pushtun aim, this is harboured despite being in...

Long time dalit apostates and proud.

This is a somewhat funny diversion, maybe we should all declare ourselves as proud dalit apostates? Surely that way we are all contented. 😇

Many of you need to get real about china, Russia turkey etc

You are right, this is all very serious and I am sure very sobering inside the relevant corridors in India. It will be a shock to see that tiny Qatar, a gulf Arab country is signalling that it is willing to go so far so publicly. It's the public aspect as with Canada that is alarming for India...

Be open to the idea they may get a pardon.

pour your soul out, it's better out than in but I should suggest that pdf is not a sympathetic place to come if you need this sort of therapy, just a suggestion.

Even if the US starts becoming neutral, looks elsewhere or ambivalent that would harm India if it's somewhere the India is used to us support. Did the us support India with the Canada row? Nothing is forever, except self interest, so we are told.

Indias growth trajectory and rate of growth as a power is dependent on being geopolitically tethered to the west. China will not take you as a partner if the west is building you up to be the adversary of China, how you think that could be possible is nonsense. Do you really think western...

Qatar would not have been oblivious to their nationality, period. I don't think this will stop Indians wanting to earn the qatari dollar, in any way.

I don't believe there nationality is incidental. I don't know how or why they were chosen to begin with, but also the reason they were suspected and caught is because there is a growing consciousness in the Muslim world about what a hindutva India is turning into, and that has consequences.

So what motivation do the us have? This story harm's Israel too to an extent.